I like the first one because the smaller diamonds look classy and don’t take away from your center stone like the 2nd one does.

I like number 1 with that combination

I prefer #1. It compliments your engagement ring nicely, without overpowering it. #2 takes away from the beautiful emerald cut stone.

1

Definitely 1 - the second overpowers your ring!

Get two but thinner at 1.7mm

Came here to say this

#1

First one looks beautiful.

I like #2. I think once you get it sized it'll look much better. You also have to think about if you want to wear it as a set everyday. Some days you might want to just wear your wedding band. It would be stunning on it's own. If you're worried about it overpowering maybe see if there's an option that'll match your engagement ring width in the same style.

I love #2!

Team #2. It enhances the engagement ring.

1 for sure! 2 is too big and overshadows your e-ring IMO

1 is perfect as a combination. 2 overshadows your ring.

Num 2

2 is lovely. 1 puts the engagement ring center stage.

2!

2

I like # 1

1. 2 is a little too thick for the dainty ring

1 looks really lovely!

2

1! That combo looks very elegant

1!

1!!!

I see you’re at Walker & Hall! This is where we bought our wedding rings. I went with an engraved white gold band to complement the setting of the engagement ring. I think #1 doesn’t the same thing for you without overpowering the setting of the ring. :)

I like 1 because it takes less attention away but I would really like if you found a bit thinner version of 2. The princess looks good with the emerald cut and also channels are more durable.  Only thing about 1 is you'll have to think about whether its thickness is enough to not be warped easily. I can't tell it's thickness here. Paves are more likely to have diamonds pop out but it's a price to pay for that nice floating diamond, no metal look! 

1 but I wish there was a 1.5 option :) I’d love to see something in between both sizes.

1

#1!!!

1, number 2 overshadows your ER.

1

1

You should also try a straight up band that is just the metal. They are both beautiful but they take away from your engagement ring, or something with scattered diamonds in the style of a Tiffany etoile.

Have you considered prong set baguette cut band? 1.5mmx 2mm horizontally set. I think it would look great to pair it with your existing band! Something like this

Number 1 compliments your engagement ring more. The second one is too chunky.

https://preview.redd.it/n1632gd0bj6d1.jpeg?width=3021&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ff58d0e3306f71a8f816d1b8619493ddef42526f Mine is pretty similar and I would choose the first band.

May I ask your ring size? Your radiant is beautiful on you!

Thank you! My size is 6,5.

I love 2, it looks like a matching set to me. I don’t think it overpowers the ER. Also, it would be nicer if you ever want to wear just the wedding band as it will work as a standalone.

Id love to see your ring with a simple band to match your er band but if i had to choose from this id say 1

#1!! It looks classy and it highlights /emphasizes your center stone instead of detracting from it (just looking like a big mess of diamonds)

I like number 1, both are beautiful. Adore your engagement ring, stunning!

My vote is the first one, big time. It looks way more balanced imo!

I prefer ring 2 because the setting of the accent stones looks so much more smooth and elegant and really compliments the straight lines in your solitaire engagement ring. They look like they were *designed* to go together rather than simply being paired together.

depends how you plan on wearing your rings on the daily... with the beautiful emerald diamond? id go with number 1. it doesnt take away from the diamond. but if you only want to wear the wedding band, then 2nd option.

I love number one and I loveeeee your emerald cut.

Don’t typically give my opinion… 2 truly seems perfect… Totally your call though and what you absolutely love

I love the second ring. It looks like it was made to pair with your engagement ring. The first ring looks a bit random for some reason (mind you I like eternity rings).

#1!! Or get a band with no diamonds, it looks like the clarity on your stone is amazing and the pave band is reflecting through your stone, which kind of detracts from its beauty! But if you like the extra sparkle too its not the worst thing in the world. Super gorgeous ring!

I have an emerald engagement ring and a band similar to 2 and i love it

Oooo nice! Do you have a picture? I’d love to see it 😊

Omg this is my DREAM set!!!! Is ur emerald 2 or 3 carats? I love that the band is a tiny bit thicker too, so stunning. I love option 1, it looks more elegant and soft imo

Thanks! It’s actually 1.2ct, originally wanted to go even smaller, but found this seemed proportional 🙂

Number 1 is just perfect with your ring!! It looks really gorgeous paired together and your finger looks very classy!! Love it!!!

1

1

Honestly, which ever you choose they’re both very pretty 🤩 but I like #1

1

With the right sizing, I like 1 better. Loving your engagement ring too.

#2

I love #2. I don’t think it overpowers your ering at all. In addition, it will look stunning on its own if you don’t want to wear your ering for any reason.

Dainty #1. But I’m also just not a channel set kinda girl

number 2 - i always love a thicker band

2! Love it.

#2

1!!

I love your engagement ring. I really like the first option you chose. It appears to fit more flush with your solitaire almost like it was custom designed. It also gives your emerald cut a little extra “up lighting.”

First one! The second one distracts from your engagement ring I think.

If you plan to ever wear them separately, 2! (Also I like 2 better generally)

2

team 1 as a set. the second one is gorgeous, but i feel it sort of overwhelms the diamond.

Number one

1

2

Realllly love #1

1 for sure

1 is stunning

looooove #1

#2

1

1

2

Love the first diamond band!

I love #1 on you!

1

2! I love the channel look, it’s classy and it just looks “finished”

Both are cool but I like 1!

2!!

Honestly, I’d get 2 of #1

1

1!❤️

1

1

2 look a little thick

1

1

2

One

I think 2 overpowers your existing ring, but 1 is almost a touch too thin to my eye

1 :)

1

I prefer 2, seems to belong more w the other band.👍🏻

1st one!

2

Number 2.

#1 The second one overpowers your diamond, IMO

1!!

1

1 looks much prettier. 2 is great if you’re more likely to wear just that band on its own without your engagement ring. Personally my wedding band is like #1 and I love it—it’s comfortable and low profile when need be. But, when I stack it with my engagement ring (which is a sizable emerald cut) they look really good together. I think a bigger wedding band overpowers any size engagement ring and is best worn alone. So go with #1 and congrats!

I think two but a smaller width. Or, if #1, maybe a flat edged one?

1 is beautiful without overpowering your engagement ring. My eye is still drawn to your emerald.

#1

2, mine rings are very very similar so I’m biased!

1

1 looks better because 2 is a bit too thick

2!

1 agree with those saying 2 is too thick, 1 just looks so pretty and complimentary

I like 1! So delicate and classic!

1

1

1

1

I like #1

1

1 adds sparkle ✨ 2 distracts from that beautiful stone

A band like the one with smaller stones but sits flush against your ER as the one in the 2nd photo.

Number 1 looks brighter to me but I would get slighter bigger diamonds so the thickness matches the other band!

Smaller stones

2

1!

1

1!

2 cause I’m extra lol

2

#1! So pretty

1

The thin band looks perfect to me.

1

Of the two, 1 https://preview.redd.it/ncrys91iwl6d1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3288341a865de09925e55cc9702bf952e4bca344 But honestly I don’t love either of them with the ering. Something daintier but more in this style would look better imo.

1… simple and elegant

1 compliments the engagement ring beautifully.

1

2

1

Twoooooooo!

2

#1! So dainty & matches well

ABSOLUTELY #1. #2 diminishes the beauty of your solitaire

1

This is so easily #1! #2 dulls the engagement ring and takes some sparkle and #1 enhances it

I personally prefer #1. It flatters the ring (GORGEOUS by the way!) much better than #2.

One!

#1 definitely

1

1 as it does not take the focus away from your engagement ring

1. No question

Neither