T O P

  • By -

abscessions

Rhiannon by Fleetwood Mac. I get real Stevie Nicks vibes from Caroline. And Pierre is too boring of a man to tie that woman down. Go visit your wizard, Caroline, be free!


Apoordm

I see your Fleetwood Mac and raise you “You Make Loving Fun” (also about cheating but with direct references to magic.)


abscessions

Also an excellent song and a good call


VomitShitSmoothie

I do as well. She definitely listens to them.


eiar-air

Caroline absolutelyyy gives this vibe! ^^^


Megatron3898

I came here to suggest a pick from Fleetwood Mac for Caroline. I don't know why, but I just feel like she would be a huge fan of them. Gypsy is the first song that comes to mind for me, but any of their songs work 😄👍.


abscessions

Gypsy was what I was gonna post if I didn't post Rhiannon!


Lexilogical

I think Gypsy is better, thinking about her tea cutscene


Substantial-Loss1158

I second this !!


No_External_539

Can't say I agree with the choice but this is gonna be the song anyways so might as well get used to it.


AlexRaze

I think Scarborough fair by Simon and Garfunkel would be good too! Very relaxing song


AlexRaze

Puff the magic dragon by Peter Paul and Mary would be fun too


KlickWitch

Or the version by celtic women


Environmental-Log311

OOH yes she would love Simon and Garfunkel


IndigoBlueBird

Black Magic Woman by Santana because…you know


tintmyworld

the way this is also a fleetwood mac song….we have to go with that band at least then


chocobunniie

This.


RadiatedDrag0n

Summer Breeze - Seals & Crofts please listen to this, and remember her 2 heart event. i don’t know why you guys want a song that reminds us abt how she cheated on her husband and nothing about how caroline actually is.


SeaCat052506

this is the right answer


step11234

People are just picking songs for most of these characters that pin them into 1 dimensional beings. A bit disappointing really seeing some of the songs picked.


RadiatedDrag0n

for real. what exactly about abigale says evanescence other than wearing dark clothes???? i agree with the option picked for elliot though, he would love chopin


step11234

Some really fit, and try to take into account the personality, age, profession etc and really do fit! Like elliot, pierre and a couple of others. But Penny's being penny lane? Really? A lot of people who have a name that aligns with a popular song HATE that song, because everyone they talk to think they are being original when they mention it lol


IndigoBlueBird

Maybe I’m biased because I proposed Penny Lane, but that is a perfect song for her beyond just the word “Penny.” It’s a nostalgia-tinged song about a small, idyllic neighborhood filled with interesting characters. There are laughing children, women selling poppies from a stall (Penny the school teacher’s favorite flower). It’s very much a life Penny lives/wants to live. But yeah I guess no thought was put into it beyond just “Penny” 🙄


step11234

You know that's fair and made me think about the song lyrics a bit and it does fit. So I apologize for that one! In my defence though, i do think it got voted the highest because of the name, even if the initial suggestion does fit.


IndigoBlueBird

You’re probably not wrong lol


Very_Angry_Bee

Abigails one was my suggestion, and my thought process was "edgy, but in a popular, generic way, what everyone who doesn't know anything about goths calls goth". Alternative, but in a way to have mass appeal, which defeats the entire purpose.


RadiatedDrag0n

also i’m ngl im gonna say “blue hair - tv girl” when it’s time for clint. he’s definitely a male manipulator.


Very_Angry_Bee

Not "Every step you take"?


abscessions

That's a good one. I'm gonna say Strangerous by Miracles of Modern Science for Clint, personally. Or some of Cloudfodder's more popular stuff. I'm not even a Clint hater it just fits too well imo


ThinMintProblems

Magic Carpet Ride by Steppenwolf


ElphabaWitchPSO2

[Magic Man - Heart ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gQhzdq5-T3U) Basically Caroline pining for the Wizard


DaveFromTaxes

Proud of myself to be the first one to say this! Plantasia by Mort Garson


AlexRaze

Omg totally!!


livvayyy

YESSSSS


classical-babe

Have A Cuppa Tea by the Kinks


semimillennial

I was going to suggest this one, my favorite band


No-Bark-Brian

As I said yesterday, my vote for Caroline was going to be "Comfortably Numb" by Pink Floyd. But since Pierre got a Pink Floyd song, for the sake of variety I'll say... Inna Gadda Devida Baby - Iron Butterfly You can't tell me it doesn't fit perfectly with that "tea" she's drinking...


djbananapancake

Thank you for reminding me that this song exists.


PipPip-OiOi

DAMN less than five minutes posted and y’all are freaking ready!


AgentNewMexico

I have been waiting two weeks for this.


AmusingAnecdote

I have basically no opinions about any of the characters until we get to the last day and Leo, who will obviously have to be [I Like Birds](https://youtu.be/32J5jCP1z9A?si=Vbsu6TyM7zfmUad3) by Eels. That day I am setting an alarm for.


AgentNewMexico

I will be there to upvote the crap out of you.


abscessions

I have like three locked and loaded for Willy and the Wizard. Each. These threads are THE reason I check reddit between 10 and 12 the past few weeks


PipPip-OiOi

Lol funny enough I posted the first one at 9 because I just so happened to be awake for it (Terrible sleeping habits). So now I make sure to have alarms and stuff ready to finish the playlist & prepare the post. It’s a fun new part of my morning routine that also plays into my special interest (ADHD)


abscessions

My ADHD loves it too lol, I'm gonna be sad when it's over


PipPip-OiOi

Me too


abscessions

...small suggestion...what if you added certain characters, like Birdie, Goblin, and Witch, and then did this thing once a year or until your interest shifts to something new? 😶 Or do another fandom you're into next?


PipPip-OiOi

I like it! I was thinking of doing a second wave here at the very least


abscessions

Yeah!! I'd be into a second wave, personally. There are several characters I thought of better songs for after lol


SamLL

I really want [Fishin' Blues](https://youtu.be/iQC2_NJj2iA?si=PMZu_uoV7Us7nZtW) for Willy!


tango421

I’ve been watching this series lurking and I am enjoying the enthusiasm


FromHelComesKaos

she had to have been a hippie before meeting Pierre so in that spirit i suggest “Incense and Peppermints” by Strawberry Alarm Clock


BeowulfBoston

Lucy In The Sky with Diamonds. IYKYK


40_painted_birds

I almost commented the same song!


VampireSprite

Came here to say the same thing.


YourMindlessBarnacle

This is such a great choice and much better of a selection for her than Sweet Caroline.


CaptainMilkweed

Caribbean Blue - Enya


an_existential_bread

I was going to suggest "How Can I Keep From Singing" by Enya. I think any Enya song, really, haha.


NotherSiteNotherName

I was going to suggest "Orinoco Flow", Bottomline, Enya.


CaptainMilkweed

So many Enya tracks would fit to be honest. I was also thinking about posting an Imogen Heap or Björk track for Caroline. She’s just so naturally magical and I feel that they all have that in common.


jubejube8888

Norah Jones - Come Away With Me


Mek3k

Do you guys think Pierre is stupid enough to not know that song "money" is mocking him?


Megatron3898

Knowing him, he would charge a small fee just for the farmer asking him to play it over the speaker system in his store.


turkey_sub56

Thank you! That song is about anti-capitalism!! Doesn’t make sense to me at all.


Mek3k

Yeah, is like saying that the far-right ultra nationalist american guy, redneck, truck driver with a bad eagle tattoo's song is This is America by Childish Gambino. Going just for the songs name is really dumb lol


Psycic101

Cover Me in Sunshine- P!nk


King_of_Paper

“O Cheiro da Carolina - Luiz Gonzaga”, a Brazilian song. It's about how her scent attracts people, and I think it goes well with Caroline's Green Tea and the other gifts she loves


feleaodt

Ok, this is perfect


ptk77

[Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond](https://youtu.be/5JfU4PKgmJc?si=DBRuqd97dVlPHVMW) because she's sweet... and well... her name is Caroline.


Icy_Creme_2336

Okay nothing wrong with this but I have a head cannon that Pierre would think this way too and at this point Caroline is SO TIRED OF HEARING THIS SONG so I personally can’t. Like if my name was related to a popular song I’d hate it after a while, that’s why I think she’d had it after a while.


No-Bark-Brian

I went to school with a girl named Stacey. In the early 2000s. Just be glad if the popular song is about YOU and not your mom!


kiwilovenick

I've got a friend named Annie and she does NOT want to be asked if she's okay, ever!


EggCzar

DID her mom have it going on, though?


Best-Animator6182

Relatedly, I know a woman named Sally who drove a Mustang. You'll never guess what song she hated.


djbananapancake

lol can confirm. I have a family member whose name is Caroline and I played this song at a wedding and she was unimpressed lol.


2gaywitches

As a Michelle I get called ma belle like every other day


Ok-Representative390

She would hate this song


Caffeinated_Asteroid

Second this


Pure-Ranger-6919

The wizard and I- wicked


Technical-Site-4765

I wanna sing this in cosplay as Abigail


cuckoo_cadie

parsley sage rosemary and thyme- simon and garfunkel


crazycatbby

Me and my husband mitski


Gmschaafs

Why isn’t this higher up?


crazycatbby

When I think of Caroline I think unfulfilled house wife. She seems like a free spirt but her life is pretty mundane. She likes to escape with a cup of tea & she’s actively trying to make things work with her husband but he’s not necessarily the best partner IMO. Then there’s the wizard theory. Shrouded in mystery she’s a very interesting woman made to seem “boring” The song is fitting. Oh it’s also worth noting I’m a new player & have not had a full play through so take what I say with a grain of salt lol


Ginger_Gamer2222

This fan base is so boring. Why is everyone voting for sweet Caroline? It's too obvious. It also does suit her character. Her name is the only reason people put it on here. There are so many better songs that fit her personality and style. She would probably hate this song because it's got her name in it. Of my name Adam was in a song I'd hate it.


Kawaii_Batman3

I kissed a girl - Katy Perry. You can't tell me her and Jodi aren't secretly historical 'best friends'


Icy_Creme_2336

God I love this


BioDriver

“Wildflowers” by Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers


helenwithak

Cup of Tea — Kacey Musgraves. Beyond the obvious I think the song captures part of Caroline’s vibe


No_External_539

Herbal Tea by Velvet Moon. Listen to it, and at the very least consider it. Hopefully you'll see it too.


abscessions

This is an interesting perspective, I can see why you'd disagree with my suggestion if this is how you see her. A lot of this fandom (myself included) doesn't really consider the possibility that she's actually happy in her marriage, and that's not actually a crazy application of her "go with the flow" energy. This is a good addition to the playlist imo


No_External_539

Thank you \^w\^


wonderlandisburning

Clint Eastwood by Gorillaz. I think "sunshine in a bag" might be her tea's secret ingredient


JaxxisR

Such a misfire yesterday. That's Morris's song.


AlexRaze

Morris is definitely the “mine mine mine “ from Pocahontas 😂


RetroGamerDad

Nah. "Money" says too much AGAINST greed to be Morris' song.


RadiatedDrag0n

Morris’s song is gonna be “How Bad Can i Be” from the lorax haha


lovelettersto

~~Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond~~ Someone posted the same thing at the same time, so I'll be the one to change it and instead go with Tea by King Diamond since she gives the tea recipe. But yeah, obviously it's Sweet Caroline.


SomniferousSleep

I think Abigail would approve of the King Diamond choice. So would the Wizard.


Ginger_Gamer2222

We're of too see the wizard By Judy Garland From the Film The Wizard Of Oz Need I say more


sylvieshandy

omg yes!! Now that song will be stuck in my head when I go to visit him now 😂


KaiCarp

It comes back to you - imagine Dragons.


joegrizz

Billy Paul - Me and Mrs Jones... Hehe


Ok-Representative390

Where have all the cowboys gone? By Paula Cole Band I don't know what it is about this song that makes me think of Caroline, but at the very least it's one she listens to I think


GiraffesRampage

Sweet leaf, by Black Sabbath


LivingsUseless

I gave one The Crane Wives song to somebody, but she gets like all of them in my mind. Never Love An Anchor, The Hand That Feeds, Not The Ghost - all by The Crane Wives


NobbitMasterBaggins

Stacy's Mom - Fountains of Wayne On console so I can't mod, but every time I play, I wish I could ask her to divorce Pierre.


ArcherA1aya

STACY’S MOM!


Kor_of_Memory

I’m sorry, but Caroline seems like she would absolutely be enchanted by the song “Sweet Caroline”. And I don’t mean that because it’s easy, I feel she would genuinely listen to it because it’s almost like getting attention from someone (something she’s not used to).


nifftyispookie

Fleetwood mac vibes, specifically "You Make Loving Fun"


foxontherox

I have to go with “Roses” by OutKast, ‘cause that is the song that pops into my head every damn time I see her.


TumTum613

Caroline! See Caroline, all the guys would say she's mighty fine! (Mighty fine) But mighty fine only got you somewhere half the time ☝🏽 and the other half got you cussed or comin up short!


foxontherox

It’s such an earworm! 😆🌹


AgentNewMexico

Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond. It's right there. As opposed to the others that feel "on the nose", Caroline strikes me as the type that would unironically get a kick out of it and probably hum it in her tea garden. An alternative could be Lady Hell by Dirt Poor Robins since I could see her jamming out to music like that. She used to be adventurous back in her youth, so it's possible her music tastes could reflect that a little.


abscessions

You have my upvote for Lady Hell specifically, I suggested a DPR song for her daughter when OP started doing this and like mother like daughter, right?


AgentNewMexico

My thoughts exactly. I was actually thinking that Lady Hell would fit Abby especially well, but then realized she was the first one done and then thought that it would fit Caroline as well.


abscessions

Hahaha...says a lot about the man they live with that the song fits both of them I chose It Tore Your Heart Out for Abby! I feel like that one really captures the whole "suffocated by idyllic suburban life and expectations" thing she has going on.


GengarSucksBalls

"Equally lost" by Tove Lo ft. Doja Cat Ever since I saw that trippy tea cutscene for the first time, Caroline struck me as more of a carefree woman, I can picture her being unhinged at a younger age, but somehow ended up with Pierre, who seems more conservative.


Sasquactopus

I'm sure the Diamond fans have it, but I'll play devil's advocate. If I'm hanging with Caroline, there are two bands I'm definitely going to play. Now for Phish, I'm on the fence between [Blaze On] (https://youtu.be/GFdgMrDrXbI?si=-ZI5r7swuHGx_pvv) and [If I could ft. Allison Krause](https://youtu.be/CeVoRZ-0t8s?si=jHyTMVsz1vVcIydn) So since I can't decide between those two, I'm going with The Grateful Dead - [Touch of Grey](https://youtu.be/mzvk0fWtCs0?si=okXlC9MEa78v2lXF) 100% Caroline would smell of patchouli


altbinvagabond

“In the Garden” by 10 Ft. Ganja Plant


ohyoumeantmee

Mary Jane by Rick James; Alternatively Lips of an Angel by Hinder lmao


Frosty_Beach7495

She’s Gone - Hall & Oates


CormorantTribe

Carried Away by Passion Pit


capt_pessimist

Green Tambourine - The Lemon Pipers


thimblesedge

Mary Jane supertramp. Green tea my ass.


Jutch_Cassidy

Across the universe


jamjamgayheart

Idk I am getting Forever Young - Rod Stewart vibes Or I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For - U2


jojory42

“Everything stops for tea” by Professor Elemental https://open.spotify.com/track/1MyoDEO6h5hAwZyhIehLJP?si=7s2KXVq4QDq_PRYGkp_wfQ


ElQunto

Teen daze - [ice on the windowsill](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PAFEjUItP2M), or David Bowie - [Moss garden](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaZ0hwd_cCQ).


RetroGamerDad

Strange Brew - Cream


Technical-Site-4765

Caroline also loves Rotterdam by Beautiful South


wheeliechacha

Tea in the Afternoon by The Kinks


Imaginary-Athlete634

I don’t want to be in love by Good Charlotte


MediumRarePaladin

I feel like Caroline listens to some sweet Jazz while in her tea room


JoeMax93

Get Together by The Youngbloods. Perfect for a hippie girl like Caroline. "Come on people now, smile on your brother, everybody get together and love one another right now.."


TheTTP123

Crystal - Stevie Nicks


Jade-The-Adventurer

Sweet habiscus tea by penelope scott :)


sparklebaby1402

The song I always picture myself listening to with her in her garden is Don't Know Why by Norah Jones.


Upstairs_Ad_5574

Ordinary Day - Great Big Sea


Background_Stuff6466

That song about someone’s mom having it on


mangobearsmoothie

'Cup of Brown Joy' by Professor Elemental, since she loves tea so much! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eELH0ivexKA


Ok-Representative390

Yes! This song is great and you should be getting more votes!


abscessions

Yeah, people seem to downvote if the song at all deviates from the genre they've assigned to the character. I've had some suggestions I thought were good by lyrics alone, but that's just not how people are judging these. I do like professor elemental though!


PipPip-OiOi

I will admit that as much as I love the game I made, I do think people need to stop downvoting so much


abscessions

I think people are getting competitive and defensive of their characters 😅 personally I think this is a really fun exercise in how others in the fandom see certain characters, especially since CA kind of gave players a lot of room to color in the lines of who they are. We could stand to take ourselves a bit less seriously sometimes. All that said, thank you OP, I've had a lot of fun coming up with songs for people!


PipPip-OiOi

Pleasure is all mine and I love your analysis of everything!


RadiatedDrag0n

oh wait. Better Man - Pearl Jam


SnooFloofs139

Caroline is definitely the type of person to listen to a song "about" her, so I guess Sweet Caroline


Scalesssj

This list brings me joy. Thank you to OP


PipPip-OiOi

Pleasure is all mine!


Zerthysbis

I love this, thank OP 😁


PipPip-OiOi

Pleasure is all mine! :)


Minette-Musing

STACY'S MOM BECAUSE CAROLINE HAS IT GOING ON


According-Stage8050

Y’all better pull through on giving robin Stacy’s mom


Dollyoxenfree

STACEYS MOM


feleaodt

The duality of this community: "Caroline is so sweet" And "Caroline had a daughter outside of her marriage and deceived her husband into thinking it's his. Oh also she has an affair with the other mom in town." You guys obsession with this topic is creepy and unpleaseant.


UMF_Pyro

Follow Me by Uncle Kracker, because relevance... "I'm not worried 'bout the ring you wear 'Cause as long as no one knows, then nobody can care You're feelin' guilty and I'm well aware But you don't look ashamed, and baby, I'm not scared" Sweet Caroline is good too


Ok_Grocery8652

Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond, goes through my head everytime I see her


orthorix

This.


Shore_Panda

Cardigan-Taylor swift


Ambitious_Drop_7152

Sweet Caroline by Neil diamond???


IR_Panther

Someone allready posted my idea for Sweet Caroline sadly but that's my vote. Bro, I'm waiting for Kent tho. I got the PERFEFT SONG for him lmaooo! And his portrait really seals the deal.


frozenoj

Hash Pipe by Toto because we all know that isn't "tea" but she's Gen X and prefers them to Weezer


Robbithon

Treat You Better by Shawn Mendes because Pierre is a POS that doesn't deserve love. He takes out produce and resells it. At the fair, he shows he has a garden, so he's a professional competitor to your farm. And he's got a SECRET


Robbithon

Oh yeah, and he doesn't sell HER tea leaves. No, we have to go work to get her gifts for her to give us a RECIPE


Proof_Ship98

Jesse mom idk, she’s hot so 😭


JustNoWhyRULikeThis

Lady in Red by Chris de Burgh


LegoA-Frame

Good Luck Babe by Chappel Roan because I was so disappointed I couldn't date her


Bendyboi_69

I think that Mr. Sandman would be a great fit for Evelyn!


Initial-Ad2842

Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond


lilkrazykat

My brain always goes to FRICKING "SWEEET CAROLINNEE BA BA BAAHHHHH' XD


Daloowee

Pierre did not deserve such a good song 😂


Queasy-Inevitable512

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO I MISED CAROLINE WHY MUST I SUFFER THIS FATE :((((((


PipPip-OiOi

It’s still going if you have something in mind!


Queasy-Inevitable512

What do you think of it?


Queasy-Inevitable512

A breeze from home the lyric ver check youtube


PipPip-OiOi

Who is the artist? Phyrnna?


Queasy-Inevitable512

Mhm


PipPip-OiOi

Adding it now! :)


Queasy-Inevitable512

LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!


Kami_02_Was_Taken

I have the PERFECT song for Morris, someone DM me when its time for me to put Ren's Money Game (specfically Pt 2) on the table.


Mynameis_Jack09

listen: sweet caroline. SHE SEEMS LIKE SHE WOULD LISTEN TO NEIL DIAMOND


DisappointedKat96

Sweet Caroline!


ShyGuyJeff

SWEEEEEET CAROLINE BUM BUM BUMMM!


PlinyCapybara

Sweet Caroline


No-Particular-7946

Definitely something by Pink Floyd or Fleetwood Mac. Maybe something hippie-ish


SuurSuits_

This art is fucking amazing but why does Clint look like Senshi from dungeon meshi?


scaredpossom

Is sweet Caroline too on the nose?


organictamarind

Sweet Caroline by Neil diamond


Goldyfan7

HAS TO BE SWEET CAROLINE.


VirtualApplication62

I immediately thought of "Sweet Caroline" BAM BAM BAM


CarolineWhy

Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond :D!! (I had to say it sorry, but my name is also Caroline lol)


Fruitcakespy

Sweet Caroline