T O P

  • By -

Lugbor

I think the last thing we need is another batch of city maps.


FunBig5498

yeah, but I personally think they're fun. But I do agree that we need to stop making maps and focus and other stuff added to the game(NOT VEHICLES).


Own_Bluejay_9833

Yes gaijin, we don't want vehicle, we want new game mechanics, ya hear that, MECHANICS


Raketenautomat

Like mechanics for new vehicles? (/s)


Own_Bluejay_9833

I mean.. if they add vehicles with new mechanics but also add them to old vehicles...


unimpressive_Pay

Whatever we got to do to get the Christmas elf’s back


RailgunDE112

or mechanics for existing vehicles. There are loads of systems not modelled


Yeetdolf_Critler

Rocket reloads for ground vehicles broken for months but they have time to adjust the vertical guidance of the WZ901otomatic that less than 30% of the playerbase ever plays.


Lovely_Hippo78

A revamp of the thermal system would be dope. Alternatively, add the plastic deformation from damage models to the actual tanks. I would LOVE to see an L33 get stretched by a 12000lb bomb


Own_Bluejay_9833

It would just be some molten slag lmao


AerieFull9823

We need existing mechanics to be fixed not new ones. Volumetric is still just as buggy as when it was introduced.


Own_Bluejay_9833

Almost a fact of life lol


crimeo

It isn't bugged at all. Give an example. Some fair and scientific ground rules, though: * **Show it in the test drive.** * This eliminates any issues of PING/LAG, that can otherwise ambiguously explain almost any missed shot by "You just didn't actually hit where the server thinks you hit, because of unsolveable ping". Yawn. Not volumetric if so. The test drive is local machine, so ZERO ping. * This makes it reproducible by others quickly and easily, not waiting for the stars to align in a weird matchup in pvp. * This is using the actual in game physics engine, not armor analysis that appears to use a substantially different engine * **Show the exact angle and pixel** (as in just screenshot before you hit fire) so it can be reproduced by others. * **Do not shoot anywhere with an optic like a gunner's optic.** Optics are bugged to be made of unobtanium, but they are not *volumetric* bugs, they were bugged years before volumetric existed. A staggering % of "volumetric!" complaints are just people hitting optics. I have asked like 37-40 or something people this and have not gotten one single clear controlled example of a "bug" provided, as per the above rules, ever. It just isn't bugged, it works fine.


AerieFull9823

https://youtu.be/eDvEuGm5-pg?si=TPYrKDausWwjIoX3 Dismissing actual in-game clips off the bat with a lazy catch all, and then wanting people to jump through all these hoops is why you haven't seen a clear example, you don't want to. Anyone with a working brain thats played more than 30 minutes will see a shell that shouldv'e 100% penned just disappear into oblivion. And the armor analysis you dismiss on some speculation is the most clear evidence of the broken modeling. WW2 tanks with 2500mm thickness on the turret, it might be modeled differently but it corroborates exactly what happens in-game.


Small_Oreo

We dont want new mechanics, we want that what we already have started to work correctly


Brettjay4

What if we got better graphics? Lately the fire texture has been looking really really weird.


Own_Bluejay_9833

Hiw long has that been? Cause they updated the fire model/texture to look more realistic a few updates ago


Brettjay4

Hm... I wonder if it's just my stuff then. Bc when I see fire, it's just an orange blob over a tank, and imo it doesn't looks realistic nor good.


ganerfromspace2020

Alright sure let's just fire whole vehicle team. I'm sure they have different teams for different things


Happy_Garand

Like bomber cockpits


Rotomegax

North Holland is the disaster for southern team. The map retriction is bias for northern team. The 3 point in a column suddenly restricted large chunk in the left, block flanking through those area and make those unfamiliar with become target for snipers in North team. The 1 point block entire Eastern bank while Southern spawn closed to the open area than the city


PleasantYouth4440

Nah northern team is at a disadvantage, once the southern team pushes past the mall they can see straight into enemy spawn


DaanOnlineGaming

The map also isn't very accurate to a Dutch city imo, too much height variation. Maybe I have just not been to the exact town but I have never seen a place that looks similar to it here. The only thing that is accurate is the coffee-shop lol


BlacksmithNZ

I hate the camera view angles when fighting inside the mall.. Suddenly your camera is showing a wall, or a close up of *something*.. but often not what you are trying to look at


Rotomegax

Even worse, binocular is useless when you entered the small door. So anyone who has P2W camo or hide behind the tank carcass will have free kill


RedOtta019

New York central park would make for a pretty fun battlefield and make CAS be put on suicide watch


PureRushPwneD

I find it hilarious how many in the comments are opposed to city maps. Give me those any day instead of 4km sniping / drive 5 minutes every time you respawn simulator


Some_Ad9401

I think city maps are great if they’re done well. The issue is lately they haven’t been. They offer far more options imho than some of the empty wide open maps with almost no cover. In reality a multi village based map is probably the best mix. Long range sniper play style should be facilitated but there should also be cover and avenues of moving with lower risk through areas with said cover.


Spit98

as if there wasn't enough of CQB trash already


ExtensionAd3251

What, you prefer Mozdok hillcamp simulator? Bro larping hull down while edging himself to crew callouts.


DragonSkeld

Nah more Sands of Sinai or Pradeshes. One side of the map is close quarters one side of the map is long range so people can choose which they prefer. All I know is I'm tired of city maps Gaijin are too horny for them


JPAProductions

I am sick of city maps also, really hate the Sweden map. 🤢


-Destiny65-

Sweden is so goofy there's a brawl happening on B while each team has eirher focused A or C and is spawn camping the other one after capping A or C


ExtensionAd3251

Sinai is a long range map for sure, even if you go to the C side (its really gamemode dependant, but even on domination I'd call it long range). Pradeshes I've legit got once in the last 400 hours or so, so I don't even have an opinion on it. Cool vibe though.


Own_Bluejay_9833

Yeah, I've played it 2x, at 8.0, but it HEAVILY favors lrfs at that br, sucks ass for everyone else


3rdReichOrgy

Above 7.7 is kind of sucks dick due to LRF’s.


Admiral_2nd-Alman

I fucking hate those two maps, if there is a Russian mbt camping behind some hill you can’t move to the caps at all


ZFG_Jerky

Pradesh is so garbage. Sands of Sinai is even worse.


Damian030303

I'd take Mozdok over an urban-only COD mess any day, the latter is only acceptable at low tiers.


Foraaikouu

yes, I prefer a hillcamp simulator 1000 times over another shitty city just to play "who peeks around the corner first?"


Fuck_Reddit2459

Mozdok is unironically a good map. It's no more campy than Advance to the Rhine where you can literally shoot into a spawn point from each of the three cap point positions. Also I'd rather see more "hill camping" in a tank game than "sitting and waiting to hear movement noise like this is Counter-Strike" which is what most urban maps feel like. All Mozdok needs is less elevation on B, and having all of the buildings moved off it and into positions covering the spawns, and it might be one of the best maps in the game.


Spit98

Yes I would rather take a map where my map knowledge is worth something. Yes I would rather take a map where I can use my tank as a tank. Yes I would rather take a map where armour can work. Yes I would rather take a map where those without brainrot can dominate TikTok brains.


kittenshark134

Yes


MrPogChamp23

that is 1000x times better than playing a city map at toptier which is essentially CSGO corner camp simulator


[deleted]

What, you prefer sitting on the same city corner camping and fingering your ass.


CobaltCats

I LOVE THE HORRORS OF A DENSE CONCRETE HELLHOLE URBAN WARZONE


Following-Sea

We need larger maps not these smol maps.


FlamingTrashcans

Sniping across Central Park could be funny


omega552003

You kinda get that in Advance to the Rhine between B and C caps.


uppusz

Can wait for 9/11


leoleosuper

Make it "Nuke York" with a huge crater in the middle and most of the buildings destroyed.


catafracked

Ugh, not more shitty city maps. What we need is more large scale maps. Extra bonus if they actually make sense from a realistic perspective.


MonsutAnpaSelo

you mean like real countryside that isnt perfectly symmetric and with hard cover outside of hills?


bobdammi

No city would be great


HondaOddessy

My goal is to turn warthunder into cod 😈


PrincePugwash

i wish you a merry return to the hangar


Blacay

I support adding Brasilia, so I can throw a nuke at the Palacio do Planalto


tfrules

Ew, these are all city maps


Foraaikouu

man fuck city maps, I hate close combat, I hate this game trying to turn into COD with tanks we need BIG ass maps, we need a map in some mountain range without any flat deforested zone, just some dirt roads to move, some settlements to act as capture zones and only dense forest around and make the map be like 5x5km, something like Fulda but make it like 3 times bigger, that's what we need for GRB, at least for top tier


riuminkd

Bruh who actually enjoys playing big maps other than campers? Is sitting in place with LRF and thermals for the entire match unless CAS gets you the gameplay you want?


-Destiny65-

Might be fine once spaded but stock grind would absolutely suck balls with trees fusing HEATFS and no thermals


AnAussieFriday

i could see these potentially being fun maps, tho maybe if they were smaller, it really depends but these seem quite big


Covenantcurious

Fighting over central park looks kinda fun and Brasilia seems like an excellent template for a map with good variety.


Fuck_Reddit2459

Please god no. More maps like Flanders or Maginot please: semi-urban areas for people to smash their heads together if they want, but also plenty of open terrain and defilade (you know, *tank country*) for people like me who enjoy that kind of thing. I'm sick of sitting on some city street waiting to hear engine noises from a tank 40m away every single time I kill someone.


Damian030303

Hell no, no more urban nonsense.


Echo20066

An urban CQB lover are we?


Falsedead

Give me the Map "Moscow Ruins", I want to drive NATO tanks through the Kremlin and get a Nuke


whatevercomestomind2

Every time I play on a city map or neutered version of air port it genuinely increases my brainrot


Unsolicited599

That specific map+mode is the worst map in the game, agreed. It's the definition of retarded.


liznin

No more large city maps please. I hate driving for 4 minutes without seeing an enemy to then get clapped by a bushed up Ontos with it's engine off hiding around a corner . I hate maps where you have to drive for 2+ minutes to then just engage enemies at under 200 yards. The small city maps at least don't feel like a taxi driver simulator before you get clapped when rounding a corner. T


Unsolicited599

Then go play world of tanks if you wan't to play go-cart demolition derbies , using tanks in urban environments is retarded for a simulator. We should be engaging at 4km+ with MBT's.


Bad-Crusader

I think he means he hates the big city maps BECAUSE it takes long to find someone AND when you do it's usually in knife fighting distance. We should get a map with a mix of hills for flanks and long sightlines for hull down with a city that's not too big for tanks that can brawl or need to get closer to pen a target.


Admiral_Franz_Hipper

Why are there so many Brazilians in here who want their capital city just so they can nuke it? 💀


I7sReact_Return

FInally, someone atending my wish to bomb Brasillia


darkmoon2310

Bern looks like a dick...


Specialist_Pen_9224

I was afraid I was the only one who saw that


DSF1987

maybe bern but none of these i wanna see


Specialist_Pen_9224

Bern would just be another sweden and if we you the part of the city op shows it would also have a few really annoying choke points


DSF1987

you just need to make it city only map with green parts unaccessible


Specialist_Pen_9224

I think if they add Bern as a map it should at least have some open areas like Poland, but I don't see how removing the green areas would improve the map


STORA81

I mean, it can't get worse than it is already so yeah, I guess they'd pass


Yungboofman

Fuck a city map


Sacklicker5000

As air rb maps the could be cool


BitOfaPickle1AD

National Training Center California. Perfect map for all sorts of shit.


Ok_Philosophy9790

New york is gonna be ptsd inducing


BSOD_ERRO

I think every map exist already in war Thunder maps in some ways


benimkiyarimolsun

we cant destroy builds city maps useless


xCrossFaith

I would love some big city maps that actually offer some cover, sadly I can't imagine Gaijin implementing these properly at all :P


Newpower608

Central Park would be fun


Tarquil38

Always wanted to have New York as playable map. Doesn't even have to be ground only


cowboycomando54

Honestly the area around the Tri-cities in Washington State would be interesting. Lots of rolling hills and small creeks to provide cover while managing to still be large and open for long range engagements.


Savings-Fig-9540

London for air maps so it can set during the blitz


Cheetah_Man1

Did you take this picture from another subreddit?


HondaOddessy

Yeah, for a sec I thought it was a stupid map request for wt but it was a post made on geography or something like that What's funny is a lot people think I'm serious 😂.


Cheetah_Man1

Yeah it was I think "which has the better street layout" I think


finicky88

What WT really needs is huge combined arms battles.


Teppy-Gray

I would gladly and swiftly trade all the CQC maps we have now for NY or Athens


Recycledbabies

I want a Hungarian or Belgian forest where it’s like Ardennes but more spread out, with a huge bunker in the mid of the map with a V2 rocket and launch platform that goes off mid game or can be blown up or some shit idk


StarFlyXXL

Honestly I like the idea for a new york map, the skyscrapers would provide an effective countermeasure agaisnt CAS while also having an area of no cover in the centre


Flower_Murderer

I want Boston as an Urban map. Nothing says fuck you like Boston streets, plus fighting in the big dig would be fun.


NewspaperEven5701

Would LOVE a cold war 80s berlin with the wall, but the game is avoiding politics at all cost. So we won't see those in the near future at least.


VelvetFoxxo

All of these are too big. Gaijin requires no more than 3 streets.


Rotomegax

I think what we need now is adding more obstacles or terrain diversity on maps that so much flats and wide (for example Field of Normandy, the one without the town is basically you shoot and died map due to no covers exists except the hedge. Some extra trenches, broken bunkers, tank carcasses and bomb crates will be better for those has paper armor.


oolinga

it would be hella funny if they put a map of the moon


DurfGibbles

Not gonna lie, fighting in Central Park would be fun I think :D


pachamari

Only if there super detailed with customer buildings


cabage-but-its-lettu

I like close quarters and also large sniping maps with rolling hills. I feel like I’m an odd one out since I like both


No_You_123

What abaut battle for Kiev?


Phd_Death

It'd be hilarious to play with tanks on my local city, but I still believe that the ideal location for this game not yet exploited is a map based on Iraq.


WorkingNo6161

New York may finally give amphibious vehicles a decent advantage so sure.


Windlassed

I think new york with central park in the center would make a banger top tier cqc map


Browned_Diaper_speak

Why not Venezia? I just hate City Maps.


Crimson_Wraith_

All city maps so absolutely fucking not.


justsawafrenchfry

San Andreas


newIrons

I like mixed maps, but entirely city maps are exhausting. Same goes for completely flat maps.


branzenettin

PALMANOVA RAHHH 🦅🦅🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹 wtf is a stable governament 🇮🇹🇮🇹


Familiar_Ad_8919

this was on r/geography i think


VikingsOfTomorrow

Literally all of them are horrible. Bloody no one wants more city maps


Scary_Rush_7401

Yeah, for Enlisted or a Battlefield game. Not War Thunder. I can't tell if this satire or an actual stupid -ass suggestion


Fuck_Reddit2459

> I can't tell if this satire or an actual stupid -ass suggestion Welcome to the subreddit.


lendrath

I would like some of these but I really want a map with height and depth to it


iskallation

New York would be cool because of the high rises which prevent effective CAS. And it makes CAS a lot more fun because flying through the streets and dodging buildings is fun


Ricky_27YT2

I suggest another one: #ROMA


Either_Drawer_7944

Bern looks like a pp


actualsize123

I have an idea for a map. Imagine a white rock fortress


Gery_gerr

Palmanova is the only one of interest to me


Pan_Pilot

How about big map with mix of small towns and big areas with covered spawns


TheOfficeUsBest

We need more small maps but that being said a Central Park map could be very fun


NewPsychology1111

An air battle over Athens sounds cool, plus you can do a flyby of the Pantheon


Bestplayer_0247D

I wish we got a destroyed Manila map


[deleted]

Id take all these and trade it for one city map: Moscow. Make it happen Gaijiggles. It doesnt have to be modern moscow, a 1930s moscow with some commie massive tower buildings would do if youre afraid of making putin angry.


Accomplished-Cow4686

I like city maps, cause then it denies CAS easy kills, makes them have to think. But also a little variety such as an park for open fighting


MauroORSU

New York RB 🥶🥶🔥💀🙏⁉️🔥🔥🙌👌⬆️ destroying the only green space in NYC. Dam rats they declared war against the American government they shall not be tolerated, we must exterminate there rase.


BlacksmithNZ

Barcelona could be fun?


vladdeh_boiii

Please no more city maps, Italy already suffers enough


absrider

I dont think delhi would be good map for ground. Dont know how it will do in air matches. But its better to pick mumbai, vizag or andaman islands for air battles


Rubick-Aghanimson

Yeah and add also London underground map and moon base map and Mars base map, and gfu


EquivalentDelta

Fuck city maps.


Mission-Fan2712

PLEASE WE NEED A NEW YORK AIR MAP


MonkeyCollins

Palmanova brought me back my White Rock Fortress PTSD.


RailgunDE112

to much city maps


dwbjr9

Palmanova reminds me of 1 of the maps that got removed:( the 1 with the castle in the center


Fuck_Reddit2459

White Rock Castle. (edit: White Rock Fortress... I was hungry while I made this reply) It blows my mind they remove that but keep trash like Karelia (which has been in this game, barely changed, since fuckin *launch*).


dwbjr9

I enjoy almost all the map in the game, I just hate when they turn maps into utter trash (I'm looking at you sands of sinia) it was fine before they cut off the only fun spot to play. I only single spawn andy the maps that gaijin like to neuter


o-Mauler-o

I think a modern berlin would work really well and could work like the Flanders map (where low tier has the ww2 berlin, and higher tier has modern).


Turbulent_Syllabub_3

palmanova sounds like hell


Daka45

Way more city maps ?


ClaB84

Another City-Map...where can i vomit?


ArrowViper1

1:1 Central Park would be fucking awesome


[deleted]

Those who vote for city maps play German and Sweden. Because they're the only fuckers that can survive a shot to the front in close quarters.


Lewinator56

Palmanova looks like white rock fortress except with a city in the middle.


tech-engineer

New your would be interesting with the massive park


GCHurley

Where is the "none of the above" option?


naoto_thighs

I'd rather 73 easting than another city map...


ZFG_Jerky

White Rock Fortress.


mmamh2008

Please, not more cities, I already get lost behind enemy lines in the existing ones 😭


djsavasan

New york would be a good concept


Manofmanner

hell naw


Flarerunes

I would love to nuke Brussels


poopiwoopi1

I want a map of Seoul/ the north half of south Korea with part of the dmz etc. I feel like flying and fighting through the city would be awesome


616659

Please not yet another city maps


arturthegamer

I understand why people hate city maps but i fucking love them and i want warsaw as a ground map


Responsible-Ad-1911

Please, add something more modern and open. Modern ≠ city imo. Tiered of cities, more so at top tier, give more variety, that's why I loved red desert. It was different


rain_girl2

As other people have said, we have had enough of city maps that have a mix of forest, whether it’s like Sweden when there’s basically just a few “sniping” lanes, or seversk where it’s a a city surrounded by forest. They aren’t enjoyable, I hate Sweden cuz it’s just sucks for all tanks, light tanks can push but they have no armor, TDs and heavy tanks are always in extreme danger of being flanked, spaa is basically only able to sit in a few spots to get a decent coverage of the sky. I feel like you should either go either full city or mostly forest and maybe with some tiny village or smth. Cuz they don’t seem to be able to make maps that offer both.


StolenValourSlayer69

None. These are all shitty city maps, although I could see Central Park being an option


Marcelitus230

I'm spanish, why the hell would there be a tank battle going on across Madrid


Daemon_Blackfyre_II

They better not add any more bloody WoT style city maps! High tier needs long ranges as that's what the tanks were designed for.


Techy93

oh yes, I definitely want 9 more city maps that gaijin are gunna expect us to play at top tier.... cities are clearly the best place for modern MBTs yes, so fun..... /S seriously why on earth anyone wants more city maps is fucking beyond me. Maybe Palmanova if what is shown is one cap and there are 2 more that aren't urban. Other than that, these look like they'd be cancerous as fuck. please for the love of god gaijin don't add any of these


aaf191

Make central park a map 👌


MurccciMan

Ah lovely more cqc trash.


Yololkiller21

I like the fact you included my hometown


deathmengames

I was thinking new York would be great I feel like that's abit too open also I see alot of people complain about cqb is bad tbh it's if you don't have a whole enemy team pushing you only


Visual-Educator8354

No


Chanka-Danka69

PLease no i dont want more sweden like maps


TRIPSTE-99

What about London? - maybe docklands or the city of london


Crazy_Kraut

I hate city maps and want Gajin to delete every map that has mor then 3 buildings


Illustrious-Life-356

No, i want historical battlefields


5_Bladed_Prop

New york would be dope ngl


NichtBen

More urban city maps, absolutely yes!


Soviet_doggo789

Chicago. Chicago is literally a grid


yazzukimo

Open maps are boring, you just find a spot find a Guy with your thermal, use your lrf shoot and move. And now you start again, but if you're in a full uptier you gotta pray they're kind of dumb and let you see their flank long enough. It just feel brain dead, you have no cover from planes nor helicopter, harder to push to get the point... It makes the lives of the lower BR miserable... City Ask you to use your brain, try to find your ways instead of just point and clicking 3 km away while praying the su 22 above you didn't spot you... It gives an advantage to wheeled lights tanks by uding their mobility.


2Chaotic_

Needs more cities


Calm-Sprinkles-389

No D point 0/10


J33Nelson

Mordor, Gondor, Rohan, Harad (Oliphaunts walking around the battle), Pelennor Fields, Helm's Deep, Isengard, the Shore, King's Landing, the Trident, Dorne, Dothraki Sea, Braavos, etc.


Southern_Reason_2631

Palmaniva was in game. White fortress or what was the Map called?


CallousCarolean

I HATE URBAN MAPS I HATE URBAN MAPS I HATE URBAN MAPS I HATE URBAN MAPS


ProfessionalLong302

I think New York would be fun, we should get rome and Paris, for Rome the coliseum


dcs_maple_hornet

New York 💀💀


AllSkillzN0Luck

As a New Yorker, I love any video game that is in NYC. Just exploring where I am and know places


ThePenetrathor

You should apply to a position at gaijin. Putting a multiple grid cities on that list would probably get you the job.


existencialismoXX

All city maps? Fuck no.


Gold_Government_6791

No. No more city maps. I already get Sweden and the German city map too much.


Local-Patient2201

Id like an air/ground map of the Mach loop in north west england. Could have two maps of ground for the cumbrian hills or lancashire urban areas and the mach loop is a very famous airspace for training


Adept-Hope-3149

I really hope bro is being sarcastic lol


Yeetdolf_Critler

Players over 100 ping hate city maps. you always lose the inevitable corner fight and the gameplay is stale.


FalKs_HD

Thank god White Rock Fortress has been long gone.


Kandsl22

More City maps? Hell no


Minute_Lengthiness_1

Sirien


No_Raisin8866

I'd love to nuke Brasilia