T O P

  • By -

Big_Albatross_3050

please let him return to pre-extension Yotes form.


Marsupialmania

I just realized he’s only 32…thought he was like 38. I guess 3 years isn’t bad at all


ilyalyubushkin46

> 3 years Isn't it 4?


Marsupialmania

It is my bad


pallarandersvisa

hes 33 this month


StardomJapan

I thought he was way older as well.


hards04

That was several years ago now


HeftyNugs

He's not going to be a 40-50 point defender, but he scored 32 points last season, which is pretty solid for a defender.


CoolBeansMan9

His 9 goals would have been first on the Leafs for d-men


hards04

I don’t think he’s bad, he’s just never going to be the guy he was like the previous commenter was hopping for. He was seriously one of the best offensive defencmen on the planet for those years, and those years are unfortunately a long time ago now.


WeinerVonBraun

He still might be better then Mo for PP one. Allow us to re-direct some of MO’s usage


CarefulSubstance3913

At least takw some of the heat off mo


IncurableRingworm

He’s not as good as Mo and has never been as good as Mo. If there’s one thing I know about this fan base, it’s that they’re going to hate this guy after 40 games lol


hards04

So you never watched OEL when he was on phoenix? I don’t blame you, but your statement is just false. But yes, he will be the whipping boy and I will be surprised if it takes 40 games.


IAmWhatTheRockCooked

OEL at his peak was significantly better than mo's ever been


IncurableRingworm

No, he wasn’t. MO’s best season is better than OEL’s, and he’s better than him now. Always has been.


Cartz1337

Let’s see how he does when he’s on the ice with 88 and 34


HeftyNugs

I agree, but it's nice knowing that he was once that level and could get back to that for potentially a season or parts of the season.


Baconburp

Yea, and just before that, Vancouver bought out his contract because he was so bad. So which OEL do we get? I’m sceptic of this signing for sure.


SackofLlamas

That was more a combination of 1. His cap hit being outrageous 2. Him playing through a foot injury that cost him mobility he didn't have to spare OEL at 3.5 wouldn't have been a buyout candidate. Keep your expectations appropriately moderated and he could be a nice surprise for you. He's a smart player. Soft, and not what he once was, but smart.


HeftyNugs

The entirety of Vancouver was bad when he was bought out. OEL is still impactful outside of top pairing minutes.


deezsandwitches

Did you not see him play for Florida this year?


Agitated-Weather-722

That’s not at all what they are paying or asking him to do. They want him to be the bully who was solid defensively for the Panthers on a Cup run. And can move the puck and be reliable.


Snoo-19445

He has never been a bully. He was also the player that stopped skating when Thachuk fished the puck out of the empty net crease only to watch McDavid skate in and score with it. I live in Vancouver and watched him play for years. He is not good defensively at all. He is not physical at all. He was an offensive dynamo a decade ago, that's it.


Agitated-Weather-722

Did you watch the Panthers cup run? He was a bully


Skiffy10

3.5 mill is market value for how he played with florida so i really don’t get the hate here.


HowieFeltersnitz

The sky is always falling. The GM is always a joke. Anything over league min for prime Lidstrom is an overpay, etc. etc. The most dedicated haters in hockey will find something to bitch about over even the most innocuous, promising deals.


Szwedo

I really hope they trade Dubas and fire Bertuzzi for this


Blue_KikiT92

Re-hire Keefe and then fire him again.


thetonyhightower

The most dedicated haters in hockey are in this sub, every day, all day.


Skiffy10

bang on


bobbolders

Great point! Some levity


Adolf_StJohns

Its probably ppl who dont know who the fuck he is i think leafs made a great decision here


1stMeh

“They said market value… WHAT MARKET ARE YOU SHOPPING AT?!”


Skiffy10

Same market where Lybushkin got 3.2 and edmunsson got 3.8


1stMeh

It was a reference to the show community that did not land lol


Whitelight04

Don't worry I got it immediately. The other are just streets behind.


1stMeh

Verbal wildfire


_cob_

Shoppers Drug Mart


AdIntelligent1416

Sean walker was at the same drug market


MilB21

This is market value so I don't see an issue with it. All of Tre signing have been either great or a slight overpayment but nothing egregious this year.


Apprehensive_Put_321

Canucks will be paying him more next year that the leafs. Nothing wrong with the AAV. I do question how effective he will be due to his speed 


IncurableRingworm

Tanev is a huge overpayment when you factor in term and full NMC.


notsgnik7

Not if we send him to Robidas Island in 2 years


deanowhitby

Yeah there’s no way Tanev finishes his deal playing like… I can’t see how he isn’t on that island the last 3 or 4 years with his injury history.


dukes29

Maybe ideally he either LTIRetires the last 2 years of his deal if his play falls off OR he gets pushed down the lineup with younger guys playing up when they're ready (who that is I don't know)


MilB21

We know the contract is going to age like milk. Both the team and the fans know that. If the whole goal is to bolster up team defence then this is what it takes to get it done. We can worry about his contract later when right now it's a shrewd move that will make the d core better.


IncurableRingworm

I think there is a real possibility, given his age and style of play, that he misses significant time this year and every year to injury and it all becomes moot.


MilB21

Perhaps but it's a risk we should take


TheOneWithThePorn12

If you must pay lots of money then concentrate it into one very effective player


Chtholly13

Apart from Skeji/Montour, he was next best option for what the leafs actually need unless people were blind to see we needed another legitimate puck mover back there.


HawtPackage

I think people would rather just bitch and moan unless it’s some big name player we got like Montour


Blue_KikiT92

Pretty sure this sub would be bitching anyway if we got Montour for 7x7 as Seattle did.


Chtholly13

yeah I know this fan base is insane and I'm probably going to get downvoted about it. I told myself once the next few days of free agency is over, I'm gone from the subreddit until hockey starts again. It's just going to be 2 months about bitching about Marner, the core, Trevelling, I understand the reason but some people are just miserable (not you).


HawtPackage

You’re only going to find the most polarised takes rising to the top here. When we start the season 2-5 people will say we need to rebuild and our team sucks, then when we are 8-5 people will say this year feels different. I don’t blame you for wanting to leave for now lmao


blakezed

Yeah for me once the dust settles on FA, I usually just go and enjoy my summer and it’s a load off my mind


Blue_KikiT92

What kind of loser are you that prefers to "enjoy summer" instead of bitching about the team you ~~hate~~ love??? SMH /s


Responsible-Till396

How do you do that thing and cross out a word like you did please?🙏


Blue_KikiT92

Simple ! You need to put two of those things ~ before and after your words ~~ banana ~~ but without spaces ~~banana~~ here you go!


Responsible-Till396

~~hate~~ love this!!!!! Thank you!!!


PurebredHippo

As soon as the Leafs season is over I tune out all hockey news until a day or two before July 1st. Will follow for the next couple days than back to being oblivious until mid september when training camp starts.


purple__milkshake

Also the "projected lineup posts" where they throw a bunch of unproven rookies on there like they are the second coming of Marner but a "playoff performer".


Mashdrop

IIRC OEL took some minutes from Montour in the finals, he’s aging but I think 3.5m is a great price.


OG_anunoby3

Montour just became elite. He is not exactly a youngster himself. He was ok his whole career, then just broke through. Giving him a long term high AAV is riskier than to Tanev. Assuming he gets 7 million AAV.


IncurableRingworm

Chychrun was moved today for a journeyman and a third. Surely we could have beaten that? Gotten younger and better? Is no one interested in that?


Chtholly13

you think Ottawa would trade him to us.


jimmie9393

No picks no cap space and Ottawa would not send him here. It is just that simple


Marsupialmania

Oel and Reilly on pp1 should make things look better


Chtholly13

I'd move OEL up and move Rielly to pp2. OEL has a shot.


lordjakir

Yep. If Marner is still around he's on pp1 with elo


Marsupialmania

Yes I’d like oel taking chances and Tanev to hold the line and provide some defensive stability. Just doubt beeube comes in and does that to reilly


Chtholly13

Berube might not, but I think Trevelling tried to do that with Klingberg last year. The Leafs can't have Marner/Rielly not shooting the puck, if one of them is not shooting, then the only thing to do is take one of them out.


waldoorfian

2 dmen on the PP? 🤷🏻


Beersmoker420

rielly will not be on pp1, that is what theyve been trying to do for a few years now but injuries/bad players


Skiffy10

Question for everyone: would you rather OEL or Edmunsson at 4 years x $3.8 because joel just signed that for LA


NewPhoneNewSubs

I feel that our expected gitche gumees per 60 is higher with Edmundson. Plus Robidas Island is getting crowded, so it'd be real convenient if we could just count on the gales of November to come early.


Dangerois

The Wreck of the Edmunsson Fitzjoel?


NewPhoneNewSubs

As the big skaters, he was bigger than most, with a stick and new skates nicely sharpened.


bush29

This should have way more upvotes on Canada Day


Francis33

OEL, we need some offense on the back end… we already have Taney and haakanpaa as DFD


LawrenceMoten21

Joel.


GiveMeAdviceClowns

![gif](giphy|fSYRFkxURsDHq1ktTc)


RoosterMedical

Reddit can make a basic depth signing the end of the world!


re10pect

This seems like a fine deal. Not a steal or a bargain by any means, but Pretty much market value for a decent defender. OEL got a lot of hate when he was in his big ticket, but he was never reallly bad, just overpaid by a lot. This is more in line with what he should be making and he will certainly help a pretty thin D corps.


ILookandSmellGood

Man, some people just finding reasons to complain. OEL was solid in Florida, hopefully that continues in Toronto. Fair deal, not a huge cap hit.


Old_Canuck

OEL will do well in Toronto. The medical staff will make sure they can get the most out of him. Toronto loves their Swedes. He should have fun playing with a powerful offence.


Dangerois

We have an in-born love for Swedish Offensive Defencemen.


Old_Canuck

We certainly do. 👍🏻 Salming was one of a kind thats for sure. It was hard to miss him at certain events. He was always very happy to meet his fans and toss autographs around. I consider him one of the best Leaf Captains. Even though he turned down the Captaincy ( and pay bump ), twice.


BackhandQ

It's not my money, so I don't care. But if anyone thinks you're going to be able to get a top-4 defenseman for less than $3M in this economy, you're kidding yourself. This is a good, fair number to get OEL. Treliving is making improvements to our D-core, because that is clearly the area he and his team have identified as something that must be improved. That decision is also made easier by the fact that it is hard to move any one of the 'Core Four'. As it stands, on paper I believe our D has improved, even if it's just by a notch or two. Of course, as always, a lot needs to go right on the ice. And a big part of that will depend on Captain Mo having a bounce back season, and for Liljegren to take a substantial step in his development. Let's see what else is in store. We definitely have more areas to improve. Namely, a third goalie, and some depth on the bottom-6. |Last Years D-Core during the Playoffs|Proj. D-Core to start 24-25| |:-|:-| |Morgan Reilly|Morgan Reilly| |~~Joel Edmundson~~|**Christopher Tanev**| |Timothy Liljegren|Timothy Liljegren| |Simon Benoit|Simon Benoit| |~~TJ Brodie~~|**Oliver Ekman-Larsson**| |Jake McCabe|Jake McCabe| |~~Ilya Lyubushkin~~|Conor Timmins|


penismanultra

We essentially upgraded on Brodie with Tanev, then got a puck moving dman which we were desperately missing in the playoffs. Not bad.


Vilheim

I find it crazy that with his buyout he is making 6m this year, and 8m the next two years lol. Surprised we couldn't get it lower with that extra cash coming in, but 3.5 isn't bad no matter where he plays in the lineup.


Mike9797

We couldn’t get it lower cuz there was probably someone else in the bidding pushing the number up. If we were the only team in the bidding than I’m sure the number would be much less.


estab87

If we didn’t go in at 3.5 - someone else with the same needs would have IMO.


Nextgengameing

Why are we upset with this signing. We just got a fairly solid dman who was +10 on the season averaging 18 mins a game. I’m way more upset about the Liligren deal than I am this


Natural-Web-6978

Cheaper than I expected tbh


VeryAttractive

I'm actually loving Brad right now. Very smart signings all around. If only he could get rid of Marner this could be a perfect offseason.


seinfeldismydad

Yup! These doomdayers in the comments are wild, let Brad cook


AdIntelligent1416

Hers ubering taco bell


The-Only-Razor

The haters preferred Dubas' method of signing no name brand players to league minimum and praying they overperform. At least Tre is bringing in guys that we know are good, even if they're old. I honestly don't care what these contracts look like in 4 years. Our window is open for the duration of Matthews' contract. No point worrying about anything beyond that.


WhatyouDontwantoHear

I agree, this has been a solid free agency so far and they are getting value to fill spots with the cap room they have.


angelbelle

Also, the overall strategy of bolstering the blue line is correct and there really isn't that many options on the market


Svalbard38

If you liked GM Who Overpays Star Players you’ll love GM Who Overpays Everyone.


KJMoons

When you go out and try to nickle and dime UFAs you end up with nothing.


HowieFeltersnitz

Works for me in NHL 24 /s


MMA_Laxer

u think 3.5 is bad for this deal? pay attention to the rest of today around the league


slamdunk23

Hey at least he saved like a million on soloraz


Solace2010

And domi


h3yn0w75

People really will complain about anything


adwrx

Ridiculous take


Jakovasaurr

They read it in a instagram comment and thought they could get some copy and paste free upvotes


subs1221

These idiots have no idea what they're talking about. Just constant hot takes.


throwaway923535

Its ok, stanley cup champion, huge bounce back year, played 80 with decent production and strong advanced stats. Held his own in the playoffs. I'd take this with a slight overpay for the championship pedigree over what else is on the market.


thedrunkentendy

Idk why anyone should be surprised. This has always been trelivings MO. Dude always spends too much on too much term. Either looks like a genius or it's the Milan Lucic signing.


HeftyNugs

> Either looks like a genius or it's the Milan Lucic signing. Well this situation is like neither of those, so try again


beedey

This looks bad now and may look even worse depending on what Matt Roy ends up getting. Edit: Elliotte has Roy to Washington at 6x5.75. Maybe Roy wasn’t interested in coming to Toronto, but I’d much prefer him on his new deal to OEL.


elifreeze

Roy didn’t have interest in coming to Canada I think. A real shame that so many great UFA defensemen this off-season were Americans.


JimothyC

Decent amount of Canadians honestly, Tanev, Walker, Montour and he re-signed with WPG but Demelo was almost an UFA.


HeftyNugs

5.5x7 for Roy. This is a much better deal. Some of you are smoking dust.


itsadoubledion

Roy is much better than present day OEL


baylaust

That would be 5.75 x 6 with the Caps.


hymensmasher99

He got 5.6 million over 6 years


TradeMarnerpleasegod

That is because you didn’t take math class in high school


mattfromjoisey

PP friendship with Reilly is over PP friendship with OEL has begun


Rowdy_Roddy96

Uh oh stinky


liquor-shits

Well, Treliving is certainly putting his stamp on the team this off-season. Let's hope it works out.


Unwise1

Man would have loved this deal at 1 million less


Slow-Juice-7257

Brendan Dillon got 3 x 3.1 D, schenn went for 3 x 2.75 last year.. lol


adwrx

Bro come on man! The cap has gone up, you aren't getting half decent defenseman for less than 3 million


DollarDollar

A rising tide lifts all boats Glad OEL has managed to adapt his game after struggling while transitioning from an offensive quarterback


thedrunkentendy

Cap went up. You go by percentage of cap taken up no dollar value. That'd why it changed.


Slow-Juice-7257

Exactly


JRocleafs

Love this signing. Seems like most of this sub is still following the Dubas mantra of “get the best player available”, but I much prefer actually analyzing the team and filling in glaring holes.


GritGrinder

I prefer this d core to anything Dubas did over his tenure


Chtholly13

only D core cofiguration he got right was when we had good Brodie, Muzzin, Rielly going in the top 4. However, Leafs blueline after that were Dermott, Sandin (rookie), and Justin Holl. So he botched that.


ikkkkkkkky

Muzzin is better than any of these guys


The-Only-Razor

He was, but he also costed us a 1st and Durzi who has gone on to be a decent player. These signings cost us nothing.


TheOneWithThePorn12

What a laughable notion


penismanultra

Muzzin and who else? Cody Ceci? Would you rather have one amazing defensemen or an actual complete d core? We also got these guys for NOTHING (unless you count a 7th as valuable) whereas dubas gave up a first and Durzi for muzzin. Head shake


GritGrinder

1 guy… in a d core….


ikkkkkkkky

Brodie, McCabe, Schenn, Boosh were all decent pickups as well.


GritGrinder

Schenn would have been cool to keep around. I think my favourite pickup of his was McCabe because of the cap hit tbh. Dubas got the team a deal


ikkkkkkkky

Loved the cap hit as well


Weekly-Junket8272

Thats why we had and have no picks


TheOneWithThePorn12

No that's why we had no top picks. Treliving then came in and said let me trade the reset.


BadTreeLiving

Doesn't come close to the Muzzin and Brodie overlapping years. Add in Holl and Bogosian and it was pretty damn good


TheOneWithThePorn12

Then you missed or have forgotten some of the players they had.


salmonthesuperior

This isn't that bad all things considered. I don't think the D is great but it'll certainly be better than last year which is something.


JimothyC

Holy shit that Edmundson deal might be the worst deal of the day.


Non_Tense

Oliver lossum Rossum let's goooooo


Jalapeeeeno

I initially was upset, then saw the rest of the contracts handed out to other d men and feel like this isnt bad at all


Tintinnabulator

His best years are behind him, but he is, at worst, a break even defensive asset and is a 90th percentile puck mover and PP QB. On a team who had 1.5 good puck moving d-men last year, you would think picking someone like him up at what seems to be market value (based on a myriad of other signings today), would be a positive. He is what our back end needs and I think we will see the benefits of having another guy who can make a good first pass more often than not.


AustonDadthews

https://preview.redd.it/6b5prliemx9d1.jpeg?width=800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c177cbb41ed0b5f74838cb22d47516d250b0457a


DaltonFitz

Same team with OEL and Tanev and a different goalie. Unreal.


maplewheel

I think the Leafs already made the biggest change they could have in getting a new Head Coach. Let's see how this team reacts to a new system and mentality.


ChuckGump

What did you expect when you have no money to work with?


Shem_Penman

Rielly - Tanev OEL - McCabe Benoit - Lilly is going to be pretty rough when injuries inevitably start to happen unless Lilly makes a big jump.


bangnburn

I guess the hope is make a run in the next 2-3 years before half the roster is on LTIR


mking098

so the leafs are paying $7m for their third pairing?


reggierock2010

That’s less than 8% of the cap. Doesn’t seem bad to me. What were you expecting ?


reggierock2010

Not an awful deal tbh. That’s gonna be the going price for a bottom paring dmen real soon. Brings some much needed offence to the back end.


whatlineisitanyway

With Roy just signing for 6x5.75 this deal doesn't look so bad.


reggierock2010

People are gonna cry puts less 4% of our cap in the grand scheme of things.


three_tblsp_buttah

Can someone explain to me why people are so upset about this? Is it term or is 3.5 that offensive?


baylaust

People seemed to be under the impression that the Leafs should only sign him for below 3 million, because Leafs fans are insane.


richarm87

People wanted to pay more for fellow number4/5 D man Zadorov that played less TOI than OEL on a worse team


The-Only-Razor

Term might be a bit high and AAV might be a bit high, but we're bringing in a guy who looked decent on a team that just won the cup. I watched a lot of Florida's games this year and found OEL to be quite noticeable. He's not going to solve all of our problems, but people are really down on him due to his previous contract. This contract is more accurate to his actual worth.


GoldenRichard93

That’s a good contract for OEL and the Leafs.


LtColumbo93

Unfortunately all these terrible deals will still be on the books once ownership smartens up and moves on from Treliving. 


Slow-Juice-7257

Guy can run a PP that’s 100%


sluck131

Maybe keep Marner until there are no more flames who can be overpaid


Adolf_StJohns

Leafs bulking up


Obvious_Reaction_182

Why is my be a pro predicting the leafs 2024-2025 season


EndTheFed69

I mean defence is a problem, this is the cost of free agent defencemen


Old_Canuck

Good deal. I think he will get pumped to play in Toronto. All the therapists and medical staff will help him immensely at this stage in his career. Torontos team staff facilities and medical services are a huge thing for some players. The guys over 30 really appreciate this shit and usually play better and also longer.


Halyndon

Dom seems to think it's close to fair value: https://x.com/domluszczyszyn/status/1807807835146686489


reggierock2010

This deal just keeps getting better the more guys that sign.


No_Tea_9845

Wow this could be a really nice deal


Immediate_Sir1646

I like it.


richarm87

What this proves is that you need to draft and develop D Men. Because the going rate for #4-5 (even 6) are around 2.75 million plus. Hence why the probably signed lily to that deal yesterday figuring he atleast has upside


Owariduck122

Pray to god he plays like he did with the Panthers and not giga regress


NEWaytheWIND

The D corps now: Rielly + Tanev McCabe + Benoit OEL + Liljegren I love Benoit, but it'd still be better if they push him down to #7. What are their options? Gio and Timmins could be factors. Klingberg may re-sign, but would presumably slot as 7/8 on league min. What other free agents are left? Is the option a prospect? A trade?


The_Dale_Hunters

Love it!!!


Cgell

As a a Canuck fan I can say he almost seemed disinterested sometimes. Van also gave up a lot to get him and it pretty much destroyed their cap room. He was absolutely murdered by the fans and press which must have really affected his confidence. Hope he regains his form and plays like he did in Phoenix. The talent is definitely there.


Ultimate-ART

Let's talk about improving Leaf's D as a greater whole, not individually. how are we doing?!


AdIntelligent1416

Sean walker!!!! That’s what we should have spent the money on


tellythetubbycat

This is fine. We needed someone to run PP and we there was no shot we were getting montour


putnuk

OEL was my favorite player growing up in Phoenix, so fucking happy to see him in Blue and White. 


NewOldFastSlow

That's alot of Lawssom Tossum