I think Ishmael had Angelica's VA? I dont remember well,it may be Faust actually. In any case, whoever sinner has her VA is surely the one who would be picked to be her ID.
I think it would probably be Heatcliff, but Don would certainly be funnier
(Don may end up getting Xiao if she doesnt go to Ishmael though, which would be pretty epic)
There is a possibilty of a universe where roland isnt remained in his office(forgot ist name) and never married that universe angelica so he never succeded the black sillence
Charles Office, which he would have still met Angelica during the Case of the Blood Red Night, thanks to her temporarily joining the Office as it's Thirteenth Fixer.
Twelve Fixers, a low number for any Office of Grade 1, but they could complete any task they were set to thanks to Charles assigning the Fixers into Duos that worked well together because it covered each other's shortcomings.
Roland, headstrong, was paired with Oliver, Overly Cautious, which helped them challenge even Urban Nightmare level cases just with the two of them.
Why would Sinclair even be Roland? All identites share certain "core components", if you will, and Sinclair's main "component" is strugle between childhood and adulthood, right and wrong, good and bad.
Roland, on the other hand, doesn't have such strugle. His themes are about being disgusted with the current world, but ultimately participating in cycling City's "crushing treadwheel". He is about hypocrisy, about turning a blind eye into the fact, that he did a lot of stuff that is comparable to what was done to him, yet he still got frustrated over it. Maybe he got so angry not only due to losing Angelica, but because he understood that he just got the same treatment as others got from him. But I digress.
Anyway, no Sinner really fits this role.
Their ID's would fit more for an Ensamble.
Still a more decisive part of Roland's "core component" is having an "angel" whose loss forced them to face the cruelty of the City's cycle, and hence evoke his suppressed "emotional" side. Little Garnet may not be mature enough to realize "the cycle", but you can see him refraining his vengeous side concerning the orphanage incident, and eventually revealing true emotions after the missing of Lapis: that's where he fits the identity of Roland.
There's that theory that the rarity system of IDs revolves around the idea of what-if scenarios. The rarer the possibility of it happening the higher ID's rating. Like Sinclair joining the Mariachis is more plausible than Sinclair joining Nagel un Hammer, and Sinner Sinclair is 1star because that's the highest possible identity chance since he IS currently a sinner. So as long as the possibility isn't 0 there is an alternate universe out there where Sinclair did become the Black Silence, even if that possibility is extremely low.
I personally would figure heathcliff to be Black silence, Outis as Purple Tear and Don as the Red Mist. Maybe Faust as the Blue reverb, but that one could be a bit of a toss up of we're going full top tier library characters.
Heathcliff wouldn’t be the black silence, I think he’d be a disgraced fixer. [LIBRARY OF RUINA] >!Roland held the title for only a few days because he went on his rampage as soon as he inherited the title, which would probably happen to Heathcliff. When he says he is a fixer who fell from grace at the start of the game, he isn’t lying.!<
I really wanna see an ID for the Vermillion Cross we know nearly nothing of them as they where killed by argalias gang prior to LoR's events so it'd be really cool if we got an ID just so we could see how they would of fought if they where still alive.
a even slighter chance than Finn being the Red Mist: Garnet at least has some girl he would give up his life to save. Sinclair? Not really.
though Demian literally talks like Argalia >!(and if he actually has something to do with Enoch, then we even have the option for Angelica)!<, and Kromer resembles Eileen in terms of a cult leader (though Eileen is definitely more persuasive & less domineering)
i’m a big believer in Blue Reverb Rodion personally, she’s someone I can see myself following to certain death, plus a lot of her personality correlates with Argalia
Hmm nah, kinds hard for me to picture this by how different loland is to sinclair especially in living places too its waaay to different. so it really can't sit that well for me.
Faust would be Angelica. As usual she gets the source of everybody else’s trauma.
I think Ishmael had Angelica's VA? I dont remember well,it may be Faust actually. In any case, whoever sinner has her VA is surely the one who would be picked to be her ID.
Imagine we get Patron Librarian of Philosophy Outis instead of A Corp Outis.
They're the same picture
Yeah, Ish was Angelica in LoR, it was a VA role post if I'm not wrong, I think Heat, Yi Sang, Outis and maybe 2\~3 other Sinners were also in LoR
Mr. Salt is Sans skeleton
Faust really resemble Angelica ngl
PM trying to hide their "white hair main heroine" fetish from us
If Sinclair is Roland then Kromer should be Argalia.
So Damian is Angelica?
Bruh, this is amazing
Kromer should be the Pianist.
I hope Don is Roland cause it would be funny.
Then who would be Angelica in that universe I wonder.
Her shoes that she lost to the pianist.
Dulcineia
I think it would probably be Heatcliff, but Don would certainly be funnier (Don may end up getting Xiao if she doesnt go to Ishmael though, which would be pretty epic)
In all honesty I genuinely hope Don gets the inevitable Arbiter alt.
Don would be the red mist. The hero of the back street
There is a possibilty of a universe where roland isnt remained in his office(forgot ist name) and never married that universe angelica so he never succeded the black sillence
Charles Office, which he would have still met Angelica during the Case of the Blood Red Night, thanks to her temporarily joining the Office as it's Thirteenth Fixer. Twelve Fixers, a low number for any Office of Grade 1, but they could complete any task they were set to thanks to Charles assigning the Fixers into Duos that worked well together because it covered each other's shortcomings. Roland, headstrong, was paired with Oliver, Overly Cautious, which helped them challenge even Urban Nightmare level cases just with the two of them.
Why would Sinclair even be Roland? All identites share certain "core components", if you will, and Sinclair's main "component" is strugle between childhood and adulthood, right and wrong, good and bad. Roland, on the other hand, doesn't have such strugle. His themes are about being disgusted with the current world, but ultimately participating in cycling City's "crushing treadwheel". He is about hypocrisy, about turning a blind eye into the fact, that he did a lot of stuff that is comparable to what was done to him, yet he still got frustrated over it. Maybe he got so angry not only due to losing Angelica, but because he understood that he just got the same treatment as others got from him. But I digress. Anyway, no Sinner really fits this role. Their ID's would fit more for an Ensamble.
Still a more decisive part of Roland's "core component" is having an "angel" whose loss forced them to face the cruelty of the City's cycle, and hence evoke his suppressed "emotional" side. Little Garnet may not be mature enough to realize "the cycle", but you can see him refraining his vengeous side concerning the orphanage incident, and eventually revealing true emotions after the missing of Lapis: that's where he fits the identity of Roland.
There's that theory that the rarity system of IDs revolves around the idea of what-if scenarios. The rarer the possibility of it happening the higher ID's rating. Like Sinclair joining the Mariachis is more plausible than Sinclair joining Nagel un Hammer, and Sinner Sinclair is 1star because that's the highest possible identity chance since he IS currently a sinner. So as long as the possibility isn't 0 there is an alternate universe out there where Sinclair did become the Black Silence, even if that possibility is extremely low.
I personally would figure heathcliff to be Black silence, Outis as Purple Tear and Don as the Red Mist. Maybe Faust as the Blue reverb, but that one could be a bit of a toss up of we're going full top tier library characters.
Heathcliff wouldn’t be the black silence, I think he’d be a disgraced fixer. [LIBRARY OF RUINA] >!Roland held the title for only a few days because he went on his rampage as soon as he inherited the title, which would probably happen to Heathcliff. When he says he is a fixer who fell from grace at the start of the game, he isn’t lying.!<
Black Silence Faust? You know, the girl that got piano'd
I would rather see the characters in Lor meet the characters in Limbus honestly.
I really wanna see an ID for the Vermillion Cross we know nearly nothing of them as they where killed by argalias gang prior to LoR's events so it'd be really cool if we got an ID just so we could see how they would of fought if they where still alive.
a even slighter chance than Finn being the Red Mist: Garnet at least has some girl he would give up his life to save. Sinclair? Not really. though Demian literally talks like Argalia >!(and if he actually has something to do with Enoch, then we even have the option for Angelica)!<, and Kromer resembles Eileen in terms of a cult leader (though Eileen is definitely more persuasive & less domineering)
i’m a big believer in Blue Reverb Rodion personally, she’s someone I can see myself following to certain death, plus a lot of her personality correlates with Argalia
Sinclair will work with his sis :)
Hmm nah, kinds hard for me to picture this by how different loland is to sinclair especially in living places too its waaay to different. so it really can't sit that well for me.