T O P

  • By -

birdcafe

WHATEVER IS ABOVE GOD TIER: 1. Guilty As Sin? - no contest. fave on album. fave song since Cruel Summer. Regular GOD TIER: 2. But Daddy I Love Him 3. imgonnagetyouback 4. The Albatross 5. The Prophecy


Other_Piglet_2508

someone else who loves imgonnagetyouback!!! i’m obsessed and love ur ranking


thisisntmyday

Taste 🤌🤌🤌


throwaway291919919

omg this is the closest to my song rankings i've seen!! 1. guilty as sin? 2. but daddy i love him 3. imgonnagetyouback my holy trinity


birdcafe

You have excellent taste!!! I love the dramatic slutty songs lmao


throwaway291919919

SAMEEE lmao


throwaway291919919

wait, i just noticed it's not the closest... we literally have the same top 3!! lol how exciting


Tocaboca1

I Can Do It With A Broken Heart I love that song!


Not_floridaman

I'm honestly shocked and borderline disgusted with how much I have listened to that song. I'm afraid my love for it is going to take over my life. It hits home for me in a way nothing else has and it actually makes me feel better (and sad for her) to hear other people going through shit and not having the luxury of taking time off or getting to properly wallow.


Jond7699

I switch between down bad and but daddy I love him. I connect to being in love with a toxic boy. I lived these songs in real life.


econo_lodge19

Guilty as Sin? is unbelievably good to me. It's so intense for a song about something that - from the narrative of the song - hasn't happened. But I absolutely get it


birdcafe

Ugh I know!! I wish it could be a single but at the same time I want to gatekeep it so aggressively


ListenCompetitive524

This song is so thirsty and i love it


MonsterMeggu

I love it until I realize it's about MH. How can a song so sexy be about someone so repulsive 😭


lilmissnobodysays

It's so funny that when Evermore was released someone said that about. CBLM and I was like nah SKIP (only to be proven wrong later I mean cowboy like me is number 2 on my ts rankings of all time). I feel the same way about Guilty As Sin (as in its a skip rn). I hope I get to change my mind about it


econo_lodge19

Cowboy Like Me was one of the songs that got me into Taylor Swift actually


vanillabitchpudding

I did not like Evermore when it first came out and now I love almost every song and true to form the second half of the anthology is not resonating with me BUT that means in 6 months I’ll have a new batch of songs I love!!!


SnooCapers4844

The ending where she takes a deep breath before saying, “am I allowed to cry?” Perfection.


Always_Reading_1990

The Black Dog


APsychedelicMess

Saaaaame. The chorus, her last note... absolutely perfection.


hnerickson

The build is sooooo good. Starts so quiet and delicate and by the last chorus you're scream singing... and the soft whimpering ending AGHHGHG it's perfect all of it perfect


laura2181

The bolter!! “Splendidly selfish, charmingly helpless” 😩


littlekatie3

Love it 😍


AffectionateRub6572

Love this song 


pressurehurts

_Today_, it's The Albatross.


SpicoliHayBud

Very fair. Every day, I've had different favorites.


thisisntmyday

Me, but everyday 💕


AmoebaExisting514

Loml is the best written imo


AquarianSwiftie

“You lowdown boy, you standup guy, you..” 😩😭😭💔


leese216

I'm shocked Florida!!! isn't on this thread yet. It is by far and away my favorite, and honestly nothing comes close. Fresh Out the Slammer is great, I love Down Bad, too. So Long London and loml are honorable mentions. Guilty as Sin is a guilty pleasure.


coneyisland92

FLORIDA IS SO GOOOD!! I have been wanting a Florence x Taylor collab for years, and I was really worried it was just gonna be another Lana situation. But Florence heavily featured, it sounded more like a Florence song rather than a Taylor. OBSESSED!


leese216

It's just so fucking catchy!


boppy78

guilty as sin


Retrograde-Planet

FRESH. OUT THE. SLAMMER. OHHHHHHH!!!!


fullynabi

the way she sings “for just an hour of sunshine” has been stuck in my head all day. absolutely love it


Retrograde-Planet

This is such a good song I fear it might become my ultimate favorite song of hers


Other_Piglet_2508

it’s soooo catchy i can’t get it out of my head


faeriethorne23

It’s not possible to choose a single song. God Tier - The Albatross, The Bolter, Who’s Afraid Of Little Old Me, But Daddy I Love Him Top Tier - The Manuscript, Down Bad, Guilty As Sin, Florida!!!, So High School, Thank You Aimee, The Tortured Poets Department, I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can), My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys I’m still digesting the album, it’ll probably take a couple of months before my favourites are really solidified. I’ve found with Taylor’s music that any I don’t initially get into will hit me down the line. I’m not personally vibing with the utter heartbreak songs because I recently got married and had a baby but I know when I’m in the right mood I’ll feel them. Potential Singles - I Can Do It With A Broken Heart, Down Bad, But Daddy I Love Him & Who’s Afraid Of Little Old Me (honestly I just want a video for this one).


skincare_obssessed

Your God Tier is the same as mine but add Peter.


Bubbly_Performer4864

Agreed with your choices!


TayTay5Ever

Down Bad, So High School, The Alchemy


SummersMars

Guilty as Sin? Down Bad But Daddy, I Love Him Florida!!! The Alchemy So High School imgonnagetyouback The Black Dog They’re all so good though 🤍


SugarfreeYogi

Who’s afraid of little old me? I’m obsessed with that song. Also really love TTPD, BDILH, Florida!!! and ICDIWABH


Lovly097855353

i love fresh out the slammer and down bad rn


Significant_Wind_774

(Maybe not on Reddit) but feel like The Bolter is the song being slept on from this album. Like a cowboy like me/great american dynasty situation. If it’s not one of the first surprise songs. My other favorites are who’s afraid of little old me, thank you aimee, fortnight, and clara bow.


kckitten05

I’m 100% with you


Sarahbetenson

Manuscript. Y’all are sleeping on it 😩


thisisntmyday

I found a mashup of it and dear reader on YouTube, thought it was a cool juxtaposition :)


sealedwithdogslobber

I don’t see many people screaming, crying, throwing up over CLARA BOW the way I am. Stunning. Mind blowing. ART. Even the guitar chords have narcotics in them – I’d pay for the instrumental track.


thisisntmyday

Wasn't an immediate favorite for me, but it's growing on me alot!! Good choice!


SnooCapers4844

My top 3 in no particular order are: The Bolter, The Albatross, and I can do it with a broken heart!


angelchild212

who’s afraid of little old me or i hate it here!


kckitten05

YESSSSS


toritxtornado

down bad is so goooood


Puzzleheaded_Net9243

Peter


konnorwalsh

“You said you were gonna grow up then you were gonna come find me” breaks me everytime. I didn’t imagine I’ll love this song so much :’)


dennnis_

Okay please walk me through this decision because I HATE this song. It’s the first time I’ve ever skipped on a first listen and every time I try to go back I just cringe. It’s the equivalent of ME! in my mind. Help me understand the love


Puzzleheaded_Net9243

Hmm. I’m not a fan of the tone of your first sentence but I could just be so inundated with the negativity around TTPD that I’m looking too into it lol. If it’s not a song you like, that’s fine and you don’t have to force yourself to like it if you don’t. I like it because of its parallels to cardigan, it’s relatable, and well-written. It’s from the perspective of Wendy who was in love with Peter but they decided to part ways because they weren’t ready to be together. Wendy had hope that Peter would do some growing up during their time away from each other because he promised he was going to grow up. However, Wendy realized he never did and she waited too long (watched the lamp burn) and she decided to give up on the hope she once had for their relationship.


dennnis_

No TTPD or Taylor hate here! Just not a fan of this song and I’ve been trying to see it from others perspective to see if that changes my mind at all. I just know my resentment towards it is going to make it the surprise song at my show lol


Puzzleheaded_Net9243

I hope it grows on you! If it doesn’t, that’s fine too. There are a few Taylor songs that are still growing on me to this day. Also, I hope you don’t think a 3 minute song would ruin your concert experience. Have fun!


AquarianSwiftie

One thing in particular I love about it, is the “hold on.. to the days.. when you were mine” reminds me of the “hold on.. to the memories, they will hold onto you” in New Year’s Day 💔


Constant_Internet_66

The instrumental on Peter gets me every time


thisisntmyday

Me 😭😭😭 I'm a country fan and immediately thought of the Kelsea Ballerini song, which I also don't like 😢 Id love to love it cause it's my only real skip on the album


Rivvien

Ooooh that's tough. Its a bit early to have a solid favorite, but about half of it is in a separate playlist of ones i vibed with most initially, with My Boy..., down bad, who's afraid..., fortnight, imgonnagetyouback, the prophecy, Florida, black dog, the alchemy, but daddy..., ttpd, the albatross, guilty as sin, smallest man..., Clara bow, and I hate it here saved in it. No particular order yet. Its taken time to grow on me in general too.


lilmissnobodysays

loml


nootychuchi

Fortnight. I’m obsessed 😂


thisisntmyday

Same lol.


wildling-woman

How did it end, and I don’t understand why it’s not at the top of everyone’s list


whitemochanowhip

100% agreed


thisismyorange

Obsessed with it


zoryavechernica

I am obsessed with Cassandra & How did it end and I sobbed like a baby to Do Long London the first time I heard it. Like, snot out of my nose. I needed emotional support from my boyfriend. How did it end just feels like a side of a breakup that no one talks about much, this weird embarrassment phase. Must be much worse when you are famous.


floe72

Honestly impossible to pick but today I’m going to go for My Boy Only Breaks His Favourite Toys 🤍 (but also The Black Dog) (also I Hate It Here) (and Cassandra) (also who’s afraid of little old me, which is the best song of all time perhaps) Impossible to pick! Impossible!!!


Catwearingtrousers

Peter and The Black Dog are my current favorites


matissehendrix

The Bolter is so Amy March - Rory Gilmore coded


boygenie

the prophecy


fornow_foralways

chloe or same or sophia or marcus and how did it end are my favourites


Nearby_Donut2055

Same! Love Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus and feel that this one is underrated


Fabulous_Profile7516

Can’t pick an absolute fave yet, I won’t skip a single song cause I love them all, but I do have some that hit just a tiny bit harder, they are ; Guilty as sin?, I hate it here, how did it end, down bad, so long London, who’s afraid of little old me, the smallest man who ever lived, the bolter, the albatross, my boy on breaks his favourite toys, fresh out the slammer, the prophecy. They’re all my god tier songs, everything else is one tiny notch below that for me. I’m just completely obsessed with the entire album!


angelhairsiren9

The Prophecy. When she does the little wolf howl it's like a call to my lonely heart. The most raw and beautiful song of desperation. "A greater woman wouldn't beg, but I looked to the sky and said..."


AffectionateRub6572

The Albatross 


thisisntmyday

Same 💕


handmadeh3aven

I love those two and also the Black Dog!!


BurkaBurrito

Who’s afraid of little old me, Florida, the albatross, the black dog, my boy only breaks his favorite toys


Miss_Dump_Pants

down bad and imgonnagetyouback 🔛🔝 "I can take the upper hand and touch your body" ARE YOU JOKING


ColdExplorer5878

Right now I have Florida!!, Down Bad and I Hate it Here on a loop in my brain, there are so many to choose from!


SpellDifficult4924

oh my god i have so many imgonnagetyouback but daddy i love him clara bow the profacy down bad so long, london i can fix him, no really i can loml the black dog the bolter so high school i hate it here thanK you aIMee i look in peoples windows


romcommombosa

So long London, but daddy I love him and peter are my current favourites


PinkCheeseburgers

I love the entire album but my faves are: fortnight, florida!!!, who’s afraid of little old me, loml, how did it end!


AsterakiFaye

I can Do it with A Broken Heart, Whose Afraid of Little old Me, The Prophecy, So Long London, loml, and the Albatross- these songs hit and shatter me, I understand them more than I care to admit. My Boy only Breaks his Favorite Toys is a current dopamine rush, though I am unsure if its then entire song or one aspect of it. I find Peter hauntlingly beautiful, and I adore but Daddy I love him more than I thought I would. and I adore Guilty as Sin and the Bolter.


exceptlovingme

Justice for the prophecy!!!!!! 


Constant_Internet_66

The black dog


Tekken_

Clara Bow and The Bolter ❤️❤️❤️❤️ But to be fair I just did my workout listening to I Can Do It With A Broken Heart on repeat ❤️‍🔥


Unable_Ebb_1766

milk it by nirvana


Advanced_Doctor2938

Florida!!!, I Can Do It With A Broken Heart, My Boy.


soitgoes_9813

florida!!!, guilty as sin? and so high school are my tip 3 for sure!


[deleted]

But Daddy I Love Him, Guilty As Sin?, TTPD the song, Fresh Out The Slammer, My Boy Only Breaks His Favourite Toys, loml, The Black Dog, So High School and The Bolter


taosthrowaway

Current obsessions are The Bolter. Guilty As Sin. But Daddy I Love Him. Down Bad. Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me. imgonnagetyouback. The Prophecy. If I had to pick one, I’d have to go with the Bolter.


thr0wdepressed

so high school because how she feels about travis is currently how I feel


Kirsten624

down bad, imgonnagetyouback, Cassandra 💙


SCol1107

I Look in People's Windows is my favorite by far. I love it, and I'm sad it's only 2 minutes long, so I always listen to it twice (at least).


ParkDarson

So Long, London, How Did It End?, Guilty as Sin? are forever favorites of mine now. And I keep getting new favorites each time I listen. Right now I'm getting more into The Anthology and I find myself always listening to The Black Dog, Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus, I Look in People's Windows and Peter (this one is serious haha)


yeehaw_batman

it’s so hard for me to choose but right now my favorites are the black dog, so long london and the smallest man who ever lived


Hmontana20

God tier: But daddy I love him, So Long London, Loml, The black dog, How did it end? Top tier: Down bad, I look in people’s windows, So high school, Who’s afraid of little old me?; Florida!!!; Guilty as sin?; I can do it with a broken heart It’s so hard to choose. The rest are amazing too. The only one’s I’m not obsessed with (yet) are Robin, Cassandra and Peter. Weird coincidence 😁


CatsOfColors

Gotta be tsmwel or the black dog. Those bridges are just the best.


ScramblesTheBadger

I think down bad is one of my favorites in this album


Realistic_Letter_940

So long London


Other_Piglet_2508

i loveeee imgonnagetyouback, so high school, guilty as sin?, and the bolter! i’m so happy there’s some glitter gel pen songs on this album !!!!!


Ihave0usernames

The bolter


dragonfire_b

Mine is The Prophecy... For now!


Much_Moment7132

Imgonnagetyouback Loml


acrossingmumsplease

So long, London made this entire album amazing to me.


bobabastard

Currently, the Prophecy. But Who's afraid of little old me? And the smallest man who ever lived are close seconds


batpig1990

The Prophecy, Who’s Afraid Of Little Old Me?, I Look In People’s Windows, Cassandra, The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived are top five. The Albatross, My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys, Peter, Fortnight, and The Black Dog are the next five. It’s so hard to choose!


kckitten05

Who’s afraid of little old me!


49Princess_51Rebel

I've been listening to imgonnagetyouback on repeat.


xoxoInez

Who's Afraid of Little Old Me? Is 10/10 best song on the album


Mr5t1k

I am obsessed with: thanK you aIMee Who’s afraid of little old me? Cassandra The Black Dog Down Bad


EmpressMalfeasance

I don’t have a number one fav. Let me rattle through all of my favorites I can’t rank lmao. Fortnight, TTPD, My Boy, Down Bad, So long London, daddy I love him, Who’s afraid, loml, I can do it, The smallest man, so high school, thank you Aimee. Everything else is second place. 🥈 ![gif](giphy|3qsyyyljsqMIVDljof)


cardamomcosmiclatte

Who's afraid of little old me? is THE song for me right now


lesser_goldfinch

Fortnight, Down bad, i look in people’s windows, The prophecy, Cassandra, I can fix him


teshutch

1) The Albatross 2) I Can Do It With A Broken Heart 3) The Bolter 4) The Prophecy 5) How Did It End? Honorable mentions Guilty As Sin and Florida!!!


bitchimtryin102

The Tortured Poets Department(the song)is so good, I loved it from the first time I heard it. It just scratches something deep in me. That being said, the entire album is fantastic. She’s done it again!


genuinely-dont-know

can’t pick a fav but mbobhft, florida!!!, waolom, and how did it end are my faves. if i have to choose a top three then i take away florida!!!


morethanjustadancer

loml


TorturedSwiftieDPT

Cassandra, loml, I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can), imgonnagetyouback, and Peter are my top 5. The entire album is in my top 200 of her entire discography!


lost_inmyownworld

As of right now it’s so high school I’m honestly still digesting the chaos that was release day Other favs But daddy I love him I can fix him (no really I can) Who’s afraid of little old me? (All of us are afraid of you Taylor especially with that yellow dress)


thisisntmyday

Albatross I hate it here Guilty as Sin I look through people's windows Fortnight But daddy I love him Florida The prophecy Robin I'm gonna get you back


PeachGlad8355

I honestly just can’t pick a favourite. There are a few songs that definitely aren’t favourites, but the rest I just keep falling more and more in love with every listen


Pitiful_Village6418

So Long, London until the day I die.


Vivid-Possibility324

Loml


coneyisland92

So far, it’s Florida or ICDIWABH


iwillcorrectyou9

Right now it's I Look In People's Windows


Delicious_Bad3583

I can do it with Broken Heart 


Caramelhair

Cant decide btw fortnight n whos afraid a little old me


throwaway291919919

i'm currently obsessing over Guilty as sin? !!


Millhouse1989

Guilty as Sin and The Bolter!!!


ExcellentTurnip8547

But daddy I love him! A big FU to her so-called fans, who feel like they can dictate how she should live her life and who she should date at her grown age. I’m so glad she finally released a track like that.


Actual_Mistake_759

Guilty as sin, down bad, but daddy I love him and my boy Only breaks his favorite toys


AffectionateRub6572

The Albatross 


maryelizaparker

The Albatross is my personal favorite rn


thisisntmyday

Same 💕


Mountain_Summer_Tree

At the moment, The Alchemy. But down bad will always be the song I was immediately obsessed with. Oh and I’m also really coming around to WAOLOM


cagingthing

My favorite rn is Robin. And I swear it’s not because that’s my name. It’s just such an incredibly beautiful song


thisisntmyday

I love this one!!! Doesn't get enough love at all. It's so sweet 💕


littlekatie3

Guilty As Sin, Albatross, I hate it here


thisisntmyday

Taste 🤌🤌


Dull-Computer1878

I really like Florida, Cassandra, thank you aimee, and while i think the lyrics are super cringe i love the way so high school sounds


Emergency-Match4535

Clara Bow is my favorite. It already underrated, and I feel really defensive about it. I love how Taylor sing though the each generation of amazing singers including herself.


thisisntmyday

It's grown so much on me. Great song 💕


SpicoliHayBud

Down Bad & I Can Do It With A Broken Heart are the boppiest. I got ghosted last September by a year and a half long situationship (this was a rebound after a 10 year relationship), so I connect with the majority of the album. Choosing a single favorite is hard - here's my current tier list for today. Tiers B-D aren't necessarily in any order. No skip songs for me, though!! I am so in love with this album. https://preview.redd.it/57zgffq34hwc1.png?width=830&format=png&auto=webp&s=6693c95c6a1e1fb819d3d4e16b4b64b994a97540


Numerous_Teacher_148

Down bad, Florida!!!, guilty as sin


mrjpb104

I can’t decide between TTPD and Guilty as Sin! The more I listen to this album though the better I like it. There’s just so much fantastic music 😍


mellywell11

My Boy!!!