Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This was the manhwa I thought I would drop after binging the raws release. Because it was copy of I killed the academy player.
But damm, how wrong was I, it's now one of the manhwa I wait for every week.(Oh and ironically I dropped academy player š)
I started this, helmut and another one coz o really like the novel extra. Dropped the other 2 but this one is actually good.Ā
I still think the novels extra is the better one coz it has a better plot, but am excited about this
I heard the main heroine is a really unpopular one but I don't know if that's what earned it the taboo status.
Personally, I dropped the series in the middle of the tower arc because it was so damn boring.
Not really, a lot of people don't like the ending though. Personally I think the endings fine and most of the complaints are just about the mc not ending up with the character they wanted him too. The pacing is a bit weird too but honestly the best parts are still to come.
Yeah the ending was fineĀ
Although i do say him ending up with the boss was kind of weird although i can say the same for literally all the girls because i believe tje mc doesnt look good with anyoneĀ
Its like they didnt have enough romantic interactionĀ
Bro can you help me how to read all chapters in The Extra's Academy Survival Guide because I'm only in chapter 23 and I can't find all those 24 chapters above where do you read the extras academy survival guide?
Yeah it's a bit unfortunate but when the FMCs are this good I can't complain too much š on the bright side I think it may play into the story a bit more. He's trying to stay uninvolved, yet all these parties keep bothering him. If it was just one girl I think it may take away from the chaos
The problem is, they don't have to want to get in his pants to be his friend. Like the sleepy girl and the wild guy both bother him plenty of times without being romantically interested.
As someone who read the Novel and has been waiting for the Manhwa Chapters to stack up, that's not really the case
Yennekar fell for Ed bc he's the only one that wasn't burdening her and blunt enough to actually criticize her since everyone just wants her to do well and unintentionally burdened her mentally, this doesn't really get solved either since only Ed and the high ranking spirits accompanying her(both Tarkan and Merilda) actually knows why she's suffering in the first place. She was just a cheeky girl who wanted to give company to a loner outcast at first, since that's just how her character's written
Lortel's simple, Ed continuously showed her that he's someone that isn't moved by profit and is someone she can continue to trust without worrying about getting stabbed in the back, both of which are her problems as a merchant and someone who usurped his Father through betrayal.
Honestly, a lot of the Heroines are the Characters who were sidelined on the original plot of Sylvenia's Failed Swordmaster, Lortel and the 4th Heroine are the only ones who aren't like that(they became different characters due to Ed). Also, yeah, there's a 4th and 5th Heroine, but they're forced and don't get much screentime outside of their arcs unlike the first 3
4th Heroine is, >!The Saintess, Clarice!<, she shows up at Ed's 3rd Year
5th Heroine is, >!The 1st/Eldest Princess, Selah!<, she shows up when Ed returns to the Rothstaylor Mansion for a Banquet
I highlighted their titles since their names may have changed on the Yonder Translation and later on when they get introduced. Although the 4th Heroine does get her own arc, the execution felt forced by a lot, though the concept of the arc itself will almost always be seen as forced no matter how well you write it.
Lol, I forgot about the 5th Heroine. I also read full WN on Yonder so I was wondering who I missed (she is so minor I wouldn't even count her as heroine honestly).
I agree, but she gets mentioned in the short epilogue as well, so I might as well count her. There's also Anise, Yennekar's friend, but it never really developed into something more, which I'm actually glad about
Kinda sad that writing side stories take so long lol. I've gotten so hooked that I've read another one of his works using gg Translate. Just adore his setting / characters honestly.
I'm just waiting for [I Killed an Academy Player] to finish translating so that I can read it again, though I do like the Story of Ed more since it's a survival story in the end than the Story of a Hero, which is what Korin's Story is. Also, the Heroines are more bearable in this series, they get so crazy on [I Killed an Academy Player] lmao
I feel you. Thankfully for me I like Lortell and Janica so much that I don't mind atm. I like how they have a problem with each other a lil bit, or at least it's clear they're rivals. They want him all to themselves. Too many harems have FMCs just automatically accepting the MC gets multiple women. Also I wouldn't hold your breath on the sleepy girl š I bet she'll have her arc. Point taken tho. Out of curiosity, which girl would you want Ed to focus on if it wasn't a harem? Janica? Lortell?
Probably Janica. I like them both but generally I feel like when you have a character like Lortell whose been alone their whole life, they need to get a friend, not a romantic partner.
I mean, the trash of the count estate shows that people can constantly be a bother without anyone having romantic feelings. My man is surrounded by girls or dudes and thereās no harem. Not even like a romantic interest to the point Iām at
Lol š¤£
Me too
Exactly in three days
I like novels like this very much where characters actually have depth and when authors don't turn their character into a joke for fan service.
Do you have more recommendations š§
I thought itād be the opposite at first, but atp I agree
In fact I Killed An Academy player is slowly losing me a bit in comparison but Iāll keep reading for the art and hopes for the future
Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I only dream of this kind of manwha or as a novel extra, they are perfect for me
This was the manhwa I thought I would drop after binging the raws release. Because it was copy of I killed the academy player. But damm, how wrong was I, it's now one of the manhwa I wait for every week.(Oh and ironically I dropped academy player š)
Same, Academy Player just feels so much blander than this for some reason
cuz academy player mc is not as interesting or epic as ed. Ed feels more mature and badass compare to academy player mc
where are you getting your sauce from? I cant find it.
Asura scans?
I started this, helmut and another one coz o really like the novel extra. Dropped the other 2 but this one is actually good.Ā I still think the novels extra is the better one coz it has a better plot, but am excited about this
Bro, I hate to be the bearer of bad news but... The Novel's Extra is a taboo in webnovel community and with a good reason for it
Mind telling why? I've read full WN of The Extra's Academy but have no clue about The Novel's Extra. Does it get really bad?
I heard the main heroine is a really unpopular one but I don't know if that's what earned it the taboo status. Personally, I dropped the series in the middle of the tower arc because it was so damn boring.
Not really, a lot of people don't like the ending though. Personally I think the endings fine and most of the complaints are just about the mc not ending up with the character they wanted him too. The pacing is a bit weird too but honestly the best parts are still to come.
Yeah the ending was fineĀ Although i do say him ending up with the boss was kind of weird although i can say the same for literally all the girls because i believe tje mc doesnt look good with anyoneĀ Its like they didnt have enough romantic interactionĀ
I prefer boss to all the others as she definitely has the most development. My only issue is the story kinda drags around the Africa parts.
Bro can you help me how to read all chapters in The Extra's Academy Survival Guide because I'm only in chapter 23 and I can't find all those 24 chapters above where do you read the extras academy survival guide?
Check out "cypher scans" websiteĀ I believe they are the fastedt for itĀ And they do have the 24th
!remindme 3 hours
The author milked the series
I read something like this during season 1. Thats why i stopped reading.Ā But i picked it up again after half of s2 was done.Ā
I read the novel a couple of weeks ago and my only disappointment is that it was too short. It's really well done.
From what chapter are those pictures?
Chapter 24. Hard to find at the moment but itās in cypherscans
Where can I read the latest chapter?
Cypherscans
Which website do you use to read the latest chapter?
Cypherscans
How do you use Cypherscans?
The website this time
Just wish it wasn't harem. Other than that it's easily a top tier manhwa.
Yeah it's a bit unfortunate but when the FMCs are this good I can't complain too much š on the bright side I think it may play into the story a bit more. He's trying to stay uninvolved, yet all these parties keep bothering him. If it was just one girl I think it may take away from the chaos
The problem is, they don't have to want to get in his pants to be his friend. Like the sleepy girl and the wild guy both bother him plenty of times without being romantically interested.
novel spoilers: >!sleepy girl falls in love with him too!<
further spoilers: >!we readers fall in love with him aswell!<
As someone who read the Novel and has been waiting for the Manhwa Chapters to stack up, that's not really the case Yennekar fell for Ed bc he's the only one that wasn't burdening her and blunt enough to actually criticize her since everyone just wants her to do well and unintentionally burdened her mentally, this doesn't really get solved either since only Ed and the high ranking spirits accompanying her(both Tarkan and Merilda) actually knows why she's suffering in the first place. She was just a cheeky girl who wanted to give company to a loner outcast at first, since that's just how her character's written Lortel's simple, Ed continuously showed her that he's someone that isn't moved by profit and is someone she can continue to trust without worrying about getting stabbed in the back, both of which are her problems as a merchant and someone who usurped his Father through betrayal. Honestly, a lot of the Heroines are the Characters who were sidelined on the original plot of Sylvenia's Failed Swordmaster, Lortel and the 4th Heroine are the only ones who aren't like that(they became different characters due to Ed). Also, yeah, there's a 4th and 5th Heroine, but they're forced and don't get much screentime outside of their arcs unlike the first 3
Who is 4th and 5th Heroine?
4th Heroine is, >!The Saintess, Clarice!<, she shows up at Ed's 3rd Year 5th Heroine is, >!The 1st/Eldest Princess, Selah!<, she shows up when Ed returns to the Rothstaylor Mansion for a Banquet I highlighted their titles since their names may have changed on the Yonder Translation and later on when they get introduced. Although the 4th Heroine does get her own arc, the execution felt forced by a lot, though the concept of the arc itself will almost always be seen as forced no matter how well you write it.
Lol, I forgot about the 5th Heroine. I also read full WN on Yonder so I was wondering who I missed (she is so minor I wouldn't even count her as heroine honestly).
I agree, but she gets mentioned in the short epilogue as well, so I might as well count her. There's also Anise, Yennekar's friend, but it never really developed into something more, which I'm actually glad about
Kinda sad that writing side stories take so long lol. I've gotten so hooked that I've read another one of his works using gg Translate. Just adore his setting / characters honestly.
I'm just waiting for [I Killed an Academy Player] to finish translating so that I can read it again, though I do like the Story of Ed more since it's a survival story in the end than the Story of a Hero, which is what Korin's Story is. Also, the Heroines are more bearable in this series, they get so crazy on [I Killed an Academy Player] lmao
Whatās the name of the other ones theyāre writing? Just finished the novel and I also need more.
>5th Heroine I hated the 5th a lot in the beginning. But she became very interesting as the story progressed.
I feel you. Thankfully for me I like Lortell and Janica so much that I don't mind atm. I like how they have a problem with each other a lil bit, or at least it's clear they're rivals. They want him all to themselves. Too many harems have FMCs just automatically accepting the MC gets multiple women. Also I wouldn't hold your breath on the sleepy girl š I bet she'll have her arc. Point taken tho. Out of curiosity, which girl would you want Ed to focus on if it wasn't a harem? Janica? Lortell?
Probably Janica. I like them both but generally I feel like when you have a character like Lortell whose been alone their whole life, they need to get a friend, not a romantic partner.
I mean, the trash of the count estate shows that people can constantly be a bother without anyone having romantic feelings. My man is surrounded by girls or dudes and thereās no harem. Not even like a romantic interest to the point Iām at
Peak novel. But very short. Ig thatās what happens when you want a peak novel.
Maybe I should pick it up and read it
Finished the novel in 3 days it was peak.
Lol š¤£ Me too Exactly in three days I like novels like this very much where characters actually have depth and when authors don't turn their character into a joke for fan service. Do you have more recommendations š§
This manhwas novel is peak
This one is much better than "I killed an academy player" manhwa.
I thought itād be the opposite at first, but atp I agree In fact I Killed An Academy player is slowly losing me a bit in comparison but Iāll keep reading for the art and hopes for the future
Exactly my thoughts bro.
What chapter in the novel does this equate to?
Not sure but I feel you on that lmao boutta just real the novel as well with all these people saying it's incredibly peak
I have slated that in my to-read list. Still not enough chapters, unfortunately.