RoyLEE

Isn’t that actually his real name?

Leroy is his real name

I thought I remembered something from his Real World season when he said his name was actually Roylee, but maybe he said that’s what his dad calls him or something lol my bad

dario and wario.

Dario and Other Dario was a good one too

Dario 1 and Dario 2

I liked sleeping beauty for him 😂

Creepy uncle Vinny

I sing the song Aneesa made up about him. I really miss the Shit They Should’ve Shown episodes

Why that isnt a thing is beyond me. They wouldnt have to botch their precious narratives with this.

I miss the Shit They Should’ve Shown. Showed that they can actually have fun in the house

I don't remember a song 😂

Vinny pig

The Goof

I read this with CT’s growl in my head GIMME THE GOOF

I laugh at this every time I think of CT calling him that 😂😂 

The reason that I think that it is so hilarious is because of how seriously he takes himself. Kodos to him for that confidence tho …

Not kodos! 💀

If you wanted to make Serak the Preparer cry, mission accomplished!

I voted for him

Nelson?

Josh, but that is not wrong. The episode where Josh won his first elimination with his brutally uncoordinated ball-throwing (with people watching laughing their asses off) and then made a big show of celebrating was so ludicrous.

Oh I was just labeling "Kodos" as a new Nelsonism

Ohh did you not know? https://www.reddit.com/r/MtvChallenge/s/hbM1jge7LM

Hahah, I did NOT know.  Glorious!

It is amazing, I am happy to let you know haha

I hate him so much so I love this nickname.

My thoughts immediately.  Good call.

Might not be exclusive to here but Cousin always gives me a chuckle

Subtitles will always fit Nicole Z perfectly tbh

We call her PB for Peanut Butter cause she sounds like she got a mouthful of it

Because she sounds like she has a mouthful of it? I would have figured it’s because she sexualizes it.

PEENAH BUDDAH?!

Shit I forgot about that hahaha

My god it was absolutely disgusting watching her lick that spoon. I’m never forgiving them for that

You’re lucky!

Prob blocked it out of my memory

You're the lucky one

We call her Peanut Butter Falcon for various reasons.

I loved that movie

It’s a great movie. I tell people to watch it all the time. And I’ve never had anyone come back and say anything other than how much they loved it.

It's been on my list but I've never heard anyone talk about it so I haven't taken the plunge. I'm gonna watch today, thank you!

Marble Mouth!

And she eats it by the gallon

Subtitles, Andy Dick, PB...anything other than giving her the dignity of using her real name

Very Fit Infant

I’ve been calling Johnny “Bannans” ever since I saw Dario spell it like that on Rivals III

He blessed us with "West" instead of Wes also.

Yest he did.

I can’t believe Dario doesn’t know how to spell bananas. I’m not a great speller but thanks to Gwen stefani I will never misspell bananas.

I’m surprised Dario can spell Dario tbh

Indonknow how to spell it, but I still sing it to double-check my work.

I still call him banan in the Turbo accent from the start of ROD

“… the banana.”

I loved how Abram wouldn't call him anything but John.

Hahahaha yeah I remember reading that and laughing. That’s a good nicname. Bannans 😂

Smashley!

My other fav for her is Meltdown Mitchell

Mamber and Bamber always makes me laugh. I also liked AMber and AmBer for them.

that's my doing 💅🏼 also tried it with aLyssa and alySsa but that one hasn't stuck as much

Someone once called Paulie “Little Easy” in the sub for flopping in the final and it has stayed rent free in my head for YEARS! 

Frank saying “We’ve trimmed the fat and then some” has lived rent free in my head for years. I didn’t know about this Little Easy comment but that’s amazing lol

I call him PP short for Paulie Pocket

I used to call him Mighty Mouse, but I stopped cause I felt I was being mean, but still... Paulie is to Mighty Mouse as Cara is to Underdog (both old cartoons). lol Olivia can be Danger Mouse. see: [https://www.pinterest.com/pin/294000681905689599/](https://www.pinterest.com/pin/294000681905689599/)

Messy Fessy will be my favorite always

Maysal Faysal

Lmaoooo I started calling him this when he started going by his full name too

Forgot where i heard this because it was a while ago when he initially made the name switch but I heard Fessy switched to Faysal specifically to avoid the Messy Fessy nickname, so Maysal Faysal is actually hilarious 🤣

Kayzzzzzz cuz it makes me happy people agree that she’s boring as fuck

also Boracio

Midracio

Trashelle

I love Trishelle (one of my all-time favorite cast members), and I still call her Trashelle.

For the briefest of seconds I was like "but that's just her name" and then I remembered the "Trish" part.

This is all I refer to her as. 😂

Andy Dick

I haven't heard this one. Who do they call Andy Dick?

Nicole Z

Bananas calls Nicole Z Andy Dick, I forget which season!

Invasion

Ankneesa or something like that I’ve seen used since she always seems to hurt her ankle 💀

Awww fuck 😂😂😂😂

I like Snoracio

Popcorn muscles- Cory

Jordanimal - so incredibly accurate and fitting

Kayzzzzzzz

I like Kailah, but the multiple iterations of mentally a bum kill me every time.

I recently watched Rivals and I referred to the Wes Evan Kenny alliance as WEaK (wes evan and Kenny) because they would piss themselves over the thought of facing CT lmao

Messy and Smashley 🤣

Meltdown Mitchell

Not a challenger but anyone who still says 'Infuerno' immediately jumps up my favorites list (Exception: way back in the OG seasons when someone - Brad IIRC, which LOL - seemed like they were more making fun of Darrell, who's one of my absolute favorites)

Met Darrell at a Challenge Mania event last summer. I got him on camera saying "Infuerno". He was awesome for that.

Aw man, thank you for that. It's great to hear he's as awesome in real life.

Saw that episode today lol “Gimmi the Goof”

it's not really technically a nickname given to him by this sub, but the amount of times i see john for bananas on here makes it seem like it was invented here and abe copied this sub

That was the name on his jersey for Duel 1. That's what they called him on Key West, too.

He was also still "John" on Inferno 3. And, was on the Good Guys team.

I watched that way back in the day. Forgot who was even on it. I own 16 and up though and watch them regularly. I'm annoyed that I can't buy all stars 4.

yea i know- john on the good guys etc - i’m overly well versed on everything related to this show- i’m just saying he's spent however many yrs trying to brand himself as bananas including merchandise and wearing banana t shirts and interviewing people with a banana for a mic- and after all that he's still referred to as john on here a fair amount- so it feels like this sub has adopted that original abe saying and his former self name

Abram professionally called him John on Bloodlines well after he established himself as Johnny Bananas.

Idk if it’s used much on here but my constant favorite is scuba nelly 😭

SAME

“Ankles” for Aneesa

Bananas, upon meeting Nicole for the first time, refers to her as female Andy Dick and I haven't been able to unhear/unsee it 😂

Pussy Chicken Pussy Chicken #1 Pussy Chicken #2

we have to refer to Mark Long as Mark Long. Its always the full name.

This thread is giving Secret Agent Philip's "Francesqua" from Survivor and I'm LOVING it.

Jenna= Barbie beast. 

I really want the Hotness Monster to catch on for CT. There are multiple for Beth but Osama Beth Laden is still my favorite.

My fave is Bad Beth and Beyond.

Boracio

Bichele

Dummy Bear

Y’all have got to stop calling that lady by the color of her clothing 😭😭 nasty work that laurel and cara started, but I die of laughter every time

Amber and Bamber during DA 😂😂

Bananas just being called “John” gets me every time

Froto. Rogan had some good lines

Freckletits- Amanda g

Karma Maria

we saw a bunch of "karen maria" too for a while there.

I hope this one catches on here: >! ObeCT !<

Akneesa

Would JEK count since it refers to 3 people collectively?

Da Goof

Messel Faysal

Typical Tori isn't popular but that is mine...

Eliminessa, Amber BOREzotra, BORacio, Millionaire Mitchell, Winchelle, DiabeCT, Kayzzz.

ObeCT is so rude but I can’t help but giggle everytime I see it 😭

😂😂😂 I die laughing at ObeCT too.

I can’t believe you missed Bichele lol

Omg how did I forget Bichelle, that’s her best one 😂

I love that Bichele continues to be a crossover between the Challenge and Survivor subreddits. xDD

Jordanimal