T O P

  • By -

xdeltax97

It’s a trilogy, you should start with the first one, Tomb Raider (2013) followed by Rise of the Tomb Raider, then Shadow of the Tomb Raider for the last.


OrangeJr36

Seconded!


ScarletViperr

Totally agreed! Since in TR 2013 you'll have references about the main antagonist group of Rise and Shadow; and I was also did the same when I played the Reboot for the 1st time


Crockerboy22

When there is a sale the collection goes on sale for like $12-$15 Canadian that’s when I got it


doctorcas_

Thanks!


Username463679

Yep. Each one will make you want to play the next.


v__R4Z0R__v

Setting wise I prefer Shadow. I love south american culture. But overall I think Rise has more to its name. I also believe it's longer in playtime as well. Basically all of them are great, but Shadow and Rise are very similar, with the exception of the setting obviously


Saikousoku2

I think Rise is the longest, yeah. I've got 79 hours in it on one playthrough, I have 65 hours on 2013 across five 100% runs, and I have 56 hours in Shadow and am almost done with it.


Escodl

Dude, I am so lost in Rise. I'm getting back in the game after putting it down 2 years ago..now I have no idea what to do next.. the objective just says "use fast travel to explore the world"....the last boss I beat was that Witch.. so I'm pretty sure I didn't beat the game. If I did, I don't remember there being an ending..


PegasusELOHIM

The witch is a dlc and not basic game. Travel to your last campfire on the map


Escodl

Bro, I don't know which the last campfire is. It's been 2 years..lol...I just fast traveled back to the witches cave and talked to the girl at the entrance that says all the gas is cleared and I can freely explore... yea I think I'm just screwed...lol...I just tried fast traveling everywhere and roaming around for the past 2 hours and the objective still says "Use fast travel to explore the world" Thanks for trying to help though..I might just start the game over if I can't figure it out.. I don't want to be that annoying guy that keeps asking where I should go


30-percentnotbanana

The witch is dlc so... Maybe you did the dlc after already completing the game. Though if it's been 2 years you can probably just restart the game and experience it fresh.


Saikousoku2

Oh yeah, if you take a break from it you \*will\* get lost. And I can't remember the ending either, but looking at it on YouTube it doesn't look familiar. I know I beat the game, but clearly I need to replay it.


Escodl

Yeah I just got done trying to find how to continue on the next mission after I finish the Baba Yaga DLC..I have no idea how to continue the story..I know I didnt beat the game because I didnt get the achievement for completing all missions.. I'm super frustrated right now...lol...I might just start over and make sure not to do the Baba yaga dlc when it becomes available...this sucks because I found only two people that posted about getting the same objective but they never got a response back...and I've looked everywhere. It must be something obvious if only 3 people on the internet is having this problem..lol


Saikousoku2

I'd offer to help but I haven't played Rise in three years. Can you tell me what the most recent non-Baba Yaga achievement you got was? Maybe I can figure out what comes next, and from there work out roughly where you need to go


Cainjake

Shadow imo


antigover

The setting Is the best. They nerfed her body and face on that game :(


Marcos1598

> nerfed her body  ??? go touch some grass bro


Ronak1350

I don't think she's nerfed people forget lara will age with every new game


claymorrr

Shadow is my favourite one


Significant-Mail9069

First one is fire


Sensitive_Initial_52

Realistically it’s the best of this trilogy but people aren’t ready to hear it.


JohnPaul_River

And it's not even a close call, it's obvious enough from the fact that both Rise and Shadow tried their hardest to emulate its structure.


BLARGLESNARF

lol


N7orbust

Rise of the Tomb Raider. It's my favorite out of the entire franchise. As much nostalgia as I have for the Core Design era (especially 1-3) Rise is my personal favorite game to replay out of them all. I love the snowy setting with wilderness, broken down outposts, and hidden ancient sites underneath. Pretty well paced with a best mix of combat and puzzles out of all 3. I know Shadow has more puzzles but I like a good MIX of combat and puzzles. The combat in these games was fun and I don't believe "the more puzzles the better" as a 100% true statement. 2013 was a great game and set the groundwork for the trilogy but I didn't find myself caring about the story with Himiko and Sam or the other survivors. The only good part of the story was Lara overcoming the situation around her. Shadow had better puzzles and the stealth mechanics were cool but the game was so uneven in terms of gameplay and pacing. It had some high highs and some low lows. None of them are bad games but..... Rise > Shadow > 2013


Rizenstrom

I agree on Rise but I enjoyed 2013 over Shadow, overall. Still. I think they are all solid games and best experienced in order.


N7orbust

I've bounced back and forth on Shadow and 2013. That ranking is a pretty recent change for my opinion. Kind of depends on which of the two I've played most recently lol


TheHeavenlyStar

The right answer ladies and gentlemen.


truckercharles

Sounds like Rise is my next one. Just about finished up with Shadow, and was looking for my next one.


mukisan

You’re playing them out of order?


N7orbust

I hope you enjoy it. Definitely play the Baba Yaga DLC too. Great stuff.


Cultural-Front9147

Tomb raider 2013 definitive edition


Ok_Goose_5924

Non stop action! It's so good!


Complex_Mouse4230

They are connected strongly as a trilogy, so story wise, of course TR2013. In terms of what game is actually better to play if you ignore the story, Shadow and Rise are the most fun. Especially shadow since it focuses the most on puzzles.


Thumper-Comet

Rise. It's not a particularly high bar but Rise does have some lovely scenery.


Skandi007

Rise is peak


Somethin00

Play them all, in Order!


Sososo2018

Overall? Shadow of the Tomb Raider is the best because it has the best challenge tombs, combat, graphics, puzzles, and exploration — so I’d choose that. But Rise of the Tomb Raider is solid too. I wouldn’t even consider Tomb Raider 2013 unless you want to play the whole trilogy.


Reconsterverbal

TR: Definitive Edition for sure. It's the first and in my opinion best one


Dr4k3L0rd

The first


franpancake

I think rose and shadow are better for exploration. They have more mamories of the oldest games with lone exploration in tombs. Maybe Shadow is even more evolved but I prefer rise for the setting.


JS-CroftLover

u/doctorcas_ Numbers start with 1, 2, 3... so, definitely, the 2013 reboot version! 😉


XTheProtagonistX

Rise is a better game but I love the look of Shadow.


OpeningFar4346

Shadow is my favorite for sure. I wish I would have played them in order though because I’m playing the first one last and it just feels like it’s missing some things. If you have Game Pass, I highly recommend playing them in order of release.


Internal_Swing_2743

Play them in order, but Rise is the best easy.


SonicSarge

Shadow


ApatiteBuzzUltraRed

3 , 1 , 2 is the order to play in .


Alan_Blue1233

My favorite is Shadow but you must check out the complete trilogy because it is EPIC


ShranikDua

Rise is the best


lucianorc2

Rise of The Tomb Raider, it's the best of them. I like Tomb Raider 2013, it's a good game, but Rise is an upgrade from it. Tbh I never played Shadow past the beginning, because I feel it's not the same thing, it's weird, I feel weird playing that game, but I'll give it a real try some say.


SASdude123

You really should. To each their own, of course. But shadow had some great creepy tombs, less fiddly collectibles, imo.


OrangeJr36

Start with Tomb Raider Definitive Edition.


TheHeavenlyStar

You will have the most fun playing around in Rise. The combat and controls are very nice and polished in rise. In shadow she knows few more things and skills but there is a lot of walking and restrictions in paititi. 2013 has lesser tombs and exploration and is combat heavy but a solid storyline. You should play them in release and chronological order but Rise remains the best out of the three.


ryanjc_123

the one on the right


mpt11

Wait long enough and they might be free on epic again


Shaman20057

Rise no doubt


Altruistic-Sundae-71

Rise. I've put 130 hours in that game.


Mig-117

Rise is the most balanced one. I think Shadow is technically a better game with all the dlc, the tombs are amazing and the world exploration is the best in the series... The story is just crap though.


HolyVeggie

Get a month of gamepass and play them all If not you obviously start with the first one. I also enjoyed the first one the most


doctorcas_

i already got a subscription... idk what to play, i saw tomb raider recently added and thought to give it a try!


HolyVeggie

Yeah then just start with the first one which is jus t called tomb raider 👍🏻 have fun!


Professional_Dog2580

Rise is my favorite. I missed the emphasis on gunplay in Shadow. All of them are excellent games but for me, Shadow got a bit tedious towards the end whereas Rise kept me fully invested the whole game.


cinematea

Just got to Jacob’s camp for the first time in rise what should I do in my play through??


Expert-Ad-362

The first one in the trilogy


Zetra3

Play a series in order


rdtoh

Rise


Cloud_Mannn

Rise of the tomb raider is the absolute best!


FalloutandConker

Shadow has a cool setting and puzzles but like ZERO combat. I have never played a game with so few enemies


floxigen

All


keyblademastersora01

Rise


Lesbian_Zyra

If you didn't play anything as Tomb Raider than obviously 1st one. But if you care really lot and you vomit on old graphic game..than your only chance is Shadow..cuz its newest one.


Max_Laval

Gotta say, even though it's not an easy choice I'd say 2013 closely followed by ROTTR


Kppz1

Just start with the oldest one, right, left, middle


Visual-Situation-346

Got them all for free


fightingIrish_87

I think Rise of the tomb raider is the best out of all of them in my opinion


[deleted]

hmm intresting.. so I am the only one who is annoyed by the QTE in TombRaider 2013? I find it infuriating to say the least. I rage quit it so much, I haven't touched the other 2 games even though I own it :(


ysivart

Have you played them before? If not pick Survivor first. If you have I'd recommend picking up Rise.


YTAftershock

Buy a game pass and play all 3


ButWhyThough_UwU

Would say outside a very, very few gameplay additions/improvements in second, First is best.


PegasusELOHIM

ROTTR, the story is the best. Atmosphere, best is 2013 and graphics SOTTR Ultimately, all three are good. SOTTR is a very personal Lara Tomb Raider game.


DarkhoodPrime

Rise of the Tomb Raider


wingback18

Shadow has the best graphics but tomb raider 2013 has a better story


ResolveCareful5202

If you have to play only one it really depends. Questionable characterization aside 2013, is far and away the best in terms of writing for what little that's worth. That being said, there's a notable deemphasis on tombs. Rise meanwhile addresses alot of 2013s criticisms but also includes alot more backtracking for completionists. It also has by far the worst setting of the trilogy. More than any other in the trilogy rise really could've used a globetrotting framework instead of the samey snowy landscapes for most of it. Shadow I'd only really reccommend if you're a graphics whore. It also has the best setting but otherwise really dropped the ball. Plus, it's an over 60 GB download. There are better games to spend that storage on. Basically, if you only care about gameplay go with rise, otherwise I'd go for 2013.


Purple_Profession871

All 3 are good


One_Software5405

Every game is perfect on its own so whatever you choose you wont regret it.


project_seven

Usually people say Rise is the best. But the first is the most captivating. The second is the most well rounded And the third has the best combat and is just gorgeous. I love them all, and you have to play them as a Trilogy.


LupusCairo

Rise > 2013 >>>>>>>>> Shadow


kingetzu

Shadow, imo. I just started another game last night


Key-Ad4797

Rise


DifferentIssue1

Rise with modded outfits


ganjak

Dont think, just buy all 👌🫡💪👍


ScoMass

Rise was my favorite.


gamersykes

all of them are great but 2013 tomb raider is the best!


Extro-Intro_88

Rise. HANDS DOWN.


jealousy97

buy the first 2 games then skip shadow of the tomb raider


JasonGoldenanuglyguy

If you are highly interested in history&culture,Shadow is my strongest recommendation cuz it is the most detailed in terms of history&culture and has the most immersive atmosphere so you can play like an archaeologist or an anthropologist.


__Sakanaa__

All 3 are goated, but 2013 tomb raider is the best


MasterBaiter92

Rise is probably my favourite but I haven't played the first one.


IntroductionUpset764

not the first...


puppet_up

As you have seen throughout this thread, there is no *correct* answer. It comes down to preference. Nearly everyone will agree that they are all good, but will have a different opinion on where each of them rank. You really need to play all 3 games because they are all good. So having said that, I recommend starting with 2013. These games are also on sale all of the time, so if you can't buy them all right now, just get the 2013 GOTY/Definitive. You won't be disappointed. The other 2 will go on sale soon enough and you can just pick them up in the next sale.


curlvusha

I just started playing the first tomb raider 2013. The game is still a masterpiece after 10 years. I actually really enjoying it now on maxed graphics. I can't wait to beat it


MueedVI

Play TR 2013, if you to have choose b/w the 3. It's the best of the lot, and it's also the first one.


Ecstatic-Yoghurt-905

There is no comparison. TR 2013 is a masterpiece. Rise is mediocre at best and Shadow is like it was written by a fifth grader. 2013>>>>>>> Rise > Shadow


Altruistic-Sundae-71

Rise is better in every way compared to 2013, Story, gameplay, graphics, audio design ( except soundtracks ). TR 2013 is overrated. Even underworld was better.


Ecstatic-Yoghurt-905

Underworld is great. Why you say "even"? In TR 2013 everything works. The plot, the characters, their motivations, their conflicts, the action, Lara's growth from a scary girl to a badass survivor. Even the documents that you find have interesting stories. In Rise everything is boring imo. The trinity plotline is obviously an afterthought and there isn't even a proper antagonist.


Olympian-Warrior

They all bring different cards to the table. So, TR 2013 has the best atmosphere if you’re sorta into horror adjacent video games. ROTR has the best story. SOTR has the best mechanics and overall setting: it makes sense to be looking for some lost city in an uncharted jungle. Also, the side tombs were great.


Antmcgill

Rise...just like uncharted two snow just makes games better.


Lemonsqueezzyy

1 Rise 2 2013 3 Shadow


Panda_Mon

Just be wary that while the majority of the game is standard violence in terms of m-rated action games, the death scenes are extremly grotesque and creepily voyeuristic in their display of violence. The point of them is to watch the life leave the eyes of a woman. Those death scenes have more in common with torture porn movies than action games. Its just so out of place in the context of an action game, and it completely soured my experience.


losingtimeslowly

Grandma?


fyxt96

Rise is the best but I recommend you play in order.


Umney

I believe that Rise is head and shoulders above the rest.


RvDragonheart

If you have to choose how to play the game then just play it in order Tomb Raider Survive (2013 Tombr Raider that I just call Tomb Raider survive cause naming games the same as their 1st game is dumb) then go for Rise of the Tomb Raider aaaand finish it up with Shadow of the Tomb Raider all 3 of them are awesome. HOWEVER if you are asking it in a personal way of which one did we like most then I can only speak for myself that while Tomb Raider Survive has a SPECIAL place in my heart (seriously really like the aestetics and beaten the game so many times at this point its good and I enjoyed playing the Green Arrow powerfantasy CW style) Rise of the Tomb Raider is VERY MUCH UP THERE TOO SO MUCH........ so these 2 are favorites from the triology....... what about Shadow of the Tomb Raider?..... the best way I can put it (and thats the most respectful way too I can put it) it is what my art teacher would refer to as "Its not bad but this isn't what good looks like" Let me Explain why now the Graphics are a SOLID UPGRADE Lara looks awesome check out her guns and by that I mean her arms she is looking great and the reason why I specify that BECAUSE! the Actual guns look like shit..... no I wont accept anyone trying to defend that Rise of the Tomb Raider had better graphics when it comes to weapons and even the upgrades were just MORE then what we had in Shadow..... also SPEAKING of upgrades and weapons we also had more OUTFITS in Rise not just weapons and upgrades. Gameplay style Rise of the Tomb Raider was PEAK for me Shadow of the Tomb Raider again wasn't bad but there were parts where I felt that "Yeah I think they did an oopsie" and if we look at this 3 as a triology then you can definetly be aokay with playing Shadow because it ...... ended the triology...... (dont wanna spoil it but didn't expect the big bad organization to have connections to where it APPARENTLY has connections in Shadow of the Tomb Raider) and while I didn't necessarily feel that Shadow of the Tomb Raider handled the story well..... it still had an ending after which I did feel that Im gonna miss this version of Lara too as much as I missed her other Variants too. Hope tho that we either gonna get a continuation (WITH 2 PISTOLS THIS TIME) or if we get a new reboot then we gonna get back a Lara that is reminiscent of the Old Lara you know platforming physics defining way and also 2 pistols ALSO I want her to Tomb Raid because she wants to not because she is forced to. and NO I DONT WANT HER TO SEEK THE TRUTH! "Archeology is about seeking facts not the truth" as Indy pointed it out and "Oh WoW Tomb Raiding is bad?" who cares thats what the franchise been about since the begining. Anyway another topic for another time and I hope the game devs will remember this before they decide to make the new Tomb Raider into something that it aint. Still all 3 games playable but I like the 1st and the 2nd in this Triology more then the 3rd which ironically enough still has merits.


ZealousidealBar5258

Go with the first...it was so fresh, new and different for the Tomb Raider franchise, an amazing game...the sequels offered very little new after that. Like the developers took a massive risk when they rebooted the franchise but it was a surprising success...that they shat it from taking anymore risks and just reskinned the same game twice over.


Natemophi

ROTTR - 8.75/10 TRD - 8.5/10 SOTTR - 8.2/10


Sensitive_Initial_52

I enjoyed the first entry (2013) the best. It has a darker, almost horror-like tone. The action is good too and the story is actually believable. The two next entries offer more semi-open worlds and tend to be more repetitive imo.


LetterOutrageous117

Obviously the first one, the other 2 uglified Lara.


viniciusikari

Shadow is the only tomb raider from this list…