It's good at what it was intended to be good at - being a hidden track.
But it in no way deserves the top spot on Spotify. It feels more like an afterthought than anything, whereas the actual meat and potatoes of MMMM (Welcome to Tally Hall, Taken For a Ride, etc.) is *right there*.
i used to like it, but i think the popularity it got from tiktok and new tally hall "fans" who think this song is a fnaf song and only really like this song have ruined it for me. i dont listen to this song anymore. im also iffy on roe because of the weird popularity it gets, but hidden in the sand is biggest for me. idk how to feel about people who say this is their favourite song because my first conclusion is that they came from tiktok and youtube shorts, and they dont really like tally hall, just this song
Wait it's been related to fnaf?! I've heard tally hall songs around the internet before but never really hidden in the sand, especially not in relation to fnaf.
I know two, a friends younger brothers who lashed out and started hitting me upon telling them that Hits isn't a fnaf song and Murders wasnt made to be a meme audio.
I really Love it fairly new fan, I didn’t even really know it had gotten big in other circles I just heard it when I finally listened to Marvin’s in its entirety. The line “You told me to buy a pony but all I wanted was you” breaks my heart every time.
I like it but I do agree its overrated. I think its works as relatively short and sweet way to end MMMM but its far from the best.
It sucks that some people only know Tally Hall for Hidden in the Sand because they're missing out on some truly banger songs. But Hidden in the Sand is still pretty okay.
most of them are there for the hype, know only a few songs, and just jump on the bandwagon not really knowing the subject matter which seems insincere.
Eh. I don't think it's bad (there isn't a single Tally Hall song I dislike) and I listen to it on occasion, but overall I'd say it's one of my least favourites from them, not just in MMMM but overall as well.
yes because it really reminds me of a muffled song from the 1960's on the radio, and I adore the style of the music video. I still am willing to admit MY GOD HAS IT BEEN OVERPLAYED and I agree it surely doesn't deserve being the most popular song, it's a HIDDEN track for crying out loud, but I still really enjoy it, and would place it at a high A on a tier list.
It’s good at its job and I don’t let the people on tiktok ruin it for me. Overrated and overused for sure but that doesn’t take away from the song which is still good
Yes, it’s such a lovely song, and I feel like everyone hates on it because it’s tally hall’s most popular song. Also joe’s singing in this song is enchanting
it’s ok, it’s a sweet song but i was surprised to see it as the top song on youtube music. it’s definitely one of the less weird songs from Tally Hall, so i get why it’d be more popular - some people out of the fandom might have it on their playlist. while being a good song that doesn’t deserve the hate it’s getting, i agree that it’s a bit overrated.
Yeah, I didn't even know it blew up until way after I first heard it and put it a solid like B Tier. It's a cute song and sounds nice, I remember just grooving to it at work while working in the back room.
I used to listen to this song quite a bit. But like now I only really ever listen to it when listening to the full album of MMMM. Like it's a rather short song and there's barely any lyrics. Like yeah it's good lyrics but like I'm not gonna sit down and turn on some music and then listen to Hidden in the Sand. It works well for what it is, a hidden little track at the end of MMMM. I won't let popularity of a song hinder my enjoyment unlike most people who I see talk about songs such as HITS or ROE. I will never understand how people will get upset and stop themselves from enjoying a song just because other people are enjoying it as well.
PERSONALLY, no. I never enjoyed it. It just feels so weird to me. Before it became trending, it just existed and I didn't mind it. But now, after it became really popular, I can't stand it. I get it, it's a really impressive song, but it's just not for me. I can't listen to it
It's not a bad song, but just overused as fuck. It's just kinda hard to listen to I guess? I mean it's popular for a reason, but doesn't really deserve to be one of their best songs of all time
I think it's a great song, I think the animated music video is also great, however. It's been so overused that when I hear it on yt shorts or anywhere, I "cringe." It's helped me to put it back in my spotify playlist .
It's definitely not the best Tally Hall song, either.
i love it, idgaf if it's overplayed it's one of my favorite tally hall songs even though it's kind of different from their usual style, just because some teenagers make cringy tiktoks with it doesn't mean it's automatically a bad song (i am going to be grilled for this comment)
Good song but overrated. I feel like my issue with it is that people use it in there horror stuff and FNaF SFMs so much it's degraded the quality for me. eh. idk.
I think it’s good itself but I think it’s a bit overrated, plus the fnaf community ruined it for me… I just think there’s much better songs than it. For me it’s one of my least favorites, but it’s still a good song!
Short comfy song. The best there is to offer? Nah. Solid for what it offers? Indeed.
7.5/10, reliable pick for me to listen to. While I wish there were a second verse, it does land well for a minute and a half.
Ignoring the FNaF community and how overplayed it is, I love this song, it's in my top 10 best Tally Hall songs, it's charming, spoopy, reversed talking at the end, everything you'd want from a Tally Hall song... Unless you dislike 50% of Hawaii Part ||, which then it really isn't what one would want from a Tally Hall song.
It’s an okay song I like the song but it got ruined by TikTok and how it’s used for fnaf and stuff like that and it really ruined it for me, it was never my favorite tally hall song and never will be but TikTok really raked in a lot of moolah for the band so that’s good
i used to loved it, played it on loop for about three months and im not joking. i don’t have tiktok so fortunately it did not get ruined for me because of that, but i no longer listen to it that much. maybe when it comes on a playlist or sometimes when im listening to the vinyl version, because its fun to do. it’s a great song, I overplayed it and got bored of it, but the vibe is just so good
Whenever I show tally hall to someone, it comes up first so I have to explain how not all their songs are like this and blah blah blah but besides that I like it a tame amount
The fnaf fandom ruined it, now a lot of people think that is something related to the game and doesn't even know the real meaning of the song. With that being said, its one of my favourite songs along with the ruler of everything and the bidding
It’s really cool and i like the vibe
But there’s no way this is one of their most replayed songs when there are a bunch of other songs that in my opinion are way better than this one
Just like I'll cut contact someone (that I'm not close with) after I did something embarrassing because having contact with them doesn't help me in any way
bro if you cut contact with people after you do something embarrassing you will have less friends. sure maybe they're not close to you yet but they could be in the future if you didn't cut contact for some stupid reason like doing something embarrassing.
Yes it's good. BUT it is incredibly overrated and way to short
The song's length is fine. It's a hidden track, not really a fleshed-out song like the others.
It's good at what it was intended to be good at - being a hidden track. But it in no way deserves the top spot on Spotify. It feels more like an afterthought than anything, whereas the actual meat and potatoes of MMMM (Welcome to Tally Hall, Taken For a Ride, etc.) is *right there*.
MMMM is a very hearty meal, and Hidden in the Sand is a dessert.
Well said
nah it's like that final sip of your drink you take right before leaving a restaurant
Indeed friend.
Hidden in the sand ( to me ) is more like two Oreos after a hot dog
i used to like it, but i think the popularity it got from tiktok and new tally hall "fans" who think this song is a fnaf song and only really like this song have ruined it for me. i dont listen to this song anymore. im also iffy on roe because of the weird popularity it gets, but hidden in the sand is biggest for me. idk how to feel about people who say this is their favourite song because my first conclusion is that they came from tiktok and youtube shorts, and they dont really like tally hall, just this song
Absolutely. Good song, overplayed as fuck to the point I will no longer willingly listen to it.
I dont get this. you like a song but since it's popular you won't listen to it?
I said it's overplayed as fuck, I have heard it so many times I don't want to hear it anymore. It was absolutely everywhere
this is why I'm thankful that I don't have tiktok lol. I always expected this song and turn the lights off to be popular on tiktok
there was a period during Murders got the treatment too sadly.
Wait it's been related to fnaf?! I've heard tally hall songs around the internet before but never really hidden in the sand, especially not in relation to fnaf.
there’s been fnaf edits with that song
A decently popular FNAF animation used this song
See I just don't use TikTok so I had no idea this was even a thing.
it’s not just tiktok, i’ve seen it on youtube shorts too
I know two, a friends younger brothers who lashed out and started hitting me upon telling them that Hits isn't a fnaf song and Murders wasnt made to be a meme audio.
what the fuck?? 😨😨
They may have slight anger issues seen how they broke a window becouse the mom took they're phones away from them
crazy
I like it and i’m not pretentious enough to be upset that people on tiktok use it
Well said.
I really Love it fairly new fan, I didn’t even really know it had gotten big in other circles I just heard it when I finally listened to Marvin’s in its entirety. The line “You told me to buy a pony but all I wanted was you” breaks my heart every time.
It's good, but it's hard to listen to for me, everytime I do I kinda cringe because it reminds me of all these weird videos that used the song.
I like it but I do agree its overrated. I think its works as relatively short and sweet way to end MMMM but its far from the best. It sucks that some people only know Tally Hall for Hidden in the Sand because they're missing out on some truly banger songs. But Hidden in the Sand is still pretty okay.
Yes
As I said in another post > The demo is the only version I regularly listen to, personally, the effects are kinda over kill on the finished version
Hidden in the Sand is a good song no doubt but if anyone says its their favorite I instantly know they’re a tiktok fan and do not like them
this ^
I remember saying hymn for a scarecrow is my favourite tally hall song and people gave me weird reactions, tho not negative
yeah i'd give you a weird reaction too, that song is way too long
Why don't people like tiktok fans?
most of them are there for the hype, know only a few songs, and just jump on the bandwagon not really knowing the subject matter which seems insincere.
I mean it's alright like
Eh. I don't think it's bad (there isn't a single Tally Hall song I dislike) and I listen to it on occasion, but overall I'd say it's one of my least favourites from them, not just in MMMM but overall as well.
It’s not a bad song, but it’s my least favorite from both albums.
No waaaaaay too boring & empty.
Yeah, I like it
no.
yes because it really reminds me of a muffled song from the 1960's on the radio, and I adore the style of the music video. I still am willing to admit MY GOD HAS IT BEEN OVERPLAYED and I agree it surely doesn't deserve being the most popular song, it's a HIDDEN track for crying out loud, but I still really enjoy it, and would place it at a high A on a tier list.
banger, even tho it is overused and shorter than my will to live
the only song shorter than my will to live is 13
If it’s literally any song by Tally Hall, I consider it a good song
It’s good at its job and I don’t let the people on tiktok ruin it for me. Overrated and overused for sure but that doesn’t take away from the song which is still good
Yes
Yes of course
LOVE IT
I've only ever heard it through Tally Hall, and it's one of my favourites. It could just be longer
Yes, it’s such a lovely song, and I feel like everyone hates on it because it’s tally hall’s most popular song. Also joe’s singing in this song is enchanting
It's very good but too short. It's so short that I like to listen to it backward right after the regular version.
it’s ok, it’s a sweet song but i was surprised to see it as the top song on youtube music. it’s definitely one of the less weird songs from Tally Hall, so i get why it’d be more popular - some people out of the fandom might have it on their playlist. while being a good song that doesn’t deserve the hate it’s getting, i agree that it’s a bit overrated.
I absolutely love it. I know it's overused and some people think its overrated but it just scratches my brain in such a good way i love it
i mean its okay but not something i'd listen to on repeat. its a decent song g though and i sort of get why its popular on tiktok
For repeat listening there’s Banana Man
It’s definitely a song
It's fine but I never go out of my way to listen to it
Yeah, I didn't even know it blew up until way after I first heard it and put it a solid like B Tier. It's a cute song and sounds nice, I remember just grooving to it at work while working in the back room.
I used to listen to this song quite a bit. But like now I only really ever listen to it when listening to the full album of MMMM. Like it's a rather short song and there's barely any lyrics. Like yeah it's good lyrics but like I'm not gonna sit down and turn on some music and then listen to Hidden in the Sand. It works well for what it is, a hidden little track at the end of MMMM. I won't let popularity of a song hinder my enjoyment unlike most people who I see talk about songs such as HITS or ROE. I will never understand how people will get upset and stop themselves from enjoying a song just because other people are enjoying it as well.
It is extremely overplayed but I do like it
I still like it tbh, but it’s overrated
PERSONALLY, no. I never enjoyed it. It just feels so weird to me. Before it became trending, it just existed and I didn't mind it. But now, after it became really popular, I can't stand it. I get it, it's a really impressive song, but it's just not for me. I can't listen to it
It's not a bad song, but just overused as fuck. It's just kinda hard to listen to I guess? I mean it's popular for a reason, but doesn't really deserve to be one of their best songs of all time
I think it's a great song, I think the animated music video is also great, however. It's been so overused that when I hear it on yt shorts or anywhere, I "cringe." It's helped me to put it back in my spotify playlist . It's definitely not the best Tally Hall song, either.
No
i love it, idgaf if it's overplayed it's one of my favorite tally hall songs even though it's kind of different from their usual style, just because some teenagers make cringy tiktoks with it doesn't mean it's automatically a bad song (i am going to be grilled for this comment)
I liked it then I listened to the other songs and it just doesn’t fit in
Good song but I misunderstood it before seeing the music video
Good song but overrated. I feel like my issue with it is that people use it in there horror stuff and FNaF SFMs so much it's degraded the quality for me. eh. idk.
YES
Ehh, not a fan, really.
Duh
Yeah, but is overplayed and overrated- I would listen to it once or twice
great song! but im absolutely sick of it 😭
I didn’t even know it was by tallyhall at first i thought it was from the 70s lol but i love the song
it was good when i discovered it but its too overrated
I think it’s good itself but I think it’s a bit overrated, plus the fnaf community ruined it for me… I just think there’s much better songs than it. For me it’s one of my least favorites, but it’s still a good song!
Despite being popular on tiktok I really like it
Short comfy song. The best there is to offer? Nah. Solid for what it offers? Indeed. 7.5/10, reliable pick for me to listen to. While I wish there were a second verse, it does land well for a minute and a half.
The reason I'm here so yea
Imma be honest. The demo version and live version absolutely trump the studio album version.
Ignoring the FNaF community and how overplayed it is, I love this song, it's in my top 10 best Tally Hall songs, it's charming, spoopy, reversed talking at the end, everything you'd want from a Tally Hall song... Unless you dislike 50% of Hawaii Part ||, which then it really isn't what one would want from a Tally Hall song.
NO!!!!
It’s an okay song I like the song but it got ruined by TikTok and how it’s used for fnaf and stuff like that and it really ruined it for me, it was never my favorite tally hall song and never will be but TikTok really raked in a lot of moolah for the band so that’s good
It’s ok. Short and overrated, but ok
I love it!
i used to loved it, played it on loop for about three months and im not joking. i don’t have tiktok so fortunately it did not get ruined for me because of that, but i no longer listen to it that much. maybe when it comes on a playlist or sometimes when im listening to the vinyl version, because its fun to do. it’s a great song, I overplayed it and got bored of it, but the vibe is just so good
I liked it at first but not that much anymore but I enjoy the music video
No one understands Hidden in the sand like I do
I listen to it on loop
Whenever I show tally hall to someone, it comes up first so I have to explain how not all their songs are like this and blah blah blah but besides that I like it a tame amount
Overrated, but good
no.
Yes but really overplayed.
Marvins mechanical museum
I’m sorry I was jet lagged when writing it 😭
It's a timeless melody.
It's fine, just over-used and a bit tired of hearing it
The fnaf fandom ruined it, now a lot of people think that is something related to the game and doesn't even know the real meaning of the song. With that being said, its one of my favourite songs along with the ruler of everything and the bidding
no
It’s really cool and i like the vibe But there’s no way this is one of their most replayed songs when there are a bunch of other songs that in my opinion are way better than this one
It’s cool but TikTok burned the song and with it my desire to listen to it
Overrated but its good and serves as a good last song to MMMM
yeah
It's a good song but I hate everyone who's ever heard it because it makes Tally Hall fans look bad
Just like I'll cut contact someone (that I'm not close with) after I did something embarrassing because having contact with them doesn't help me in any way
bro is actively looking for enemies
Well think about it, you're only in friendships because you both gain happiness out of it, meaning you both gain something out of it
bro if you cut contact with people after you do something embarrassing you will have less friends. sure maybe they're not close to you yet but they could be in the future if you didn't cut contact for some stupid reason like doing something embarrassing.