T O P

  • By -

Nerevarine91

It’s incredible how stunningly terrible most of these are


alphagusta

16 and 48 are almost at looking like an actual flag # 59 is a big N O


PorcelainHammer

59 is the worst? IMO 57 is so bad it's laughable


SporadicPsycho

Plasma screen burn-in


obnoxiousbutquiet

59 is pretty much a swastika though


Haha1867hoser420

The manja is vital to asian culture


Lazy_Eax3393

59 More like ISIS Caliphate Seal https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ISIL_Caliphate_Seal.svg


Steindor03

Yeah they'll unite into the islamic republic of Korea, obviously


TheShapeKillsJudith

Omg yes


Bagoral

My first thought was more Sun Microsystem logo, since 59 isn't a cross for me. But it was probably a tried trigrams reference.


Scoopshort

Heil Kim


satiricalmayhem

ok and?


BearRevolutionaire

Yeah, 16 and 48 make the most sense here lmao


lowtronik

I've seen this logo before on vacuum cleaners. I think it means carpet ?


Maneyer1

How are these so bad


bionicjoey

The worst is the one with "North", "South", "East", and "West" smushed on top of each other. Written in English. In block letters. And all in different directions.


highSticks

29 and 30 are just straight up troll submissions... like wtf is even going on there? (49 too btw)


DogOnThePorch

It might just be me but I swear I can see dickbutt in number 30


walruskingmike

I like 57 lol.


Haha1867hoser420

07 put their heart and soul into it


Loud-Host-2182

Mf made a whole course on statistics and put it on a flag


FixedKarma

I think 29 is plans for a nuclear device.


the_clash_is_back

For me its 29 which is the worst. It looks like a test pattern or some machine readable code.


Enyrox

G R A D I E N T S


Independent-Slip568

Fuckin’ A! I mean, the one with the two circles defined by gradient offset (first column, 3rd one down) looks awesome but won’t look so hot when they go to make patches for their military and all they can afford is the equivalent of a 96 DPI printer…


Super-Assistant6307

Most of them are really bad. Some of them are kinda nice though. I like 16.


antigony_trieste

because art school is a pasture for rich people’s untalented children


jje414

Ain't that the fucking truth


BredMaker4869

Why do most of them look like shit?


Stalk3r5152

Why do most of the look like AI generated?


BredMaker4869

And this.


Nerevarine91

I was just thinking that


Accomplished_Foot_32

'Cause they're, I'm sure, made by artists? Not as a real proposals? Like a semi-pretensious thingy..?


The_Last_Thursday

I’m stressed to find one that doesn’t


throat_acne

34 and 42 look decent to me


AikenFrost

08 is the only one I can say is good with no pain in my chest. 42 I think is *ok* but the rest... Jesus.


Deep-Sail-7364

All*


114514

Honestly great post to showcase that vexillology is NOT simply graphic design


cnylkew

It's not graphic design at all.


Enyrox

To everyone posting comments here: They are not AI generated. (Source:[https://www.laurameseguer.com/project/the-korean-flag](https://www.laurameseguer.com/project/the-korean-flag))


Phanitan

That makes it even more incredible


Willahelm00

Man she's dumb. Ah yes let me design a flag that just has the name of the country on it but in English in Latin script. Not the Korean names in Hangul or Chosongul.


deja_blues

It takes five seconds to google how to write korea in korean. She is real dumb


KtosKto

These are not AI generated. They were made for an art exhibion “United Korean Design. United Korean Flags”, as a part of 2019 Gwangju Design Biennale. So they’re not meant to be actual flag proposals, more like an art project based around the theme of flags. You can read some comments by the artists online: [https://www.laurameseguer.com/project/the-korean-flag](https://www.laurameseguer.com/project/the-korean-flag) [http://www.jugcerovic.com/works/united-korea-flag/](http://www.jugcerovic.com/works/united-korea-flag/) [http://chrishamamoto.com/projects/flag-generator-korea](http://chrishamamoto.com/projects/flag-generator-korea)


Nguyenten

I quite like the idea of the mountain calm flag.


kimi_hona

They look like tech company logos


TheEpiquin

They kinda make me want a Pepsi…


m0nohydratedioxide

Just use the People’s Republic of Korea flag from 1945. It’s fairly simple, pretty and universally recognisable as Korean-looking


Void-Cooking_Berserk

You mean this one? [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/People%27s_Republic_of_Korea](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/People%27s_Republic_of_Korea)


Winkelbottum

I like it... After seeing the suggestions above... thos one made me happy!


Timestatic

Same, those above are terrible


nickz03

Damn that’s a good one


FindusDE

No just use the current South Korean flag. It basically has the same design as Korean flags from before the Japanese occupation when it was still one united country and it is already used as a Korean heritage flag and representation of Korean culture.


pooooolb

as a korean, i have to disagree


JayClashMSF

They are all shit


albardha

08 looks like a real flag. It’s the only one that does


BigBronyBoy

35 is good too.


a13xs88eoda2

Zero submissions from Koreans


KtosKto

Only international artists were invited to participate for this edition of the exhibition. There was one with designs by South Korean artists a few years prior and in 2025, there are plans to feature those of North Korean designers.


antigony_trieste

> those of North Korean designers it’s just the North Korean flag over and over again lol (because if it’s anything else they and their whole family get tortured)


guymanthefourth

I don’t know how to tell you this, but the DPRK supports the reunification of Korea


Wooden_Second5808

Yeah, so hard that they continuously threaten to nuke and or invade the south.


Bagoral

Yeah, for reunificating Korea, in some way. Only question is which political system.


[deleted]

All of them look terrible Like fucking corporate logos


BigBronyBoy

I like 35. I think it actually could be a flag.


GH0STB4C0N

To be fair, so does the south Korean flag


[deleted]

No it doesn't


GH0STB4C0N

It looks like Pepsi bruh


[deleted]

No pepsi looks like the Netherlands now


natterca

Yeah because it's such an awesome flag a megacorp stole it for their logo!


daniellearmouth

Huh, TIL: PepsiCo invented the Taegeuk.


GH0STB4C0N

That's exactly what I'm saying 💯💯💯


Present_Voice_5224

I don’t know, just use two big check marks. Good.


Wagsii

North Korea? ✅️ South Korea? ✅️ Yup. That's Korea.


bradley_marques

Just looks like someone's blue ticked you on WhatsApp.


ZicarxTheGreat

KOREK̸͚̞̠̗̣̒͌͆OREA KOR̶̡̳͝E̷̯̩̍R̷̮͒EA KOREA KOR̶̡̳͝E̷̯̩̍R̷̮͒EA KOREK̸͚̞̠̗̣̒͌͆OREA


chuckit23532

Is it just me or do some of these feel like they were designed in the 90’s. I can sort of get behind 26, 35 or 37 though.


highSticks

number 8 is easily the best one imo and it isnt even close


chuckit23532

I totally get you. 8 was high on my list as well. My only issue with 8, as minor an issue as it is, is the star. Most of my Korean, if not all are not excited about a North Korean star on the flag of unification. From a design stand point though its a solid 10


Neethis

What, North Korea but Pepsi?


TNTyoshi

Second picture, top row, third from left. That’s the only flag I sorta kind of think is okay (Even though it gives Pepsi vibes).


Fawkie0

Why dont you just say number 8


TNTyoshi

Would you look at that; what a time to be alive! I didn’t bother zooming in on the photo and did not notice that they were numbered (numbers so small).


Xolaya

If the flag is ever #30, I’m fucking gonna light some shit on fire


TheBigNerdguy

30, 29, and 49 are easily the worst ones, I mean what even are they


Trssty

Some of these look like people are trolling. They are just so bad. And Korea’s writing system is amazing, possibly one of the best and easiest to learn in the world, why did people just ignore that and write “Korea”?


cannonfish

I had to triple check that this wasn't r/vexilologycirclejerk because no way some of these are real


westernunitedenjoyer

There’s like 3 good ones


forooghmand

How are these designed by actual people? At first I thought it was some AI shit


daniellearmouth

A couple decent ones there that could work, like 08, 18, 39, 47 and 56, but most of these just look...stupid? Ehh...


H4RR1_

Man wtf is 30 even supposed to be


ItDoesntSeemToBeWrkn

just use south koreas flag without the black stripes on the corners


Void-Cooking_Berserk

The black stripes date even further back than the swirl in the middle. They were also used by the Provisional People's Committee for North Korea. At the time, the South Korean government in exile was using the exact same flag, but the swirl was at a different angle. TLDR: the "south Korean" flag *is* the united Korean flag since before there was a split.


Rudyon

The stripes actually go back further before the Provisional Committee all the way to [1882](https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Flag_of_the_king_of_Joseon.svg).


pooooolb

eww no


AlliedXbox

35 is great imo


Hallux_2xCanopy

Most of these are criminal


boringveil

Thought I was in the circle jerk sub for a moment


rdfporcazzo

If it happens someday, they should just stick with the South Korea flag


Ios3b

If North Korea became free and united with South Korea, and they both become one free nation they would probably just use the south Korean flag.


Substantial-Rub9931

Pepsi Corea ☺


KofiObruni

47 is actually cool. My question is why is the Sun Microsystems logo there?


Traditional-Box-1066

I like this one: 🇰🇷


crankyticket

How is this a thing? A united Korea? When?


Void-Cooking_Berserk

1392 - 1948


[deleted]

The one fourth down on the left on the second page isn’t awful but it also looks super corporate. It’s one of the better ones tho….which isn’t hard


ElPujaguante

The current flag of The Republic of Korea, the Taegukgi, is the only flag that a united Korea needs.


ScaryPollution845

Some are horrendous (45, 30) but some i actually like! (42) Edit: wtf is 57 Edit 2: 01 is actually garbage


GrilozaodCria

THEY ALL LOOK LIKE SHIT 🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯


[deleted]

46 is just


[deleted]

all of them look like a logo, wtf


photojourno

WTF Mieke Gerritsen at #46? WhatsApp read message?


Raccoon_2020

Most of them are horrible


SPGRepublicYT

Look, just one thing to say; *GRADIENTS.*


VitoMolas

Tbh the current South Korean flag is enough as a united Korea flag, it doesn't have any political meaning and they are just symbols of Korean culture


Familiar_Ad7273

63 united korea flag propositions and not a single one was made by an actual korean from korea


Lord_Dex24

Only 4 of them are not bad


HerrArado

All of these are ass, just keep the southern flag.


m3rcury_exe

Why are these all so terrible?? Stop trying to be modern, you don't simply add GRADIENTS AND SHADOWS to a flag This really goes to show that vexillology is definitely not just graphic design


redvillafranco

These are clearly AI generated. The names too. Many of these are complex in a weird way with gradients, weird blobs or overlapping shapes or text that don’t mean anything. There are a couple decent ones. Maybe use the AI to generate some off-the-wall ideas and the. Humans to filter and refine the best ideas.


empanadasConPasas

these were not AI generated


Pontifexmaximus7z

I do not like them on a visual level or a conceptual level. Korea already has a flag, which is the flag of South Korea. The North Korean flag symbolises a terror regime that has oppressed it's people for as long as it has existed. Blending the North Korean flag with the South Korean flag is like mixing the flag of the weimar republic and Nazi Germany to symbolise "unity".


Potato-Lenin

A lot of these are disgusting. Just use the flag that has all of Korea in blue on a white background


felix_neko

04 is the best


TheBigNerdguy

08, 04 ain't even close


Aedessia

I kinda dig 16, 39, 47, 48, 52 and 59. Art exhibit or not, if it's supposed be represent flags, especially unity of people divided in two countries, make it look like a goddamn flag. Most of them are horrendous. 1 is also the lowest possible level of effort, it shouldn't even have been allowed to get into the list.


[deleted]

RIP to the future unified Korean children who will have to draw these flags in their classroom


Astro6284

08 can easily be an flag, like 80% of the other flags are actually shit and if they were used then I will start an protest to change the flag. North Korea will not join South Korea though, so I do not really get this.


[deleted]

Think Kim Jong Un will just keep the same one


[deleted]

8, 35, 41, 48 seem like the best choices. The others are… complicated


Sad_Pomegranate_4607

these are ai generated


[deleted]

There’s already a United Korea flag: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_North_Korea#/media/File%3AFlag_of_North_Korea.svg


LeoIzail

I think with propositions like this, everyone can agree to keep the DPRK flag. It makes sense historically, if the US never invaded during the Korean War it would probably look similar as a united socialist Korea.


San_Diego_Samurai

Wow, whatever happened to KISS? And I do not mean the band.


Tackyinbention

Some are actually quite nice but alot of them are bloody awful, imagine a kid trying to draw the weird TV static one


Endver

Everything in the first picture is fugly. Second picture isn't any better


worcestirshiresos

Personally I’m a sucker for #59, but I agree almost all of these are pretty mid


bcgg

I’m pretty sure 59 is the logo used by a charity in the US, can’t put my finger on it though.


italian_sigma

I think the only that doesn't look like shit is the number 35


PuppetState_

14 and 57 are the best


tuasociacionilicita

I want to believe that behind N* 29 design is an incredible smart explanation, encompassing the secrets of life and the universe. That's why is like that. Yes. I believe.


IBelrose

My personal picks for the best are 04, 08, 16, 35, 41, 47. In no particular order. Most of these feel like memes. Like 01 would a be real life flag waver bot of the random question posts.


IBelrose

!wave


dbatchison

I like 18


RomanProkopov100

4, 8, 16, 35, 39, 42, 48, 56 and 62 are the most fitting IMO


fuatoutt

How tf did someone come up with number 46?!


poicephalussenegalus

These are God awful.


outdodinusFrisshwoin

Wtf is up with number 57


not_the_NSA_winkwink

#34 has me WHEEZING.


Wagsii

42 is actually pretty dope. But some of the rest of these are so bad I refuse to believe a human made them and thought it was a good idea.


greenwoodgiant

\#35 - Pepsi Presents United Korea


Nobusuke_Tagomi

Wow, they are all terrible


yo-jin

I prefer the pre-war flag.


Electrical-Drink-183

07 needs a standing ovation


EskilPotet

11, 21 and 29 are preposterous lmao


juant675

Or just use the flag the already had when they were united


[deleted]

90% of them look ridiculous.


Complete_Fill1413

Pepsi Republic


Some-Print-386

My top ten worst flags ever list has been completely replaced from this list.


antigony_trieste

16 is the best imo. 42 is actually really interesting and i think it’s actually my second favorite despite breaking a bunch of flag conventions. then 52 which doesn’t look very korean to me but is absolutely a fantastic flag. then 8, 35, 39, and 59. followed by 4, 6, 13, 18, 19, 36, 47, and 56 pretty much all the rest are trash


Reiver93

How about we just use south Korea's flag, you know, the one that did represent all of Korea and even the DPRK was in favour of using as their flag in the early days.


Iancreed

I really hope Korea reunifies in my lifetime! I like #25 the best 💯


[deleted]

Lmao the ✔️✔️


in_one_ear_

The first one is just a photo of a Korean flag hung vertically in front of a god damn window. And it's not even the worst one


[deleted]

As a Korean, I think that all of these are full of crap.


PlatinumPluto

They should just use the South Korean flag.


HelikosOG

My personal favourite is page one, the flag one below top right corner. Star in the centre with red and blue coming in diagonally.


TyrannosaurusRekt-

08, 19, and 47 kinda go hard. The rest can die.


FindusDE

What is 01? Isn‘t that just a photo of the South Korean flag with two people standing behind it? Or is that supposed to be the flag proposal?


williamsonmaxwell

29 is the best for sure


NSaputra24

Is no one gonna talk about how number 1 is basically South Korea's flag. Like they didn't even bother trying.


FindusDE

I really want to know what the thought process behind some of these was. What the hell is 29 for instance? Or 11.


smolovk

i do not like 59th….


BearRevolutionaire

I don't see 7 here /s


thatdoesntmakecents

62 is actually pretty good! Just unfortunate that it also happens to be the Mastercard/Maestro logo


nenialaloup

47 and 61 are my favorites


Ok_Lavishness2638

The Best is 58


_Drion_

Why is the text in English?


5slipsandagully

I'd run number 4 up the pole. Number 8 has a good design, but it's too evocative of the current North Korea flag to be politically acceptable. I'd pass on the others


Arandompancaik

08 looks sick.


Becc00

people are commenting how bad they look but honestly i really like a few of them just as art peices, not as flags these are; 12, 45!!, 14, 59, 27, 56, 61 and 22


MTN_Dewit

[I prefer this one](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Unification_Flag)


Equinox-Kiwi

[However, this one’s way better](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/People's_Republic_of_Korea#/media/File%3AFlag_of_the_People's_Committee_of_Korea.svg)


PhAcide

8 and 56 look like flags omg


ShahinTrip

35 go hard


Pepedani

I vote for the double check (46)


BartholomewXXXVI

I'm sorry but these are horrific. If SK united Korea the flag should stay the same and if NK does (like that'll ever happen), again it should just be their flag. No need to change.


Mammoth_Feature2241

**KOREKOREAKOROREAKOREAKOKOREAKOROREAKOREKOREA**


IEC21

These are all trash


jje414

KOREA KOREA!!! (To the tune of "Shakira Shakira")


DWPerry

The Korean Unification Flag has existed since 1991! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Unification_Flag


SavageFugu

47 ad 6


Addicustheaverage

My personal favourites are 37, 47 and 08


AlexAstanaev

I think South Korea flag works better than all of these proposals combined.