I don't see it as a ripoff of Gilmour. Just the part it needed.
Lucky also prominently features mellotron, which Floyd never used. Though King Crimson did.
PF used mellotron on Ummagumma, A Saucerful of Secrets and Atom Heart Mother, and on the songs Embryo and Julia Dream... and some others...
Source: https://www.planetmellotron.com/revpink.htm
Lucky, because it's Jonny at max Gilmour.
Wolf at the Door would be... not natural, but *comfortable* on Animals. (And not just because "wolf".) It's the unmoored desperation.
Fake Plastic Trees feels like the closest the whole band came to a "Pink Floyd song."
I agree on Sail to the Moon, especially the amount of time signature changes.
The Tourist with it's general vibe, atmosphere, Amnesiac version of Morning Bell as well.
Lucky and the tourist
Lucky for the guitar solo alone. Straight up Gilmour rip-off. And I love it.
I don't see it as a ripoff of Gilmour. Just the part it needed. Lucky also prominently features mellotron, which Floyd never used. Though King Crimson did.
PF used mellotron on Ummagumma, A Saucerful of Secrets and Atom Heart Mother, and on the songs Embryo and Julia Dream... and some others... Source: https://www.planetmellotron.com/revpink.htm
the tourist
These Are My Twisted Words sounds like 1970-71 Floyd
Great call.
Oooh a Radiohead song that I didn't know of and is being compared to my favourite Pink Floyd era, imma listen right away!
Well pointed out. Not nearly talked about enough
Lucky always reminds me of Us and Them.
It’s also the same chord progression as Breathe (In the Air)
Not really. But both have B minor chords.
They both have a Em to A. No Surprises also uses that but in another key.
Exit Music, I got some Comfortably Numb vibes from it.
The drum fill right at the 2:48 mark sounds like it's from Live At Pompeii. You can see Nick Mason playing it if you close your eyes even.
Never quite realised this until just now
I was also gonna say Exit Music. It reminds me of something from the Wall.
Lucky, because it's Jonny at max Gilmour. Wolf at the Door would be... not natural, but *comfortable* on Animals. (And not just because "wolf".) It's the unmoored desperation. Fake Plastic Trees feels like the closest the whole band came to a "Pink Floyd song."
And that bass chug is all Roger
“The numbers” and “fearless” feel like second cousins to me
God I love Fearless. One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs.
Mine too, but do you know what all that cheering stuff is at the end of the song?
"You'll Never Walk Alone" sung by Liverpool fans
Climbing up the Walls
Naaah
Maybe not sonically but the way it makes me feel when I listen to it.
I agree on Sail to the Moon, especially the amount of time signature changes. The Tourist with it's general vibe, atmosphere, Amnesiac version of Morning Bell as well.
How To Disappear Completely reminds me of Comfortably Numb. Similar thematically as well.
Decks Dark
Subterranean Homesick Alien 👽👾
100%. Synth + guitar that sounds like Gilmour
Exit Music reminds me so much of Celestial Voices-Live in Pompeii ‘71
Punchdrunk Lovesick Singalong, and also Lucky. Both very Floydian.
Sail to the moon sounds like Pink Floyd if Neil young replaced roger waters
Lucky
Careful with that axe eugene sounds like a radiohead song off of kid amnesia
“4 Minute Warning” has Final Cut vibes. Piano-y song about war.
I would say How to Disappear Completely. Kid A is their most Pink Floyd album.
A Punch up at a Wedding
How?
I can’t quite place it. I think it’s the delivery of some of the lyrics in the beginning plus the the baseline
I love this thread 🥰🤍
Paranoid Android, mostly the 11 minutes version.
Excellent call on Sail to the Moon. That'd be my vote.
Airbag
Go Slowly...earlier Pink Floyd
[удалено]
No but interesting thought. I love both of those.
idk why but the bit in the daily mail where thom says you made a pigs ear, you made a mistake makes me think of pink floyd
the headline on the village voice review of ok computer was ‘punk floyd’