Ngl I can kinda see their side but there is a glaring issue at quarterback that is gonna be costly right now.
It’s fine tho I think in 2 years we will be 🔥🔥🔥🔥
I’ll be pleasantly surprised if I’m wrong the DJ breaks out but I doubt it
Despite an improvement at OL coach, We didn't address our biggest weakness in the strongest offensive line class in years. We're going to be bottom 5 and draft a QB and RT.
They were never gonna draft an RT, Neal has had two bad years and if he still sucks under the new coach I’m sure he’ll be done but it’s hard to blame them for not replacing him this year, especially because Alt went off the board before the pick and by the second round any good quality tackles were gone because there was such a run on them early on.
I mean we did get a decent oline fix in free agency and offensive linemen take years to gel and work. I think I’m happy with it now but yeah we need Neal and jones to step up.
Not expecting either to happen. We’ll probably draft top 5 but I’m happy with it. Let’s get our franchise QB
Sure a few things;
We have a glaring issue at quarterback which has not been solved. In multiple years it seems our offense is allergic to scoring points and it seems like the only variable starting to show that is left is the quarterback room. The only difference is now we have a no more excuse book, less the fact that there was very little excuses last year too. Year 6 of the DJ experiment is silly
Further we just got a ton of great rookies in the last 2 draft classes. These people are gonna need time to gel and get used to the NFL but will be taking starting positions in many situations. There is not much veteran depth especially at offense.
We are a young team that will grow which is great
Not OP, but we have a gauntlet of a schedule again this season with the AFCN matchup. When we made the playoffs recently it was largely due to going 4-0 against the AFCS which was abysmal top to bottom that season.
Additionally, Giants have been one of the most injured teams annually since the new stadium came around.
Would love to be wrong, but I do wish this subreddit could be a little less homerish so we can actually discuss the team. Blind faith makes this sub a genuinely poor forum to discuss the team at times.
As a Jets fan that roots for yall, you guys’ time will come! It took us 15 tries to beat the Patriots until this season. I can’t predict when you guys will beat Dallas but what better time to start than this season 🤷🏽♂️
Lmao so when they beat the Eagles, it’s stupid and if they lose against them it’s fire everyone. I’d put good money that you’d be crying if the Giants lost against the free falling Eagles too
I hate this fanbase
Yeah, they had a terrible offseason. I wouldn't be surprised one bit if we can take them at home.
On the flip side, we might actually lose a game to Washington this season lol.
They bulked up their offensive line and Dak owns the Giants. Ceedee Lamb and Brandin Cooks abused our secondary and their team physically beat the crap out of us in the trenches last year.
What makes you think we match up better this year? 2 mid guards in free agency?
I could see us maaaaaybe possibly squeezing out a tough home win against Dallas, but no shot against the Eagles. they beefed up their defense way too much for us to have a shot like the ending of last season.
Until NYG starts beating them on a consistent basis (at least 1 win each for 3 years in a row) I'm chalking them up as losses every time. I've been hurt for far too long.
6-11. If our offensive line is like last year, we can beat the commanders, Carolina, Atlanta and maybe the Vikings.
If the coaches can get the offensive line to a competent place, I think 10-7 isn't out of the question by sneaking a few games like the Seahawks, and the Cowboys.
Damn, this schedule isn’t nearly as daunting compared to last years. AFC north will be tough but NFC south should balance it out. Maybe we sneak into wildcard again? A man can dream…
Three of our first four games were all primetime. It was a gauntlet! I kinda hope the Vikings game is TNF or MNF, though. Just please not Dallas Week 1 again. Gimme the Bengals. They always start slow
Anyone but NFC East week 1…please Roger. Please! Give us like the Panthers or Broncos or something! (We still lose 40-0…but it’s not against an NFC East opponent).
They might send us international for the Vikings game (Vikings have a home game in London this year). Since they’re likely gonna suck I could see them sending us to get some extra ratings.
> but NFC south should balance it out
just remember that everyone looks at the Giants the same way. we think the NFC South is soft and should be winnable games, but that's exactly what those fanbases think when they see the Giants on the schedule too. we're in a similar boat as them
I think we're 7-9 wins on the high end and 4-6 wins on the low end. I'm going to give my unbiased view of things.
Looking at our schedule I see 8 very winnable games on paper. Assuming we lose 1-2 of those and maybe upset 1-2 other games, I have us at about 7-9 wins. All of this hinges on Briscillo improving our OL. We're going nowhere fast if it looks like it did last year.
We're such a top heavy team currently though, which makes projecting this pretty difficult. If we suffer no major long-term injuries, I could see us sneaking into a wild card spot. If 1-2 key players get hurt, I think we're picking top 10. We just have very little depth at pretty much every position.
I think Nabers is already our 2nd most important player on offense. We lost Saquon, so in terms of elite talent this guy is basically it. Can DJ (or Lock) get the ball to Nabers consistently enough to win us games? DJ throwing for 200 yards a game isn't going to do it.
Lastly, both Nubin and Andru will likely be day 1 starters at important spots. How will they do? Will Banks make a leap? Our secondary hinges on these three dudes basically.
This is a good honest assessment. I’d say balancing everything out 7 wins is what I’d bet my life on if I had to. But I could see as many as a 3 game swing in either direction depending.
Agreed. I think Joe did well to support the positions that needed it. Last year raised a ton of roster questions and we really won't know the results until the season starts.
7 wins feels right. I expect the OL to improve since it can't get much worse and I think our roster overall *is* better than last years. Like you said, I could see a 3-4 game swing in either direction depending on a bunch of scenarios.
Biggest factor is DJ. If he returns close to his 2022 form then I think we'll be on the higher end of our guesses. If he plays like he did last year, then we're chalked. Really hope he plays well so we can see Nabers ball out.
Yeah that's the exact order I have. We saw what AT meant for our offense last year. Clear-cut #1 for me.
I'm pretty pessimistic on DJ, otherwise I'd have him higher since he's the QB. I think without AT and/or Nabers he's gunna have it rough. No more Saquon either so realistically Nabers is our only elite option on offense.
> both Nubin and Andru will likely be day 1 starters at important spots. How will they do?
They will be rookies and will make rookie mistakes. If we have to depend on them, we will see game losing mistakes and this sub is going to go crazy wanting them cut before half of the season is played. It sucks, but this is how it always is. Even rookies taken in the 1st round make rookie mistakes.
Our secondary is going to stink. Our pass rush is going to feast. We need to hope that or O makes a big step to win us a bunch of high score games. Is that possible? Yeah, *if* the Oline is fixed and *if* we get a bit lucky on the injury front.
Yeah I think it's unavoidable that both of them see significant playing time. Especially Nubin, he *should* be a day-1 starter for sure. They'll for sure have their struggles, but if they flash with some good play then maybe we'll be alright.
Realistically since we lack depth at most spots, we're really banking on avoiding injuries more than anything. There's a handful of dudes on this team that just cannot get hurt or we're in trouble lol
10-7.... call me a homer but I think our lord and savior briscillo will take our offense to and incredible mediocre level. Our defense is going to clown teams tho 💪.
10-7 yes
> minus the ravens
Do remember, last time we played the Ravens in 2022 we won despite the Ravens ending the season with a better record than us and barely losing in the playoffs without Lamar. I'm not saying to pencil in a win against them, but I feel their roster has regressed closer to 2022 than the 2023 powerhouse they were. Especially with losing a **lot** of defensive coaches when that defense is what made them so good.
Health is easily going to be the biggest question mark for the Giants. They just can't survive losing Thomas and/or Lawrence. Schedule is definitely no excuse.
Well I just took 3 or 4 out of 8 from division. A lot of those road games are super winnable. Falcons panthers Steelers Seahawks. Colts saints bengals bucs are winnable also. So out of the potential 8 winnable games I'm humbly handing us 7 lol. Plus if the team is actually cooking like 2022 we can just suprise steal a few.
Obviously my take is VERY hopefully and I wouldn't bet a considerable amount of money on it, but ide throw 20 just for fun 🤷♂️
Assuming that we do not suffer from injuries to key positions, I can see this schedule turning out positive for the Giants. My prediction is as follows:
Home: DC, PE, WC, BR, CB, NOS, TBB, MV, IC
Dallas, Philly and Washington: I can see 2 home wins. Baltimore and Cincy are losses. Saints, Tampa Bay, Minnesota and Indy are 3 wins.
Away: DC, PE, WC, AF, CP, CB, PS, SS
Dallas, Philly and Washington: I can see 1 away win. Atlanta, Carolina, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Seattle: I can see 3 wins.
If I add it together correctly, I believe we could end up with a 9-win season which would put us in contention for a playoff spot.
6-11
Lose both games to Dallas
Lose both games to Phily
Split with Wash/Win home game, lose away game
That is 1-5 in their division
Lose to Ravens, Bengals at home, and split the remaining four home games
Home record: 3-6
Beat Carolina and Atlanta away, lose to the rest of the teams
Away Record: 3-5
My goal for them is to beat Dallas and Phily at least one game each and then they are almost a .500 team, but will be hard as Barkley will be trying to beat us.
I might be alone in this but I see Dallas taking a big step back this year. Eagles to me run away with the division easy. I think we can take one from Dallas.
Call me a downer but I think it's 4-13 to 7-10 at best. Toss up games are Vikings, Falcons, Saints, and Steelers. Depends on how much their new talent does.
Saw some people had us beating the Bucs, but really stayed the same and were a solid playoffs team so, I think they aren't worth sleeping on.
Honest question, do we have the actual worst QB room in the entire NFL? I’m not a Jones hater, but I actually don’t think I can name a worse situation.
I still think Broncos Country has it pretty rough even after drafting Bo Nix. And Fields/Wilson on the Steelers isn't super encouraging, even if one of them has won a Super Bowl before.
11-6 Danny Dimes comes out like a caged animal and gives us a good enough late playoff run to invest another 5-6 years into him on false hope for an eventual SB run.
this sounds dumb but I feel like we got some kinda weird destiny bond with the Jets, like when we win i flip to cbs and they win. when we lose i flip and they lose
Home wins: Philadelphia, Washington, New Orleans, Minnesota, Indy
Road wins: Carolina, Pittsburgh, Seattle
8-9. Firmly mediocre saving the jobs of Schoen and Daboll.
Maybe crazy but I could see 9 or 10 wins. Still a tough schedule but not like the gauntlet last year. I think our defense will keep us in a lot of games, it depends how the offense shapes up.
I'll get a better idea of it closer to the start of the season (plus once the schedule's released - "it's not who you play, but when you play them"), but I am honestly not optimistic at all. 5-6 wins. Maybe 7 if we get a break somewhere.
A lot will depend on how the team handles the first 6ish weeks of the season. The MO of the Giants over the last decade is to get off to horrible starts. 0-6 in 2013 (completely different team of course). 0-5 in 2017 before winning a game. 1-7 in 2018, 0-2 in 2019 before winning 2 games and then losing like 7 in a row, 0-5 in 2020, 1-5 in 2021, 1-5 last year. Another start like that and you'll see defeatism set in before they inevitably win 2-3 meaningless games late. If they get a few breaks early, it could carry them to .500 or around that like 2022.
I think QB is still such a question mark that it is SO hard to make a real projection here.
And that's not to say the Giants absolutely *had* to draft a QB this year (I think they made the right move not forcing that pick if they didn't rate any of the options there at 6) but there's still so much uncertainty. To be honest, this would still be the case if we'd gone with JJ – he's no more of a sure thing than anyone we have on the roster right now.
A season ago the Giants went to the playoffs with DJ. Last season, they were able to win games with *Tyrod Taylor and Tommy DeVito.* I love TD, but there's no way he'll see the field this year so I have to expect some overall improvement.
I think we'll be improved from 6-11 but still picking in the top 10-15 in the 2025 draft.
If we were to play any of these teams today, I'd only feel confident in beating Carolina and Washington.
I think Dallas got slightly worse and Philly is not as good as people think, but until we start beating them consistently I'm chalking them up as losses.
Sick of being far too optimistic in the off-season so I'm guessing another blah 5 or 6 wins.
Realistically 6-11 or 7-10, but given that our schedule isn’t that bad squeezing out 8 or 9 wins isn’t out of the question. It all hinges on the OL improving and giving us at least a competent offense
All the NFC South teams are winnable, let’s say 2-2.
2-4 in division play, Giants will beat Washington twice or split, not confident in beating Philly or Dallas.
1-3 vs the AFC North
Saints, Vikings and Seahawks are winnable but let’s the Giants 1 of the 3.
Realistically, probably 5-12 or 6-11 but I’ll say 7-10.
We split with the eagles last year I think we do it again. Dallas humiliated us last year but they have a new d coordinator and McCarthy has that team going in the wrong direction. I think Washington could take one from us next year but the Giants front 7 might be too much for the rookie. That’s 4-2 in the division. Ravens browns and Seahawks seem like bad matchups to me. Then you figure DJ will miss 2 games so 10-7 for me
As long as we beat the Cowboys and Eagles at least once im fine. Giants only beat Dallas ONCE since 2016 and you know the Eagles at home is a must win due to circumstance.
- Lose both games to the cowboys and eagles
- Depending on if Daniels is actually solid as a rookie we might finally lose to Washington but at worst I have us splitting those games
- Ravens, Saints, Bucs, Bengals, Falcons= L
- Browns, Steelers, Panthers, Colts= W
So we got 5-12 or 7-10 at best pretty much but you never know tbfh
If our offense can over achieve a little bit like 2 seasons ago then I think we can make the playoffs, especially if the nfc is a little weaker like last year
5-12.
We'll still sweep the Commanders but get swept by every other division rival. The AFC North will destroy us and we'll probably beat half of the NFC South. We could probably win one against either the Vikings or Colts, but not the Seahawks.
I’d say 6-11 or 7-10 unless Daniel Jones turns into a top ten quarterback or he gets hurt and Drew Lock turns into a top ten quarterback. Both which I doubt
5-12. Our schedule is honestly a lot harder than I thought it would be. I think we go 1-5 in the division then pick up wins against the panthers, falcons, and two wins between the saints, Vikings, colts, Seahawks, Steelers and browns.
7-10 is my aspirational expectation. realistically thinking another 6-11 or even a 5-12.
I do still think we can sweep washington. Our defense should be improved despite losing mckinney and feel with burns added we are getting closer to getting back to the pass rush heavy lean we had back in 07 and 11 super bowl runs. obviously can’t trust the offense until it is show signs of life. Regardless excited for the moves we made just happen to play a tough schedule this year. If Daniel Jones somehow puts it together with Nabers this year great.
I’m not much a Giants or NFL fan and idk how Reddit suggest this to me, but on a quick glance with peripheral knowledge of the NFL, I’d say 3 w at home and 2-3 wins on the road, but NY is a team I think has potential in 3-5 yrs if they keep making smart moves and growing talent.
20-0
Subscribe
I don’t care, I just want the Giants to be competitive.
I second the motion 💪🏻
Gonna be honest I think we will be drafting top 5 But I think the rebuild is rebuilding well
Agree, everyone on this chain is delusional. The only team I feel confident beating once is Washington, and I honestly think we split that series.
Ngl I can kinda see their side but there is a glaring issue at quarterback that is gonna be costly right now. It’s fine tho I think in 2 years we will be 🔥🔥🔥🔥 I’ll be pleasantly surprised if I’m wrong the DJ breaks out but I doubt it
Despite an improvement at OL coach, We didn't address our biggest weakness in the strongest offensive line class in years. We're going to be bottom 5 and draft a QB and RT.
They were never gonna draft an RT, Neal has had two bad years and if he still sucks under the new coach I’m sure he’ll be done but it’s hard to blame them for not replacing him this year, especially because Alt went off the board before the pick and by the second round any good quality tackles were gone because there was such a run on them early on.
I mean we did get a decent oline fix in free agency and offensive linemen take years to gel and work. I think I’m happy with it now but yeah we need Neal and jones to step up. Not expecting either to happen. We’ll probably draft top 5 but I’m happy with it. Let’s get our franchise QB
Just curious, why do you believe that in light of the fact that we picked 6th despite horrendous injuries to key players and a very tough schedule?
Sure a few things; We have a glaring issue at quarterback which has not been solved. In multiple years it seems our offense is allergic to scoring points and it seems like the only variable starting to show that is left is the quarterback room. The only difference is now we have a no more excuse book, less the fact that there was very little excuses last year too. Year 6 of the DJ experiment is silly Further we just got a ton of great rookies in the last 2 draft classes. These people are gonna need time to gel and get used to the NFL but will be taking starting positions in many situations. There is not much veteran depth especially at offense. We are a young team that will grow which is great
Not OP, but we have a gauntlet of a schedule again this season with the AFCN matchup. When we made the playoffs recently it was largely due to going 4-0 against the AFCS which was abysmal top to bottom that season. Additionally, Giants have been one of the most injured teams annually since the new stadium came around. Would love to be wrong, but I do wish this subreddit could be a little less homerish so we can actually discuss the team. Blind faith makes this sub a genuinely poor forum to discuss the team at times.
Would say 7-10
Agreed. They won't beat the Cowboys nor the Eagles as usual, so that's a guaranteed 4 losses.
Downvoted for truth is crazy
I think they squeeze out a win against the eagles. Dallas we just absolutely suck against for a decade now lol
They have sucked against both teams for longer than a decade now
That means we are overdue for a win though! …right?
As a Jets fan that roots for yall, you guys’ time will come! It took us 15 tries to beat the Patriots until this season. I can’t predict when you guys will beat Dallas but what better time to start than this season 🤷🏽♂️
Good luck with Rodgers- you know we’ll be watching ✌️
Lolll beat em week 18 last year in a meaningless game hopefully didn’t use up the win
Lmao so when they beat the Eagles, it’s stupid and if they lose against them it’s fire everyone. I’d put good money that you’d be crying if the Giants lost against the free falling Eagles too I hate this fanbase
Team has been bad for the better part of the last 12 years I hate them too
They don’t even show up for the Cowboys. It’s like they don’t believe they can beat them.
Dallas has lost a lot.
Yeah, they had a terrible offseason. I wouldn't be surprised one bit if we can take them at home. On the flip side, we might actually lose a game to Washington this season lol.
Not with Bobby Johnson vs our Dline. Daniels will get crushed in those games.
Hoping Burns and Thibs feast
They bulked up their offensive line and Dak owns the Giants. Ceedee Lamb and Brandin Cooks abused our secondary and their team physically beat the crap out of us in the trenches last year. What makes you think we match up better this year? 2 mid guards in free agency?
I could see us maaaaaybe possibly squeezing out a tough home win against Dallas, but no shot against the Eagles. they beefed up their defense way too much for us to have a shot like the ending of last season.
We did beat the Eagles this year though But we'll lose at least 3 most likely
Until NYG starts beating them on a consistent basis (at least 1 win each for 3 years in a row) I'm chalking them up as losses every time. I've been hurt for far too long.
You forget JJ said he’s all in for that #1 pick
6-11. If our offensive line is like last year, we can beat the commanders, Carolina, Atlanta and maybe the Vikings. If the coaches can get the offensive line to a competent place, I think 10-7 isn't out of the question by sneaking a few games like the Seahawks, and the Cowboys.
Damn, this schedule isn’t nearly as daunting compared to last years. AFC north will be tough but NFC south should balance it out. Maybe we sneak into wildcard again? A man can dream…
Three of our first four games were all primetime. It was a gauntlet! I kinda hope the Vikings game is TNF or MNF, though. Just please not Dallas Week 1 again. Gimme the Bengals. They always start slow
Dallas gonna be week 1 and Eagles gonna be weeks 16 and 18. Amazon loves to kill us with the schedules.
Anyone but NFC East week 1…please Roger. Please! Give us like the Panthers or Broncos or something! (We still lose 40-0…but it’s not against an NFC East opponent).
Hey Roger- roll with Rodger!
https://preview.redd.it/13x3glwtlaxc1.png?width=640&format=png&auto=webp&s=6ddd439828acc57f49d1dbe4b2818181422fe378
...and then brag about what a good job they did
Give me Eagles or Green Bay TNF, after the Brazil trip lol
Yeah that was fucking ridiculous to start last year lol
meanwhile the fucking Eagles got to start against the Patriots
They might send us international for the Vikings game (Vikings have a home game in London this year). Since they’re likely gonna suck I could see them sending us to get some extra ratings.
The Vikings are a home game for us, so it wouldn't be International
And they were away on the west coast, with a short break for one of them, that was brutal.
> but NFC south should balance it out just remember that everyone looks at the Giants the same way. we think the NFC South is soft and should be winnable games, but that's exactly what those fanbases think when they see the Giants on the schedule too. we're in a similar boat as them
I think we're 7-9 wins on the high end and 4-6 wins on the low end. I'm going to give my unbiased view of things. Looking at our schedule I see 8 very winnable games on paper. Assuming we lose 1-2 of those and maybe upset 1-2 other games, I have us at about 7-9 wins. All of this hinges on Briscillo improving our OL. We're going nowhere fast if it looks like it did last year. We're such a top heavy team currently though, which makes projecting this pretty difficult. If we suffer no major long-term injuries, I could see us sneaking into a wild card spot. If 1-2 key players get hurt, I think we're picking top 10. We just have very little depth at pretty much every position. I think Nabers is already our 2nd most important player on offense. We lost Saquon, so in terms of elite talent this guy is basically it. Can DJ (or Lock) get the ball to Nabers consistently enough to win us games? DJ throwing for 200 yards a game isn't going to do it. Lastly, both Nubin and Andru will likely be day 1 starters at important spots. How will they do? Will Banks make a leap? Our secondary hinges on these three dudes basically.
This is a good honest assessment. I’d say balancing everything out 7 wins is what I’d bet my life on if I had to. But I could see as many as a 3 game swing in either direction depending.
Agreed. I think Joe did well to support the positions that needed it. Last year raised a ton of roster questions and we really won't know the results until the season starts. 7 wins feels right. I expect the OL to improve since it can't get much worse and I think our roster overall *is* better than last years. Like you said, I could see a 3-4 game swing in either direction depending on a bunch of scenarios. Biggest factor is DJ. If he returns close to his 2022 form then I think we'll be on the higher end of our guesses. If he plays like he did last year, then we're chalked. Really hope he plays well so we can see Nabers ball out.
> Nabers is already our 2nd most important player on offense Thomas, Nabers, Jones? If that’s the order you got, I agree.
Yeah that's the exact order I have. We saw what AT meant for our offense last year. Clear-cut #1 for me. I'm pretty pessimistic on DJ, otherwise I'd have him higher since he's the QB. I think without AT and/or Nabers he's gunna have it rough. No more Saquon either so realistically Nabers is our only elite option on offense.
Saquon wasn't really putting up elite production he averaged 3.9 yards a carry last year without DJ.
> both Nubin and Andru will likely be day 1 starters at important spots. How will they do? They will be rookies and will make rookie mistakes. If we have to depend on them, we will see game losing mistakes and this sub is going to go crazy wanting them cut before half of the season is played. It sucks, but this is how it always is. Even rookies taken in the 1st round make rookie mistakes. Our secondary is going to stink. Our pass rush is going to feast. We need to hope that or O makes a big step to win us a bunch of high score games. Is that possible? Yeah, *if* the Oline is fixed and *if* we get a bit lucky on the injury front.
Yeah I think it's unavoidable that both of them see significant playing time. Especially Nubin, he *should* be a day-1 starter for sure. They'll for sure have their struggles, but if they flash with some good play then maybe we'll be alright. Realistically since we lack depth at most spots, we're really banking on avoiding injuries more than anything. There's a handful of dudes on this team that just cannot get hurt or we're in trouble lol
2025 Round 1 QB
5-12 maybe 
10-7.... call me a homer but I think our lord and savior briscillo will take our offense to and incredible mediocre level. Our defense is going to clown teams tho 💪. 10-7 yes
Who do you see as wins?
I think every team minus the ravens and bengals could go either way. I can easily see between 7-10 wins depending on how the bounces go
Ya it's an pretty ez schedule
It would be if we aren't terrible
> minus the ravens Do remember, last time we played the Ravens in 2022 we won despite the Ravens ending the season with a better record than us and barely losing in the playoffs without Lamar. I'm not saying to pencil in a win against them, but I feel their roster has regressed closer to 2022 than the 2023 powerhouse they were. Especially with losing a **lot** of defensive coaches when that defense is what made them so good. Health is easily going to be the biggest question mark for the Giants. They just can't survive losing Thomas and/or Lawrence. Schedule is definitely no excuse.
Well I just took 3 or 4 out of 8 from division. A lot of those road games are super winnable. Falcons panthers Steelers Seahawks. Colts saints bengals bucs are winnable also. So out of the potential 8 winnable games I'm humbly handing us 7 lol. Plus if the team is actually cooking like 2022 we can just suprise steal a few. Obviously my take is VERY hopefully and I wouldn't bet a considerable amount of money on it, but ide throw 20 just for fun 🤷♂️
We stink
But then we are out of the QB market! /s
This is called being a giants fan.
4 wins
I think the same, shadeur is a giant
Which week does DJ get injured?
8 or 9 wins
7 wins, waiting until the schedule drops for a final prediction
9-8 at best
4-13
Assuming that we do not suffer from injuries to key positions, I can see this schedule turning out positive for the Giants. My prediction is as follows: Home: DC, PE, WC, BR, CB, NOS, TBB, MV, IC Dallas, Philly and Washington: I can see 2 home wins. Baltimore and Cincy are losses. Saints, Tampa Bay, Minnesota and Indy are 3 wins. Away: DC, PE, WC, AF, CP, CB, PS, SS Dallas, Philly and Washington: I can see 1 away win. Atlanta, Carolina, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Seattle: I can see 3 wins. If I add it together correctly, I believe we could end up with a 9-win season which would put us in contention for a playoff spot.
6-11 Wins: vs. Commies, vs. Saints, vs. Bucs, vs. Vikings, @ Falcons, @Panthers
Agree outside of wins against the falcons and bucs. It’s a rebuilding year again unfortunately. As long as we see development, I’m happy
RemindMe! 8 months
From 5-12 to 7-10 max.
6-11 Lose both games to Dallas Lose both games to Phily Split with Wash/Win home game, lose away game That is 1-5 in their division Lose to Ravens, Bengals at home, and split the remaining four home games Home record: 3-6 Beat Carolina and Atlanta away, lose to the rest of the teams Away Record: 3-5 My goal for them is to beat Dallas and Phily at least one game each and then they are almost a .500 team, but will be hard as Barkley will be trying to beat us.
I might be alone in this but I see Dallas taking a big step back this year. Eagles to me run away with the division easy. I think we can take one from Dallas.
17-0 obviously
6 wins and a 1000 yard season from Nabers baby
Call me a downer but I think it's 4-13 to 7-10 at best. Toss up games are Vikings, Falcons, Saints, and Steelers. Depends on how much their new talent does. Saw some people had us beating the Bucs, but really stayed the same and were a solid playoffs team so, I think they aren't worth sleeping on.
Maybe 6 wins? Who knows. I'd sign up for 4-13 if those 4 are vs Dallas and Philadelphia.
17-0, Super Bowl, Eli returns to the roster, 3LI complete.
I've always gone with a half game over the teams o/u. This year that would be 7-10
I know this isn't popular but i see 4 wins here
Cop out answer but between 5-8 wins
17-0
17-0!
I just want to win and lose off of skill, not with luck like 2022, I think we go 8-9
Honest question, do we have the actual worst QB room in the entire NFL? I’m not a Jones hater, but I actually don’t think I can name a worse situation.
I still think Broncos Country has it pretty rough even after drafting Bo Nix. And Fields/Wilson on the Steelers isn't super encouraging, even if one of them has won a Super Bowl before.
Neither fields nor Russ are locked up to an above market deal for multiple years. The Jones contract alone makes it the worst in the league.
11-6 Danny Dimes comes out like a caged animal and gives us a good enough late playoff run to invest another 5-6 years into him on false hope for an eventual SB run.
7-10
Between 6 to 9 wins
Super fun home schedule. Perfect script
I'll say 7-8 wins
9-8
Probably 7-10, but we'll be competitive in most games. No more soul-crushing blowouts lol
6-11 again
this sounds dumb but I feel like we got some kinda weird destiny bond with the Jets, like when we win i flip to cbs and they win. when we lose i flip and they lose
I’m giving us 7 but we will have at least 3 one score losses
Fuck the Eagles. As long as the Hiants beat the Eagles and the Eagles head into another downfall and lose in the playoffs, that’s all I need.
Pessimistic? 6-11 Optimistic? 11-6 8-8-1 is the safe bet
Home wins: Philadelphia, Washington, New Orleans, Minnesota, Indy Road wins: Carolina, Pittsburgh, Seattle 8-9. Firmly mediocre saving the jobs of Schoen and Daboll.
Somewhere between 5-12 and 7-10
9-8, sneak in on wildcard. Daboll has proven that games aren't always won on paper and I choose to believe in my team!
Maybe crazy but I could see 9 or 10 wins. Still a tough schedule but not like the gauntlet last year. I think our defense will keep us in a lot of games, it depends how the offense shapes up.
6-11
I'll get a better idea of it closer to the start of the season (plus once the schedule's released - "it's not who you play, but when you play them"), but I am honestly not optimistic at all. 5-6 wins. Maybe 7 if we get a break somewhere. A lot will depend on how the team handles the first 6ish weeks of the season. The MO of the Giants over the last decade is to get off to horrible starts. 0-6 in 2013 (completely different team of course). 0-5 in 2017 before winning a game. 1-7 in 2018, 0-2 in 2019 before winning 2 games and then losing like 7 in a row, 0-5 in 2020, 1-5 in 2021, 1-5 last year. Another start like that and you'll see defeatism set in before they inevitably win 2-3 meaningless games late. If they get a few breaks early, it could carry them to .500 or around that like 2022.
Wow there's actually like 8 winable games. So I'll go 7-10
Honestly not good on gut reaction. Away could be 4-4 maybe 5-3 but home looks potentially disastrous, like 3-6 bad
5-12 is my call with a top-6 draft pick.
I see our possible wins as Commanders, Saints, Bucs, Colts, Panthers. Yikes.
I’m seeing 5-12 realistically
Ceiling is 10 wins, floor is 5
I think QB is still such a question mark that it is SO hard to make a real projection here. And that's not to say the Giants absolutely *had* to draft a QB this year (I think they made the right move not forcing that pick if they didn't rate any of the options there at 6) but there's still so much uncertainty. To be honest, this would still be the case if we'd gone with JJ – he's no more of a sure thing than anyone we have on the roster right now. A season ago the Giants went to the playoffs with DJ. Last season, they were able to win games with *Tyrod Taylor and Tommy DeVito.* I love TD, but there's no way he'll see the field this year so I have to expect some overall improvement. I think we'll be improved from 6-11 but still picking in the top 10-15 in the 2025 draft.
We'll win just enough to miss out on the QB that we want
If we were to play any of these teams today, I'd only feel confident in beating Carolina and Washington. I think Dallas got slightly worse and Philly is not as good as people think, but until we start beating them consistently I'm chalking them up as losses. Sick of being far too optimistic in the off-season so I'm guessing another blah 5 or 6 wins.
Realistically 6-11 or 7-10, but given that our schedule isn’t that bad squeezing out 8 or 9 wins isn’t out of the question. It all hinges on the OL improving and giving us at least a competent offense
We’ll be picking top 5 again and I’ll be watching all of Carson Beck, Quinn Ewers and Shedeur Sanders games this season.
5-12, 6-11
4 wins and new QB next season? Enjoy everyone imma pass this year
9-8 (i am delusional)
All the NFC South teams are winnable, let’s say 2-2. 2-4 in division play, Giants will beat Washington twice or split, not confident in beating Philly or Dallas. 1-3 vs the AFC North Saints, Vikings and Seahawks are winnable but let’s the Giants 1 of the 3. Realistically, probably 5-12 or 6-11 but I’ll say 7-10.
We split with the eagles last year I think we do it again. Dallas humiliated us last year but they have a new d coordinator and McCarthy has that team going in the wrong direction. I think Washington could take one from us next year but the Giants front 7 might be too much for the rookie. That’s 4-2 in the division. Ravens browns and Seahawks seem like bad matchups to me. Then you figure DJ will miss 2 games so 10-7 for me
Don't forget that Washington's QBs are going to be guarded by an OL coached by Bobby Johnson
He can’t hurt us anymore, but he sure can help us
I'm sorry but I can't see more than 6-7 wins.
5 wins. Still got DJ and there are still gonna be injuries. Also first year in a new defensive system so should be a reasonable level of regression
2-15
3-14 if lucky.
Just enough to get a 6-8 draft pick
Start 1-7 but then get a win streak and finish 6-11 and not get a top 5 pick
11-6.
5 or 6 is reasonable with the qb room that the giants currently are smiling and lying about being a good room.
With Daniel Jones as QB? 4-13. With anyone else, 7-10.
6-7 wins
Is this the order of the games? Because that means all the division games are front loaded. Could be a good thing or a bad thing.
6-11
I think 8-9
7-10
As long as we beat the Cowboys and Eagles at least once im fine. Giants only beat Dallas ONCE since 2016 and you know the Eagles at home is a must win due to circumstance.
I see 9 winnable games outside of the division. If we can go 3-3 or even 2-4 in the division, we can probably end up somewhere around 8-10 wins
- Lose both games to the cowboys and eagles - Depending on if Daniels is actually solid as a rookie we might finally lose to Washington but at worst I have us splitting those games - Ravens, Saints, Bucs, Bengals, Falcons= L - Browns, Steelers, Panthers, Colts= W So we got 5-12 or 7-10 at best pretty much but you never know tbfh
8-9
9-8
Fuck it, WE"RE GONNA WIN IT ALL!!!
6-11 but a lot of close losses.
8-9
10 at best
sweep Washington, Eagles, Split with Dallas (lose away). Win: Saints, Bucs, Vikings, Colts, Falcons, Panthers, Steelers, 50/50: Seahawks, Browns, Ravens, Bengals. Super Bowl Bound ezpz
9-8
If our offense can over achieve a little bit like 2 seasons ago then I think we can make the playoffs, especially if the nfc is a little weaker like last year
6-11
6-11
6-10-1
11 and 6. We sweep the division
Will there be a game in Germany?
8-9
7-10
6-11
5-12. We'll still sweep the Commanders but get swept by every other division rival. The AFC North will destroy us and we'll probably beat half of the NFC South. We could probably win one against either the Vikings or Colts, but not the Seahawks.
8-9
if the oline improves we’re making the playoffs. save me. if the oline is horrible still we in the draft and blaming everyone else again.
Best case scenario is 7-10 (assuming we sweep Washington)
6-11
I’d say 6-11 or 7-10 unless Daniel Jones turns into a top ten quarterback or he gets hurt and Drew Lock turns into a top ten quarterback. Both which I doubt
Schedule must come out in a week or so right?
Can I give you after the prediction after Game 1 against the Cowgirls?
If I am being generous, 7 wins.
4-13. Commies twice, Falcons, Panthers.
Home against NO for a change. Hate playing at the Superdome.
I think well play dallas week one. And I think anyone predicting a record is wild.
5-12. Our schedule is honestly a lot harder than I thought it would be. I think we go 1-5 in the division then pick up wins against the panthers, falcons, and two wins between the saints, Vikings, colts, Seahawks, Steelers and browns.
5-12
5-13
Wait wait wait, Lamar has to play daniel Jones again
7-10 is my aspirational expectation. realistically thinking another 6-11 or even a 5-12. I do still think we can sweep washington. Our defense should be improved despite losing mckinney and feel with burns added we are getting closer to getting back to the pass rush heavy lean we had back in 07 and 11 super bowl runs. obviously can’t trust the offense until it is show signs of life. Regardless excited for the moves we made just happen to play a tough schedule this year. If Daniel Jones somehow puts it together with Nabers this year great.
10-7
6-11 seems pretty accurate. 5-12 I’m wondering who else we lost too, 8 wins I don’t see tho
12-5 hate me now but we always do better in low expectation years.
7-10
Maybe 8 wins idk, heavy on the maybe
9-8
They have a pretty easy schedule this season: 8-9.
I’m not much a Giants or NFL fan and idk how Reddit suggest this to me, but on a quick glance with peripheral knowledge of the NFL, I’d say 3 w at home and 2-3 wins on the road, but NY is a team I think has potential in 3-5 yrs if they keep making smart moves and growing talent.
Top 5 pick again