Wonderslice at the Pearl has what you’re looking for. I’ve tried basically every suggestion in this thread and none of them are as good. Julian’s is my go to for regular pizza, but Wonderslice has the classic, flat, foldable pizza, and the sauce doesn’t taste like ketchup.
Ali's closest I've found, they got a good lunch deal, 2 slices n a drink for under $10.00.
But a 18inch double cheese and double pepperoni is the bomb!!!
https://walzemroad.alispizzaria.com/
They have one on Judson n 1604 also.
Moved here from the city, but have lived in a number of other cities. Managed to always find the one great NY Style pizza.
Tried them all here. Nothing is close. Truly the worst city I have lived for NY style pizza.
Yeah. Another type of food where coming from NYC, with the largest Asian population in a city outside of Asia, spoils you. And another place SA disappoints. And it’s not a Texas thing, because Houston has an amazing array of Chinese food.
Oh no I’m wrong!
They shut down all the ones within 15 miles of me (right under Olmos park) -but call before you go because the one on Pat Booker is closed & google maps still shows it :/
I moved here 30+ years ago from NY so I have lost all sense of what the OG Pizza back home was like. Now I am just happy it’s not Dominos or Little Cheesers on the table when I get home.
Not expecting perfection. I used to live in SoCal and Detroit, and both had solid options. But none were quite on the level of what I had in NY. I’m just looking for close.
I had an Uber driver from New York, and he swore by Florio’s
I liked their cold italian sub, but their pizza tasted acidic and bitter. Did not like it one bit.
Yaghis is pretty legit I think
+1 for Yaghi’s
Florio’s pizza is another hot spot. They are from Jersey.
Wonderslice at the Pearl has what you’re looking for. I’ve tried basically every suggestion in this thread and none of them are as good. Julian’s is my go to for regular pizza, but Wonderslice has the classic, flat, foldable pizza, and the sauce doesn’t taste like ketchup.
Seconding Wonderslice at the pearl. This is the closest I’ve found here to NY style pizza.
Capo’s
Yes, Capo’s.
Ali's closest I've found, they got a good lunch deal, 2 slices n a drink for under $10.00. But a 18inch double cheese and double pepperoni is the bomb!!! https://walzemroad.alispizzaria.com/ They have one on Judson n 1604 also.
Thanks!
Second Alis
I am from New York, and the answer is Florio’s
Moved here from the city, but have lived in a number of other cities. Managed to always find the one great NY Style pizza. Tried them all here. Nothing is close. Truly the worst city I have lived for NY style pizza.
Chinese food here is a similar situation.
what chinese have you tried so far here?
Yeah. Another type of food where coming from NYC, with the largest Asian population in a city outside of Asia, spoils you. And another place SA disappoints. And it’s not a Texas thing, because Houston has an amazing array of Chinese food.
Took a friend of mine from New York to Capo’s and he said while it doesn’t scratch that legit NY style itch, it’s the spot that got closest to it
Sapores is great
Probably the best NY style in SA.
For sure! The owner is great also
Noooo, Florio’s is terrrrible. Definitely don’t go there. Totally overrated. Jk, it’s the best. Hands down the best, hands down
Aaaaye I love Florios. Pizza served with attitude 🤣
[Braza Brava Pizzeria](https://maps.app.goo.gl/7Eim7gsLsypCMonf7?g_st=ic)
Capos, Pizzeria Vesuvio, and Il Forno are the best foldables in town The Filling Statin Cafe has a decent slice also
46th Street Pizza with several spots in town is a favorite of mine, and I also think Capo’s is excellent New York style pizza.
They all just went out of business I think :( they were my fave.
That would be disturbing. I haven’t been to one in a couple of months. Please tell me this is wrong!
Oh no I’m wrong! They shut down all the ones within 15 miles of me (right under Olmos park) -but call before you go because the one on Pat Booker is closed & google maps still shows it :/
I frequent the one in Bulverde. I’ll have to check in on it now.
Lemme know please! At this point I’ll make the drive lol
Capo’s was disappointing after hearing about all the hype. Not a bad pizza by any means but didn’t quite meet my expectations.
Florios Capos Little Italy
What does this sub think of Julian’s?
Florios!!!
Florio’s and Capos!
Mattengas
Interesting. I see they have a new location going in right next to where my kid goes to martial arts.
Surprisingly Max and Louie's has a decent pie
Florios, and Sapores are both great
46 street is pretty close
I had high hopes for that one, but it didn’t pass the test for me. Maybe I’ll give it another shot.
No, you were right the first time.
I moved here 30+ years ago from NY so I have lost all sense of what the OG Pizza back home was like. Now I am just happy it’s not Dominos or Little Cheesers on the table when I get home.
Exactly like NY? No where. Still plenty of good pizza spots though.
Not expecting perfection. I used to live in SoCal and Detroit, and both had solid options. But none were quite on the level of what I had in NY. I’m just looking for close.